[W]e conclude that, if believed, any rational trier of fact could have found that Mr. Carlson knowingly caused or attempted to cause physical harm to the responding officers, and that he purposefully hampered or impeded the officers in the performance of their lawful duties, creating a risk of physical harm with the specific intention of preventing his removal.
State v. Carlson
Second District Appellate Court
Champaign County, Ohio
September 4, 2026
Why does Bob Meader believe this case is important?
State v. Carlson evaluated that law enforcement may use force to pink slip a person in a mental crisis. That mental crisis does not excuse the patient turned suspect from using force against law enforcement. Mr. Carlson feebly attempted to argue that he had an instinctive response to the deputy’s force. The Second District Court of Appeals rejected Mr. Carlson’s argument that his actions were merely instinctive reactions to an unprovoked police attack and affirmed his convictions for Assault on a Peace Officer and Obstructing Official Business. This decision reinforces that de-escalation does not guarantee compliance, a mental health crisis does not automatically excuse criminal conduct, and officers must be prepared to articulate the circumstances surrounding their decisions.

Background
On September 3, 2025, Mr. James Carlson was indicted for assault and obstruction. He was charged in relation to an altercation with sheriff’s deputies who responded to the home of Mr. Carlson’s parents on a report that he was experiencing a mental health crisis. A jury trial occurred on November 5, 2025, and the jury found Mr. Carlson guilty of both counts in the indictment. The trial court imposed concurrent prison sentences of 18 months for assault and 12 months for obstruction. The court also imposed concurrent fines of $250 on each count. Mr. Carlson timely appealed.
Mr. Carlson Alleges his Failure to Comply was the Fault of Law Enforcement
Mr. Carlson asserts three assignments of error. We consider his first two assigned errors together. He initially argues that his convictions were not supported by sufficient evidence. According to Mr. Carlson, “even viewing the evidence in a light most favorable to the State, it is plain that the State failed to prove that [he] had he requisite mental state to commit” assault and obstruction. He claims that law enforcement “escalated the situation by attempting to tase [him] and, failing that, immediately rushing to tackle him.” Mr. Carlson argues that he “had no time to think” and “reacted instinctively” in order to escape the “gang-tackle.”
Mr. Carlson Argues he was Compliant and Not Violent
As to the assault offense, Mr. Carlson argues that he “only struggled with the officers at the moment he was jumped by them” and did not act knowingly. He claims he “was compliant and did nothing improper or violent against any of the officers.” As to obstruction, Mr. Carlson again asserts that he was merely “reacting by instinct not by any planning, and as a result, not with any purpose,” and he claims he “could not be expected to react in any other way.” He analogizes his offense to an innocent bystander being charged with obstruction after being startled by a police officer in pursuit of a suspect on foot and bumping into the officer, thereby allowing the suspect to escape. According to Mr. Carlson, “[i]nstinctive reactions should not form the basis of an obstructing-official-business charge.”
Mr. Carlson Argues He Fought Back the Officers as it was an Unprovoked Attack
In his second assignment of error, Mr. Carlson argues that his convictions were against the manifest weight of the evidence. He claims, again, that he “simply fought back,” because he was “the subject of an unprovoked and unexpected attack.” He directs our attention to the testimony of Detective Brandon Dep. Fenwick, which he asserts “shows conclusively that [Mr. Carlson] did not initiate the struggle.” Mr. Carlson argues that the evidence was clear that he, “while in the throes of a mental health crisis, was attacked out of the blue by three officers in a darkened room after being unsuccessfully tased.” He asserts that “no reasonable jury could conclude” that he assaulted the officers or obstructed official business. He acknowledges that it is “unfortunate” that an officer was injured but argues that he should not be blamed.
Assault on a Police Officer
O.R.C. §2903.13 proscribes assault on a police officer and states in relevant part:
(A) No person shall knowingly cause or attempt to cause physical harm to another . . . . (C)(1) Whoever violates this section is guilty of assault . . . . Except as otherwise provided in division (C) . . . (5) . . . of this section, assault is a misdemeanor of the first degree. . . . (5) If the assault is committed in any of the following circumstances, assault is a felony of the fourth degree: (a) The victim of the offense is a peace officer . . . while in the performance of the officer’s . . . official duties.”
Knowingly
O.R.C. §2901.22(B) sets forth the definition of how and when a person acts knowingly: A person acts knowingly, regardless of purpose, when the person is aware that the person’s conduct will probably cause a certain result or will probably be of a certain nature. A person has knowledge of circumstances when the person is aware that such circumstances probably exist. When knowledge of the existence of a particular fact is an element of an offense, such knowledge is established if a person subjectively believes that there is a high probability of its existence and fails to make inquiry or acts with a conscious purpose to avoid learning the fact.
Obstructing Official Business
O.R.C. §2921.31 governs obstruction and states:
(A) No person, without privilege to do so and with purpose to prevent, obstruct, or delay the performance by a public official of any authorized act within the public official’s official capacity, shall do any act that hampers or impedes a public official in the performance of the public official’s lawful duties.
(B) Whoever violates this section is guilty of obstructing official business. Except as otherwise provided in this division, obstructing official business is a misdemeanor of the second degree. If a violation of this section creates a risk of physical harm to any person, obstructing official business is a felony of the fifth degree.
Purposely
“A person acts purposely when it is the person’s specific intention to cause a certain result, or, when the gist of the offense is a prohibition against conduct of a certain nature, regardless of what the offender intends to accomplish thereby, it is the offender’s specific intention to engage in conduct of that nature.” O.R.C. §2901.22 (A).
Mr. Cureton advised that Mr. Carlson was “off his rocker”
At trial, Deputy Brian Fenwick of the Champaign County Sheriff’s Office testified that on August 25, 2025, he was dispatched to an address on Apple Road on a report from Scott Mr. Carlson (“Scott”), Mr. Carlson’s father, that his son “was in a mental health crisis.” Dep. Fenwick stated that Cadet Adkins was with him, and Deputy Carnes also responded to the scene. Scott and Charles Cureton were outside the home when the officers arrived. Scott advised officers that Mr. Carlson “was acting crazy” and “turning off the electricity to the house and turning on the gas to the gas stove and [letting] it just go fill up the house with gas.” According to Dep. Fenwick, Scott was dependent on an oxygen tank 24 hours a day, and without electricity, his tank defaulted to a battery pack. Dep. Fenwick testified that Mr. Cureton advised that Mr. Carlson was “off his rocker” and had been carrying an “edged weapon,” like a hatchet or an axe.
Mr. Carlson speaking to what Dep. Fenwick believed to be a type of AI assistant.
The officers entered the home and spoke to Mr. Carlson’s mother, who was visibly upset. Mr. Carlson’s mother directed the officers to Mr. Carlson’s bedroom down a hallway. Dep. Fenwick stated that “my concern was getting eyes on the defendant” at that point. As Dep. Fenwick approached the bedroom, he heard Mr. Carlson speaking to what Dep. Fenwick believed to be a type of AI assistant. Dep. Fenwick said that Mr. Carlson was lying on his bed when he first observed him and that his bedroom was cluttered with “a lot of obstacles.” Dep. Fenwick was concerned that a weapon could be hidden in the room and also that officers might trip over the clutter if the situation were to escalate. Dep. Fenwick stated that Mr. Carlson did not want the officers to enter his room. Dep. Fenwick remained on the left side of the doorway in the hall “because when you’re dealing with somebody in a mental health crisis, giving them their distance is very important” to avoid adding to the person’s frustration.
Colorblind and Extraterrestrials
Dep. Fenwick spoke to Mr. Carlson, expressing safety concerns for his parents due to the reports of the gas being turned on and the electricity being turned off, especially given Scott’s need for oxygen. Dep. Fenwick testified that Mr. Carlson told him that the reported issue was “a family matter.” According to Dep. Fenwick, Mr. Carlson “wasn’t making much sense,” asking Dep. Fenwick if he was color blind and mentioning “extraterrestrials.” Dep. Fenwick stated that the bedroom light was not working, so he and Carnes were using flashlights. The beams of light from the flashlights bothered Mr. Carlson, so they directed the lights toward the wall on the right. Dep. Fenwick said that “we weren’t trying to agitate him.”
Repeated Attempts to De-Escalate
Dep. Fenwick stated that because Scott relied on oxygen to “stay alive” and was also a smoker, he did not perceive Mr. Carlson’s reported conduct in turning off the electricity and turning on the gas “as normal behavior.” Dep. Fenwick wanted “to get him help” in a hospital setting with a mental health professional. He testified that he spoke to Mr. Carlson for 15 to 20 minutes, and the “first half of the conversation was pretty cordial,” with Dep. Fenwick “trying to build a rapport with him to keep him calm and trying to explain to him . . . why I wanted him to go to the hospital to be evaluated.”
Mr. Carlson’s Repeated Failure to Comply
Dep. Fenwick stated that, over time, Mr. Carlson became agitated, with his tone of voice changing. He asked Mr. Carlson, “James, will you just please go to the hospital with us?” Dep. Fenwick stated, “We just want you to get checked out. I want to go peacefully.” According to Dep. Fenwick, Mr. Carlson then stood up, “clenched his fists,” and “flexed” his biceps and forearms in an aggressive manner, and it was “apparent that the agitation in him was . . . growing.” He described Mr. Carlson as “pretty muscular.” Dep. Fenwick indicated that Mr. Carlson “was just screaming ‘no’” and that Mr. Carlson “was going to blow his brains out.” Dep. Fenwick testified that he would not ask a suspect making such a threat if he had a gun, “because that . . . could prompt a response of him grabbing a gun, if a gun is present, and him blowing his head off.” Dep. Fenwick stated that he kept a calm demeanor, but Mr. Carlson kept clenching his fists.
Dep. Fenwick explained that based on his training, knowledge, and experience at the police academy and other trainings, he perceives that “when a person is clenching their fists, odds are they’re not wanting to give up.” Police policy dictated getting Mr. Carlson into custody safely, according to Dep. Fenwick.
Dep. Fenwick testified that if a person “is showing that they are a threat to themselves or a threat to others,” law enforcement officials have the authority to place the person on a mandatory mental health hold, known as a “pink slip.” He stated that although he initially attempted to give Mr. Carlson the choice to seek help, which “gives a better outcome than going in there and acting like a jerk,” it became apparent that Mr. Carlson “wasn’t going to go peacefully.” Several times Dep. Fenwick told Mr. Carlson to turn around with his hands behind his back in a calm tone of voice, but Mr. Carlson refused to comply.
Mr. Carlson is Tased
Dep. Fenwick “did not just want to go rushing into this bedroom,” but in the course of a “threat assessment” based on Mr. Carlson’s earlier reported possession of an edged weapon, the items cluttering the floor, and Mr. Carlson’s refusal to obey commands, Dep. Fenwick “opted to use [his] taser to disable him so that way we’d be able to take him into custody safely and get him to the hospital.” He testified that he was “trying to mitigate risk of injury to myself, my partners, and Mr. Carlson.” Dep. Fenwick stated, however, that upon deploying his taser at Mr. Carlson, rather than becoming disabled, Mr. Carlson remained standing and was twisting and turning.
Mr. Carlson Bites Dep. Fenwick’s Left Forearm
Dep. Fenwick and Carnes then entered the bedroom and grabbed Mr. Carlson, falling onto the bed with him. Dep. Fenwick lost his flashlight, the bedroom became “pitch black,” and he realized that Carnes had also lost his flashlight. Dep. Fenwick tried unsuccessfully to get a hold of Mr. Carlson’s arms, and he “felt [Mr. Carlson’s] mouth and his teeth” on his left forearm. Dep. Fenwick yanked his arm away, and Mr. Carlson began hitting him with a closed fist in his face and side of the head. Dep. Fenwick exchanged punches with Mr. Carlson in the struggle. He then felt Mr. Carlson’s mouth and teeth on his left hand and yanked it away. Dep. Fenwick felt Mr. Carlson’s “legs coming up” around his neck, feared he was going to be put in a choke hold, and called out to Carnes. Dep. Fenwick testified that if he had been alone and Mr. Carlson got his legs around his neck, “it would have resulted in a legal use of force.” Carnes and Adkins were able to gain control of Mr. Carlson’s legs while Mr. Carlson continued throwing punches. Dep. Fenwick testified he then applied a pressure point he learned at the police academy behind Mr. Carlson’s right ear. Mr. Carlson stated, “I’m done,” and stopped fighting. He was placed in handcuffs willingly, and EMS was called to evaluate him based on the use of the taser. Once outside, Mr. Carlson began moving his legs around, and he was briefly placed in shackles to prevent him from kicking the officers. The shackles were removed when “it was deemed that he was calm enough.”
EMS Treats Mr. Carlson
The St. Paris Fire Department responded, and taser probes were located in Mr. Carlson’s “left pec muscle” and left hand. The probes were removed, and Mr. Carlson was medically cleared by EMS personnel. Dep. Fenwick stated that he had hoped Mr. Carlson would choose to voluntarily go the hospital for a “pink slip” and evaluation. Although Dep. Fenwick repeatedly gave Mr. Carlson the opportunity to do so, after the altercation, he was arrested for obstruction and assault.
Dep. Fenwick is Injured
Dep. Fenwick sustained injuries to his arm, lip, shoulder, and behind his right ear. The injuries were photographed, and the photos were shown to the jury. Dep. Fenwick testified that he was still receiving treatment for his shoulder injury at the time of trial.
Dep. Carnes Testimony
Deputy Brian Carnes of the Champaign County Sheriff’s Office testified consistently with Dep. Fenwick regarding the incident. Carnes stated that while Dep. Fenwick stood in the doorway of Mr. Carlson’s bedroom, Carnes was behind Dep. Fenwick to Dep. Fenwick’s right, while Adkins was behind Carnes. He stated that Dep. Fenwick tried to “de-escalate the situation” and persuade Mr. Carlson to go to the hospital. After Mr. Carlson stated that he would “blow his head off,” Dep. Fenwick “told him it wasn’t optional anymore.” Carnes testified that Mr. Carlson clenched his fists, flexed his muscles, and stated that “we were going to have to make him go to the hospital.” Carnes stated that after Mr. Carlson ignored repeated instructions to turn around and place his hands behind his back, Dep. Fenwick tased Mr. Carlson without effect before the officers tackled him onto the bed. Carnes said that Mr. Carlson fought them—putting his legs around Dep. Fenwick’s neck, punching Dep. Fenwick, and trying to bite Dep. Fenwick.
Dep. Adkins Testimony
Finally, Deputy Amber Adkins testified that she was a cadet in the Sheriff’s Office on the date of the incident. She stated that Dep. Fenwick “tried to get James to go to the hospital voluntarily, explained that we just wanted to make sure everything was okay with him, and if everything was good, he would be released and he’d go about his day.” Consistent with Dep. Fenwick and Carnes, Adkins described the progression of Mr. Carlson’s agitation. She testified that she was initially behind Carnes and could not see into the room until Dep. Fenwick called out, and she followed Carnes into the bedroom. She said that Dep. Fenwick and Carnes dropped their flashlights during the incident, and the bedroom consequently became completely dark. During the struggle, Dep. Fenwick had control of Mr. Carlson’s upper body, Carnes was at the area of Mr. Carlson’s mid-body, and she tried to control Mr. Carlson’s legs, which Mr. Carlson attempted to put around Dep. Fenwick’s neck. Adkins stated that she was hit in the head by Mr. Carlson’s calf, knocking off her sunglasses.
Mr. Carlson completely mischaracterizes the record in suggesting that he was attacked without warning, triggering an “instinctive” reaction.
Having thoroughly reviewed the entire trial transcript and the wholly consistent testimony of the officers, we conclude that Mr. Carlson completely mischaracterizes the record in suggesting that he was attacked without warning, triggering an “instinctive” reaction. Dep. Fenwick made clear that his priority during Mr. Carlson’s mental health crisis was the safety of Mr. Carlson’s parents, the officers, and especially Mr. Carlson. He deliberately acted to prevent an escalation of events by remaining calm and giving Mr. Carlson multiple opportunities to agree to an evaluation in a peaceful manner. Dep. Fenwick acknowledged Mr. Carlson’s desire that officers not enter his room by maintaining a distance from him. In attempting to build rapport with Mr. Carlson and without commands, Dep. Fenwick explained to Mr. Carlson why he needed to go to the hospital, but Mr. Carlson declined to do so.
Mr. Carlson’s innocent bystander analogy fails; he initiated the struggle.
After a lengthy and calm effort by officers to assess and diffuse the situation, Mr. Carlson stood, clinched his fists, flexed his muscles, screamed “no,” refused commands to turn around, and threatened to “blow his brains out,” thereby at least suggesting the presence of a gun. Only after the incident had so escalated did Dep. Fenwick, relying on his training and experience, respond with his taser. He testified that he did so to mitigate any risk of injury to the officers and Mr. Carlson. At that moment, Dep. Fenwick was aware that Mr. Carlson had earlier carried an “edged weapon,” that Mr. Carlson was threatening, and that the clutter in the dark bedroom not only presented obstacles to the officers but also could have concealed a weapon. Contrary to Mr. Carlson’s assertion that he only struggled with the officers “at the moment he was jumped by them,” thereafter becoming compliant and nonviolent, he inflicted injuries on Dep. Fenwick by punching Dep. Fenwick in the face and head, biting Dep. Fenwick, and trying to put Dep. Fenwick in a choke hold. Dep. Fenwick sustained visible injuries, and the injury to his shoulder still required treatment at the time of trial. Mr. Carlson’s innocent bystander analogy fails; he initiated the struggle.
Mr. Carlson Acted Knowingly
After viewing the evidence in a light most favorable to the State, we conclude that, if believed, any rational trier of fact could have found that Mr. Carlson knowingly caused or attempted to cause physical harm to the responding officers, and that he purposefully hampered or impeded the officers in the performance of their lawful duties, creating a risk of physical harm with the specific intention of preventing his removal. Mr. Carlson’s concession that he “simply fought back” belies any suggestion that he did not act knowingly or with purpose, especially given Dep. Fenwick’s injuries. Mr. Carlson’s convictions are supported by sufficient evidence. Further, the jury clearly found the officers’ testimony credible, and we defer to the jury’s assessment of credibility. Because the jury did not lose its way and create a manifest miscarriage of justice, Mr. Carlson’s convictions are not contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence.
Accordingly, his first two assignments of errors are overruled.
Note: There was an additional appeal on the fine imposed. That appeal was also denied but is not evaluated in this article.
Conclusion and Holding
Mr. Carlson’s convictions for assault on a peace officer and obstruction are supported by sufficient evidence and are not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The court properly considered Mr. Carlson’s present and future ability to pay the concurrent fine imposed. Having overruled Mr. Carlson’s assignments of error, the trial court’s judgment is affirmed.
Information for this article was obtained from State v. Carlson, 2026 – Ohio – 3462.
State v. Carlson, 2026 – Ohio – 3462 was issued on September 4, 2026 by the Second District Appellate Court and is binding in the following Ohio counties: Champaign, Clark, Darke, Greene, Miami and Montgomery.
Lessons Learned
- Use of Force Standard – On May 15, 1989 the U.S. Supreme Court issued Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 (1989) and held that each use of law enforcement force will be evaluated by a three-part test:
- What was the severity of the crime?
- Immediate threat posed by the suspect?
- Was the suspect trying to flee or resist?
See: Graham v. Connor, Orange Juice, Homicide Bombers and the Objectively Reasonable Doctrine.
- Totality of the Circumstances – On May 15, 2025 the U.S. Supreme Court issued Barnes v. Felix, 605 U.S. 73 (2025) and the court held “As we have explained, a court cannot thus ‘narrow’ the totality-of-the-circumstances inquiry, to focus only a single moment. It must look too, in this and all excessive-force cases, at any relevant events coming before.”
See: When Does a Use of Force Analysis Begin?
- When is a Taser Deployment Objectively Reasonable? On September 11, 2025 the Sixth Circuit Appellate Court issued Feagin v. Mansfield, No. 24-3710 (6th, 2025) and the court explained when deploying is objectively reasonable: “Tasing is likewise appropriate for subduing a suspect who ‘actively resists’ arrest. What is ‘active’ resistance? Physical struggles with the police qualify. But so can conduct that is perhaps intuitively not all that active. For example, active resistance can take the form of ‘verbal hostility or a deliberate act of defiance’. Or it can include an arrestee refusing to move his hand for police to handcuff him, at least when ‘coupled with other acts of defiance’”. [citations omitted].
See: When is a Taser Deployment Objectively Reasonable?
- Was the Use of Force on Mr. Carlson Objectively Reasonable? Dep. Fenwick spent fifteen to twenty minutes with Mr. Carlson attempting to de-escalate him to get mentally evaluated under O.R.C. §5122.10 Emergency Hospitalization otherwise known as a Pink Slip. Mr. Carlson REPEATEDLY refused to comply and when the objectively reasonable force was used on him, Mr. Carlson violently resisted by biting Dep. Fenwick and wrapping his legs around Dep. Fenwick’s neck. Mr. Carlson’s feeble attempt to claim that his actions were instinctive reaction to law enforcement failed. The court did not independently evaluate the deputies’ use of force for objective reasonableness. However, it was implied as the deputies use force and Mr. Carlson’s Assault on a Police Officer charge was upheld.
- Use of Force to Pink Slip – On June 17, 2025 the Sixth Circuit Appellate Court held that use of force to pink slip a person in a mental health crisis who is actively violently is objectively reasonable. The court held “ Helm’s mental-health struggles did not bar the deputies from using the force required to get control of him and his resistance, even if that resistance sprang from his delusions.” Helms v. Boyd County Sheriff’s Department, No. 24 – 5853 (6th Cir., 2025). Consequently, law enforcement may use force to pink slip a person in a mental crisis if the person is violent.
- De–Escalation – De-escalation is a valuable tool for law enforcement to calm a situation with a person or persons who are agitated and preparing to be violent. There are many valuable classes, role plays and skills that can help officers resolve incidents without a use of force. However, de-escalation requires TWO PEOPLE – TWO! If a person is off their meds, on too many meds, impaired, mentally ill or some combination then it does not matter what skill level the officer has to de-escalate. If the person does not want de-escalated, then they will not be de-escalated. I make this statement from decades of attempting to de-escalate those who do not want de-escalated. In this case Dep. Fenwick, Dep. Carnes and Dep. Adkins attempted to de-escalate Mr. Carlson. However, since Mr. Carlson refused to comply, he was tased and even then – Mr. Carlson violently attacked the deputies. The trial court and appellate court rendered the correct decisions to hold Mr. Carlson accountable for Assault on a Police Officer and Obstructing Official Business.
Does your agency train on Pink Slipping?
Don’t fail your training.
Don’t let your training fail you!
Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!