Here, drugs were actually found on Mr. Fitzpatrick, and surrounding him on the floor was a torn baggie and crystal meth to where it appeared he attempted to destroy or render unusable at least some of the evidence when the SWAT team entered the residence. Further, the State introduced evidence that Mr. Fitzpatrick constructively possessed the drugs because a large quantity of the drugs were actually found in the room where he was located, and the circumstantial evidence showed Mr. Fitzpatrick knew they were there.

 

State v. Fitzpatrick

2026 – Ohio – 2523

Fourth District Appellate Court

Scioto County, Ohio

June 12, 2026

 

Why does Bob Meader think this case important?

State v. Fitzpatrick serves as an excellent roadmap for establishing constructive possession during the execution of a residential narcotics search warrant. The Fourth District reaffirmed that constructive possession requires more than simply finding a person inside a residence where drugs are located. Instead, officers must present evidence showing the suspect knowingly exercised dominion or control over the narcotics. In State v. Fitzpatrick that burden was met through a combination of drugs found on the defendant, narcotics and trafficking materials in plain view throughout the home, the layout of the residence, evidence that Mr. Fitzpatrick attempted to conceal narcotics, testimony from a confidential informant describing the home as a trap house and evidence that the residence served as an active distribution point for drug trafficking. 

Background

On September 13, 2023 law enforcement used a confidential informant to successfully conduct a controlled buy at 804 Campbell Avenue in Portsmouth. The next day, in addition to conducting surveillance on the Campbell Avenue residence, law enforcement executed a search warrant during which a large amount of suspected drugs, drug trafficking material, and drug paraphernalia were located throughout the residence. Present at the time of the execution of the warrant were the residents (Mr. Johnny Fitzpatrick and Brandi Bevins) and Michael Lewis and Tony Walker, who resided in Dayton.

Mr. Fitzpatrick was arrested inside 804 Campbell Avenue, Portsmouth. He testified that he did not aid and abet the ongoing narcotics sales inside the home.  Would the jury believe his testimony?

On October 3, 2023, Fitzpatrick, Bevins, Lewis, and Walker were indicted on nine counts, with counts one and two occurring on September 13, 2023, and counts three-nine occurring on September 14, 2023:

Count 1: Aggravated trafficking in drugs in violation of O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(1) and R.C. 2925.03(C)(1)(d), a second-degree felony;

Count 2: Aggravated possession of drugs in violation of O.R.C.§ 29525.11(A) and O.R.C. §2911(C)(1)(c), a second-degree felony;

Count 3: Aggravated trafficking of drugs in violation of O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(2) and O.R.C. §2925.03(C)(1)(d), a second-degree felony;

Count 4: Aggravated possession of drugs in violation of O.R.C. §2925.11(A) and O.R.C. §2925.11(C)(1)(c), a second-degree felony;

Count 5: Tampering with evidence in violation of O.R.C. §2921.12(A)(1) and O.R.C. §2921.12(B), a third-degree felony;

Count 6: Trafficking in cocaine in violation O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(2) and O.R.C. §2925.03(C)(4)(f), a first-degree felony;

Count 7: Possession of cocaine in violation of O.R.C. §2925.11(A) and O.R.C. §2925.11(C)(4)(e), a first-degree felony;

Count 8: Trafficking in a fentanyl-related compound in violation of O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(2) and O.R.C. §2925.03(C)(9)(f), a first-degree felony; and

Count 9: Possession of a fentanyl-related compound in violation of O.R.C. §2925.11(A) and O.R.C. §2925.11(C)(11)(e), a first-degree felony.

The indictment also contained a forfeiture specification in counts three, six, seven, eight, and nine for $2,355 in cash. Prior to trial, counts six and seven were amended to second-degree felonies.

Confidential Informant Made Controlled Buys

Mr. Fitzpatrick entered a not guilty plea and was tried before a jury along with co-defendant Ms. Bevins on September 16, 2024. At the trial, the State adduced evidence that the Southern Ohio Drug Task Force (“SODTF”) conducted a controlled buy from Mr. Lewis at the Campbell Avenue residence using a confidential informant. This confidential informant had purchased drugs at the same Campbell Avenue residence three or four times before. On September 13, 2023, the confidential informant entered the Campbell Avenue residence with buy money and a recording device provided by the SODTF and purchased what later tested as 29.23 grams of methamphetamine.

[A] sort of “convenience store” for drug activity.

The SODTF had received information that there were large amounts of drugs being sold at the Campbell Avenue residence, and also that people were seen coming and going from the residence. As the SODTF members and other witnesses described, the Campbell Avenue residence had the markings of a “trap house.” A “trap house” is a place where the residents have allowed various people to enter a residence for some benefit and the house then becomes a place for selling, using, and stashing drugs – a sort of “convenience store” for drug activity. The confidential informant, who testified, also characterized the Campbell Avenue residence as a “trap house.”

HGTV meets Trap House

The SODTF obtained a search warrant for the Campbell Avenue residence, a shotgun-style, single-family dwelling. On September 14, 2023, members of the SODTF began surveilling the residence about 7:00 a.m. and they executed the search warrant at 10:30 a.m. When entering the residence, SODTF realized from the design of the home, someone in the rear bedroom could see what was going on in the front room, and vice versa. The house had debris and trash throughout. In the kitchen, the SODTF saw Mr. Lewis. From the kitchen, they could also see Mr. Fitzpatrick seated on a chair in the living room. The SODTF found large amounts of a crystal-like substance (methamphetamine or its byproduct), scattered all over the floor in the living room. In fact, the drugs on the floor were so apparent that members of the SODTF did not have to get on their hands and knees to see them. The methamphetamine in the living room was spread around Mr. Fitzpatrick and on his person.

The SODTF found Mr. Walker and Ms. Bevins in the front room of the residence. They also found methamphetamine on the floor around where Ms. Bevins was located, but not on her person. The SODTF found syringes and a spoon near Ms. Bevins.

Narcotics, Paraphernalia and Cash was Everywhere

In addition to the drugs seen out in the open in several rooms of the house, law enforcement saw drug paraphernalia including syringes, bindles (papers used to package drugs), digital scales, a razorblade and credit card used for cutting and packaging drugs, cell phones, a bag full of numerous empty clear plastic capsules used for drug trafficking, baggies, and a large amount of lottery tickets folded into bindles. Law enforcement found a large amount of the bindles in both the living room and front room located near Mr. Fitzpatrick and Ms. Bevins. Law enforcement also found a torn plastic baggie in the room where Mr. Fitzpatrick was. In addition, law enforcement found a large amount of cash in excess of $2,300 on Mr. Lewis, including marked money from the controlled buy the day before.

Mr. Fitzpatrick said he resided there at the Campbell Avenue house.

During the search, Mr. Fitzpatrick said he resided there at the Campbell Avenue house. The State also introduced evidence of documents that were signed by Mr. Fitzpatrick showing his address as the Campbell Avenue residence.

Ms. Bevins admitted that she had agreed to let Mr. Lewis stay there if he would pay the water bill.

In an interview with law enforcement, Ms. Bevins said she had been living at the Campbell Avenue residence for approximately five months prior to the date of the search, that she had been dating Mr. Fitzpatrick for about three months prior to the search, and that both had resided at the Campbell Avenue residence. Ms. Bevins claimed that Mr. Lewis had initially pushed his way in the house at Campbell Avenue to sell drugs. However, testimony revealed that law enforcement received no calls that drug dealers pushed their way into Mr. Fitzpatrick’s home. Later, Ms. Bevins admitted that she had agreed to let Mr. Lewis stay there if he would pay the water bill. She claimed that she had received no money from Mr. Lewis because he had only arrived two days prior to the execution of the search warrant.

Promotional Giveaways with Prison Consequences

Ms. Bevins also said that when Mr. Lewis arrived, he initially had three softball-sized bags of drugs, which the SODTF explained was a large amount of drugs. Ms. Bevins said that a week prior to the search warrant Mr. Lewis sent his sister and a male named “DJ” to the Campbell Avenue residence to trap and sell drugs for a few days. Ms. Bevins said that when Mr. Lewis arrived, he sent text messages out to multiple individuals offering up free “testers” of drugs. Those free “testers” were in small, folded lottery tickets containing the tenth of a gram of drugs. The SODTF explained that this was Mr. Lewis’ attempt to build a client base. Ms. Bevins said that Mr. Walker was Mr. Lewis’ “assistant.” During the search, the SODTF members observed Ms. Bevins, Mr. Lewis, and Mr. Walker speaking to one another, back and forth.

Det. Metzler Explains the Narcotics Trade

At trial, Detective Metzler of the SODTF explained the course and scope of drug trafficking that the task force investigates. In particular, Det. Metzler described a source city where the drug originates (like Dayton, where Mr. Lewis and Taylor were from) being shipped to the destination city (like Portsmouth) where it is sold and used. Det. Metzler described the need for the task force to use confidential informants to stop distribution and sale. In addition, Det. Metzler described the street terminology for various drugs and their appearance. Finally, Det. Metzler explained that the “user amounts” of drugs are those in the range of a gram or two. However, due to the expense of the drugs, the task force sees the amounts of quarter pounds to pounds of the drug in the possession of those who are trafficking drugs.

Mr. Fitzpatrick Gave Out Free Testers

In addition to testimony from the confidential informant and members of the SODTF, the State also called to testify a male drug purchaser whose drugs of choice were cocaine and fentanyl. This drug purchaser testified he had purchased drugs from Mr. Lewis at the Campbell Avenue residence before (“a halfdozen times”), which the drug purchaser would describe as a “trap house.” This drug purchaser testified that Mr. Lewis gave out “free testers.”

This drug purchaser said that fentanyl and cocaine were out in the open and being sold there.

The day of the search warrant, the drug purchaser received a text from Mr. Lewis to come get a “test product” of cocaine and fentanyl at the residence. This drug purchaser went to get the product that day and testified that the people who lived in the Campbell Avenue residence were there when he smoked crack cocaine and injected fentanyl in the house, although he did not get the drugs off the residents. Another black male was also there. This drug purchaser said that fentanyl and cocaine were out in the open and being sold there. The SODTF came while the drug purchaser was there.

Further, the SODTF members testified that a female drug purchaser showed up during the search warrant with $10 on her person. This amount is enough to purchase a bindle of meth, which is the going rate for a tenth of a gram.

Bureau of Criminal Investigation Scientist Testified on Narcotics

The State presented testimony from the BCI Crime Lab forensic scientist regarding the identity and amounts of the following substances seized the day of the search: xylazine and fentanyl – less than .1 gram; methamphetamine – 9.09 grams; methamphetamine – 20.11 grams; cocaine – 7.77 grams; cocaine – 13.18 grams; methamphetamine – 7.85 grams; xylazine and fentanyl – 1.48 grams; xylazine and fentanyl – 1.78 grams; xylazine and fentanyl – 2.44 grams; xylazine and fentanyl – 14.22 grams; xylazine and fentanyl – .41 grams; methamphetamine – 1.23 grams; and methamphetamine – 5.8 grams. Some of these items were in separate paper folded lottery tickets (bindles) as if packaged for individual sale.

Motion to Suppress is Denied

At the close of evidence in the State’s case, Mr. Fitzpatrick and Ms. Bevins moved for Crim.R. 29 acquittal. Ms. Bevins made a general argument, but Mr. Fitzpatrick’s counsel argued that the State had only shown that Mr. Lewis was trafficking, but that Mr. Fitzpatrick was not complicit in the activities of Mr. Lewis. The trial court overruled the motions. During closing arguments, the State suggested that Mr. Fitzpatrick and Ms. Bevins were guilty of trafficking under a complicity theory.

When ‘Everyone Else Is Lying’ AND the ‘Drugs Jumped on Me’ Becomes the Defense

Mr. Fitzpatrick testified in his own defense. Mr. Fitzpatrick testified that he did not reside at the Campbell Avenue residence at the time of the search warrant or before, but only moved to the residence after the indictment. Though his testimony conflicted, he did admit that he stayed there at times. He said that Ms. Bevins must have been lying when she said that he had been living there the months before the search. Mr. Fitzpatrick denied he was in the Campbell Avenue residence when the buy took place on September 13. The day of the search, he claims that drugs were all over the place because Mr. Lewis threw them all over the place. He claimed that the drugs got on his person when the SWAT team ordered everyone to “get on the ground,” and he was put on the floor in the process of trying to arrest him. However, members of the task force claimed he was seated in a chair when they entered the residence. Mr. Fitzpatrick also claimed that he did not start seeing Ms. Bevins until after the offense, and that Ms. Bevins lied when she said he had been living there for the months leading up to the search. At trial, he said, “we didn’t let nobody in the house. Evidently, they went in without permission.” Mr. Fitzpatrick previously served more than seven years in federal prison for a carjacking conviction and also had a conviction for possession of drugs in Scioto County.

Guilty on ALL Counts and a Prison Term of 25-30 Years

The jury found Mr. Fitzpatrick guilty of all counts of the indictment. The trial court merged certain counts, and the State made election of offenses for sentencing. Ultimately, Mr. Fitzpatrick was convicted of counts one, three, five, six, and eight. For these offenses, Mr. Fitzpatrick was sentenced to 3 years on count one; 6 years on count three; 3 years on count five; 6 years on count six, and 10 to 15 years on count eight. The trial court ordered the sentences for counts one, three, six and eight to be served consecutively, and count five to be served concurrently to count one. Mr. Fitzpatrick’s total prison term consisted of 25-30 years. Mr. Fitzpatrick submitted a timely notice of appeal and raises two assignments of error.

Appeal – Evidence was Against the Manifest Weight of the Evidence

In his first assignment of error, Mr. Fitzpatrick contends that his convictions were not supported by sufficient evidence and were against the manifest weight of the evidence.

Count one of the indictment alleges that Mr. Fitzpatrick committed aggravated trafficking in drugs, pursuant to O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(1) and (C)(1)(d). Relevant to our discussion, O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(1) provides: “[N]o person shall knowingly * * * sell or offer to sell a controlled substance or a controlled substance analog.” R.C. 2901.22(B) defines the culpable state of “knowingly”:

A person acts knowingly, regardless of purpose, when the person is aware that the person’s conduct will probably cause a certain result or will probably be of a certain nature. A person has knowledge of circumstances when the person is aware that such circumstances probably exist. When knowledge of the existence of a particular fact is an element of an offense, such knowledge is established if a person subjectively believes that there is a high probability of its existence and fails to make inquiry or acts with a conscious purpose to avoid learning the fact.

Established Case Law – Aiding and Abetting

O.R.C. §2923.03(A)(2) states that “[N]o person, acting with the kind of culpability required for the commission of an offense, shall * * * [a]id or abet another in committing the offense.” “ ‘A conviction for aiding and abetting under R.C. 2923.03(A)(2) requires the state to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, “that the defendant supported, assisted, encouraged, cooperated with, advised, or incited the principal in the commission of the crime, and that the defendant shared the criminal intent of the principal.” ’ ” State v. Crumpton, 2024-Ohio-5064, ¶ 30 (4th Dist.), quoting State v. Smith, 2022-Ohio-371, ¶ 53 (4th Dist.), quoting State v. Johnson, 93 Ohio St.3d 240 (2001), syllabus. “ ‘ “Participation in criminal intent may be inferred from presence, companionship and conduct before and after the offense is committed.” ’ ” Id., quoting Johnson at 245, quoting State v. Pruett, 28 Ohio App.2d 29, 34 (4th Dist. 1971). Yet, “ ‘ “the mere presence of an accused at the scene of a crime is not sufficient to prove, in and of itself, that the accused was an aider and abettor.” ’ ” Id., quoting Johnson at 243, quoting State v. Widner, 69 Ohio St.2d 267, 269 (1982). “ ‘This rule is to protect innocent bystanders who have no connection to the crime other than simply being present at the time of its commission.’ ” Id.

Further, “[A] person’s mere association with a principal offender is not enough to sustain a conviction based on aiding and abetting; there must be some level of active participation by way of providing assistance or encouragement.” State v. Anderson, 2009-Ohio-2521, ¶ 25 (12th Dist.), citing State v. Mootispaw, 110 Ohio App.3d 566, 570 (4th Dist. 1996). “Criminal intent, however, can be inferred from the presence, companionship and conduct of a criminal defendant both before and after the offense is committed and may be proven by either direct or circumstantial evidence.” Id.; citing Mootispaw at 570, citing State v. McKnight, 2002-Ohio-1971, ¶ 23 (4th Dist.).

“‘We further observe that the complicity statute does not require the state to charge the defendant with complicity.’ ” Crumpton, 2024-Ohio-5064, ¶ 31 (4th Dist.), quoting Smith at ¶ 54. “ ‘Instead, R.C. 2923.03(F) allows the state to charge the defendant as a principal offender: “[A] charge of complicity may be stated in terms of [the complicity statute], or in terms of the principal offense.” ’ ”Id., quoting R.C. 2923.03(F).

Circumstantial evidence also showed that Mr. Fitzpatrick received a benefit of drugs as part of the payment for allowing Mr. Lewis to sell out of the home.

The State presented testimony that this offense occurred on September 13, 2023 at 408 Campbell Avenue, when Mr. Lewis sold approximately 29 grams (roughly an ounce) of methamphetamine. Mr. Fitzpatrick’s residence was 408 Campell Avenue and a trap house, where large amounts of drugs were being sold and people were coming and going at different times. It was the base of operation for the drugs sales, or a “convenience store” for drugs where a large amount of drugs were found and stored. The confidential informant and the officers described the buy at trial, and video evidence supported their testimony. While it is true that Mr. Fitzpatrick is not seen on the buy video, nor did the confidential informant testify to Mr. Fitzpatrick’s presence during that specific buy, it is also clear that Mr. Fitzpatrick knew full well that Mr. Lewis was selling drugs from his residence. His girlfriend and accomplice cooperated and encouraged Mr. Lewis by entering an agreement with Mr. Lewis for which she received a benefit (him agreeing to pay the water bill). Circumstantial evidence obtained during the execution of the search warrant also supports the jury’s finding of guilt regarding the controlled buy because the bulk of the drugs were actually found in the room where the task force found Mr. Fitzpatrick, and drugs were found on his person. He also attempted to hide or conceal, and was convicted of the tampering charge, which shows that he had knowledge of the criminal nature of the enterprise. Circumstantial evidence also showed that Mr. Fitzpatrick received a benefit of drugs as part of the payment for allowing Mr. Lewis to sell out of the home, because the State presented evidence that he was attempting to purchase a drug which assists with drug withdrawals (suboxone) when he was in the county jail awaiting trial.

The jury apparently did not believe Mr. Fitzpatrick’s testimony.

Mr. Fitzpatrick claimed that he did not aid or abet the principal offenders because he was supposedly staying at a motel in Wheelersburg. However, rather than mere association with Mr. Lewis, Mr. Fitzpatrick clearly had the culpability of the principal of the count one trafficking offense. The jury apparently did not believe Mr. Fitzpatrick’s testimony. Ms. Bevins told law enforcement that when Mr. Lewis arrived at her home, he had three softball-size bags of drugs, and that Mr. Lewis had sold drugs at her house within at least the past week. Ms. Bevins also said she knew he sent out “testers” or samples out to drug users. Evidence at the trial showed that both before and during the execution of the search warrant, at least two other people in addition to the confidential informant either purchased or attempted to purchase drugs from that location when Mr. Fitzpatrick was present. In fact, a purchase was made by a user who injected fentanyl and smoked crack cocaine in the residence while the residents were there. Thus, the State presented concrete evidence of three persons who had purchased or attempted to purchase drugs at the Campbell Avenue residence, and also that at least some of the persons were at the residence multiple times to purchase drugs.

Mr. Fitzpatrick and Ms. Bevins clearly provided a place in Portsmouth, described as a type of “convenience store,”

The State established that the principal actor involving count one was Mr. Lewis, who was from the Dayton area, which is a source city. The task force members also explained the course of trafficking where members from a source city seek out persons of a destination city (Portsmouth) to sell drugs. Mr. Fitzpatrick and Ms. Bevins clearly provided a place in Portsmouth, described as a type of “convenience store,” where Mr. Lewis could sell the drugs. In addition to providing the place to sell drugs, it is clear the drugs were kept in the residence where Mr. Fitzpatrick resided with Ms. Bevins. Ms. Bevins admitted she had agreed to allow the sale of drugs from her residence in exchange for Mr. Lewis’ promise to pay the water bill. Ms. Bevins admitted that she knew about Mr. Lewis selling from the home “a couple days before” and others selling drugs a week prior. Additionally, while the controlled buy occurred on September 13, the evidence obtained during the search warrant, and the testimony from the confidential informant and drug purchaser, constitute significant circumstantial evidence that Mr. Fitzpatrick knew about and provided a safe haven/locale for the drug business during the controlled buy of September 13.

Established Case Law – Complicity

Appellate courts have held that the providing of a place to sell and store drugs is sufficient involvement for a drug trafficking conviction. See, e.g., State v. Reid, 2012-Oho-5124, ¶ 41-42 (11th Dist.) (defendant guilty of drug trafficking when he rented the house where drug sale took place and police later recovered the drugs packaged for sale); State v. Kidd, 2007-Ohio-4113, ¶ 54 (11th Dist.) (where court held complicity instruction was proper because “[i]f for the sake of argument, [defendant’s] role in these activities were nothing more than allowing them to occur in the apartment, she could be found guilty of complicity”); State v. Scott, 2007-Ohio-303, ¶ 36-42 (5th Dist.) (complicity convictions supported by sufficient evidence where drug buys occurred at [the defendant’s] residence and drugs, paraphernalia, and firearms were found in her bedroom). Thus, even though the confidential informant did not see the Mr. Fitzpatrick on the day he purchased the drugs, the manifest weight of the evidence supports the jury’s finding that Mr. Fitzpatrick was complicit in the September 13 controlled buy.

September 14, 2023 – Counts Three, Six and Eight

Similarly, there is also substantial evidence that Mr. Fitzpatrick is guilty of counts three, six, and eight, under a complicity theory. He also claims he had no control over the residence or drugs and did not participate in the activity in any way. Mr. Fitzpatrick’s convictions related to these counts involve drug trafficking under O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(2). The definition of drug trafficking under O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(2). O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(2) states: “[N]o person shall knowingly * * * [p]repare for shipment, ship, transport, deliver, prepare for distribution, or distribute a controlled substance or a controlled substance analog, when the offender knows or has reasonable cause to believe that the controlled substance or a controlled substance analog is intended for sale or resale by the offender or another person.”

Established Case Law – Drug Trafficking

Ohio courts have held that a drug trafficking conviction under a complicity theory does not require that the accomplice offender possess the drugs, as long as the State proves the principal offender possessed the drugs incident to the trafficking. See, e.g., State v. McGowan, 2005-Ohio-1335 ¶ 18-22 (7th Dist.) (conviction upheld where the defendant provided transportation to facilitate a drug sale, even though he never possessed the drugs); State v. Wilcoxen, 2003-Ohio6061, ¶ 13 (2d Dist.) (evidence sufficient for drug trafficking under a complicity theory where defendant permitted the principal offender to carry on the drug sales from her home and shared in the proceeds of the sale); State v. Peavy, 2002-Ohio5067, ¶ 11, 27 (8th Dist.) (where court upheld a conviction for trafficking when defendant acted as a look out and was complicit to the drug trafficking even though he himself did not possess the drugs).

There is ample evidence that Mr. Fitzpatrick both constructively possessed and had actual possession over some of the drugs, as they were found on his person.

However, in the instant case, there is ample evidence that Mr. Fitzpatrick both constructively possessed and had actual possession over some of the drugs, as they were found on his person. Ample evidence shows Mr. Fitzpatrick was an accomplice to Mr. Lewis in the drug trafficking offenses related to the September 14, 2023 search warrant. Not only was he present during the sale to the male drug purchaser that day as well as when the female potential buyer showed up, he worked with Ms. Bevins to provide the trap house residence for the transaction.

Established Case Law – Constructive Possession

Possession “means having control over a thing or substance but may not be inferred solely from mere access to the thing or substance through ownership or occupation of the premises upon which the thing or substance is found.” O.R.C. §2925.01(K). “ ‘Constructive possession exists when an individual knowingly exercises dominion and control over an object, even though that object may not be within his immediate physical possession.’ ” State v. Carr, 2025-Ohio2583, ¶ 27 (4th Dist.), quoting State v. Hankerson, 70 Ohio St.2d 87, (1982), syllabus. “For constructive possession to exist, the state must show that the defendant was conscious of the object’s presence.” Id., citing Hankerson, 70 Ohio St.2d at 91; State v. Kingsland, 2008-Ohio-4148, ¶ 13 (4th Dist.). “Both dominion and control, and whether a person was conscious of the object’s presence, may be established through circumstantial evidence.” Carr at ¶ 28, citing State v. Foster, 2023-Ohio-746, ¶ 27 (4th Dist.) and State v. Brown, 2009-Ohio-5390, ¶ 19 (4th Dist.).

Mr. Fitzpatrick constructively possessed the drugs because a large quantity of the drugs were actually found in the room where he was located, and the circumstantial evidence showed Mr. Fitzpatrick knew they were there.

Here, drugs were actually found on Mr. Fitzpatrick, and surrounding him on the floor was a torn baggie and crystal meth to where it appeared he attempted to destroy or render unusable at least some of the evidence when the SWAT team entered the residence. Further, the State introduced evidence that Mr. Fitzpatrick constructively possessed the drugs because a large quantity of the drugs were actually found in the room where he was located, and the circumstantial evidence showed Mr. Fitzpatrick knew they were there. Not only were large quantities of various drugs found throughout the home where Mr. Fitzpatrick resided in amounts that exceeded personal use amounts, but a good quantity were wrapped for individual sale. In addition, these drugs were found in the common areas of the small residence sitting out in plain view. The testimony showed that one could see the drugs and actions of others in the home from one end of the residence to another. Mr. Fitzpatrick’s actions of trying to conceal or alter the evidence taken with the large amount of drugs throughout and found on his person shows his knowledge of the drugs and the activities going on in that house. In fact, there is circumstantial evidence from the large amount of bindles found in the small room where he was located that he may personally have been packaging or assisting with the inventory of the drugs themselves. The exhibit that shows the empty capsules used for drug packaging in the bathroom of the home and their location seems to link their presence more with the residents of the home, than with Mr. Lewis or Taylor. Thus, it is clear that Mr. Fitzpatrick possessed and prepared the drugs for sale, along with Mr. Lewis.

[W]hile some of these items could be typical household items, in this instance, they were not.

Further, the amounts of the drugs found is circumstantial evidence of drug trafficking, because “possession of a large quantity of narcotics is commonly recognized as significant circumstantial evidence of intent to distribute in narcotics.” State v. Robison, 2026-Ohio-1223, ¶ 34 (4th Dist.), citing 1 Wharton’s Criminal Evidence § 3:5 (15th ed.). “Possession of a large quantity of drugs, large amounts of cash, plastic baggies, and scales, among other indicia of trafficking, provide persuasive circumstantial evidence that tends to prove a violation of R.C. 2925.03(A)(2).” State v. Birdsong, 2024-Ohio-1744, ¶ 43 (11th Dist.), citing State v. Floyd, 2019-Ohio-4878, ¶ 32 (7th Dist.). In addition to the drug paraphernalia, individually packaged drugs, and drugs on the floor of the front room, in other areas of the house there were two scales, cell phones, credit cards and a razorblade for cutting drugs, lotto tickets used to bindle the drugs for individual sale, and a large amount of money found on Mr. Lewis in the kitchen. The bulk of the drugs, including those packaged for individual sale, was found in the room where Mr. Fitzpatrick was located. “It has long been established that otherwise innocuous objects such as bags, money, or cell phones can be used as criminal tools in drug trafficking and these items may constitute circumstantial evidence for drug trafficking.” State v. Cobb, 2024-Ohio-458, ¶ 17 (8th Dist.), citing State v. Hawthorne, 2016-Ohio-203, ¶ 21 (8th Dist.), citing State v. Bowling, 2010-Ohio3595, ¶ 60 (8th Dist.). Accordingly, while some of these items could be typical household items, in this instance, they were not.

[W]hat can be gleaned from Ms. Bevins’ statement is that more than one person was selling drugs from the Campbell Avenue residence.

Moreover, the State adduced testimony that at least three individuals had attempted or had bought drugs at the residence (conclusively twice when Mr. Fitzpatrick was there), as well as testimony from witnesses that the residence was a “trap house.” During trial the confidential informant said he had been to the house to purchase drugs three or four times, the male drug user said he had been there a half dozen times, and then another female drug purchaser showed up the day of the search. Additionally, what can be gleaned from Ms. Bevins’ statement is that more than one person was selling drugs from the Campbell Avenue residence. Task force members also explained to the jury the drug trafficking trade and such things as what would constitute personal use amounts for drugs, versus amounts found in trafficking operations.

Conclusion and Holding

In sum, our review of the record shows that the State adduced ample credible evidence to sustain the convictions. We do not believe that the evidence weighs heavily against Mr. Fitzpatrick’s convictions, under a theory of complicity for count one and clearly under a theory of complicity for counts three, six, and eight. We therefore overrule Mr. Fitzpatrick’s first assignment of error.

Note: There was a second appeal on Mr. Fitzpatrick consecutive sentences.  This appeal was also denied but is not evaluated in this article.

Information for this article was obtained from State v. Fitzpatrick, 2026 – Ohio – 2523.

State v. Fitzpatrick, 2026 – Ohio – 2523 was issued by the Fourth District Appellate Court on June 12, 2026 and is binding in the following Ohio Counties: Adams, Athens, Gallia, Highland, Hocking, Jackson, Lawrence, Meigs, Pickaway, Pike, Ross, Scioto, Vinton and Washington.

Lessons Learned

Aid and Abet – Mr. Fitpatrick argued that he was staying in a motel in Wheelersburg, West Virginia and therefore he was not involved in the drug trade.  On February 19, 1982 the Supreme Court of Ohio held “[M]ere presence of an accused at the scene of a crime is not sufficient to prove, in and of itself, that the accused was an aider and abettor.”.  State v. Widner, 69 Ohio St.2d 267 (1982) Therefore a person’s mere presence inside an operational narcotics trade base is not sufficient to successfully prosecute the person for aiding and abetting drug sales.  Here, Mr. Fitzpatrick drugs were found on his person, scattered around his chair, in plain view throughout the residence, and evidence indicated he attempted to destroy or conceal narcotics as officers entered. Those facts demonstrated both knowledge and control.  Additionally, the court explained “During the search, Mr. Fitzpatrick said he resided there at the Campbell Avenue house. The State also introduced evidence of documents that were signed by Mr. Fitzpatrick showing his address as the Campbell Avenue residence.”.  These factors established Mr. Fitzpatrick aided and abetted narcotics sales.

Constructive Possession – The Constructive Possession doctrine was founded by the Supreme Court of Ohio on May 19, 1982. That court established a two-part Constructive Possession test; 1) When an individual knowingly exercises dominion and control over an object, even though that object may not be within his immediate physical control; 2) The defendant was conscious of the object’s presence. State v. Hankerson, 70 Ohio St.2d 87 (1982). The most challenging element is to prove that the person was conscious of the object.  Here the court explained “The house had debris and trash throughout. In the kitchen, the SODTF saw Mr. Lewis. From the kitchen, they could also see Mr. Fitzpatrick seated on a chair in the living room. The SODTF found large amounts of a crystal-like substance (methamphetamine or its byproduct), scattered all over the floor in the living room. In fact, the drugs on the floor were so apparent that members of the SODTF did not have to get on their hands and knees to see them. The methamphetamine in the living room was spread around Mr. Fitzpatrick and on his person.”.  One does not have to go to Constructive Possession school to establish that Mr. Fitzpatrick constructively possessed narcotics in 408 Campbell Avenue, Portsmouth, Ohio.

Mr. Fitzpatrick’s Testimony – Criminal defendants have a constitutional right not to testify and most do not. However, Mr. Fitzpatrick elected to take the stand while facing decades in prison. His testimony attempted to distance himself from the drug trafficking operation by denying he lived at the residence, claiming others lied about his involvement and asserting that the methamphetamine found on his person only got there after officers forced him to the floor during the execution of the search warrant.  This fact was refuted by the entry team.

The jury, however, was not required to believe his explanation. His testimony conflicted with other witnesses, physical evidence and his own admissions that he stayed at the residence. The appellate court noted that “the jury apparently did not believe Mr. Fitzpatrick’s testimony.”

State v. Fitzpatrick is a reminder that physical evidence has more credibility and impact than a defendant’s self-serving testimony. Thoroughly documenting the location of contraband, photographing the scene before evidence is moved, recording statements and carefully documenting the defendant’s actions during the execution of a search warrant can significantly undermine later attempts to explain away incriminating evidence. Here, the drugs surrounding Mr. Fitzpatrick, narcotics found on his person, the trafficking paraphernalia throughout the residence and testimony from multiple witnesses provided the jury with ample reason to reject his version of events. All of these factors led to the community being safer for the next twenty-five years.

Pre-Sent Arms – The Southern Ohio Drug Task Force [SODTF], Detective Metzler, the other unidentified detectives of the SODTF and the Scioto County Prosecutor’s Office should be highly commended for the investigation, arrest, search, prosecution and successful appeal defense of Mr. Fitzpatrick.  Well done!

Does your agency train on the Constructive Possession Doctrine during Search Warrant Execution?

Don’t fail your training.

Don’t let your training fail you!

Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!

Robert H. Meader Esq.