We find the jury did not lose its way in finding the State proved beyond a reasonable doubt Mr. Capps did not act in self-defense, defense of another, or defense of residence.

 

State v. Capps

2026 – Ohio – 1185

Fifth District Appellate Court

Perry County, Ohio

March 31, 2026

Why is this case important?

State v. Capps is important because it reinforces that deadly force inside the home is not automatically justified under Ohio’s Castle Doctrine or stand-your-ground law—the threat must still be immediate and proportionate. The fact that his adult daughter was walking away and shot in the back from a significant distance undermined the self-defense claim and demonstrated that the danger had passed. Ultimately, Capps demonstrates that the legality of force is evaluated at the exact moment it is used, not by the chaos leading up to it.

Background

On August 30, 2024, the Perry County Grand Jury indicted Mr. Donald Capps on one count of felonious assault, in violation of R.C. 2903.11(A)(2), a felony of the second degree; and one count of felonious assault, in violation of R.C. 2903.11(A)(1), a felony of the second degree. Each count carried an attendant firearm specification pursuant to R.C. 2941.145. Mr. Capps appeared before the trial court for arraignment on September 12, 2024, and entered a plea of not guilty to the charges. On October 16, 2024, Mr. Capps filed a Notice of Self-Defense, advising he would be presenting evidence to establish at the time of the offense he was acting in self-defense or defense of others.

The matter proceeded to jury trial on May 29, 2025. The following evidence was adduced at trial.

Domestic Dispute from Property Damage to Shooting

At approximately 4:40 p.m. on July 13, 2024, Teresa Bly, Mr. Capps’s wife, called 9-1-1 and advised the operator Toni Capps, their daughter, was attempting to get into the residence and had broken three windows in the process. Ms. Bly called 9-1-1 a second time and told the operator Ms. Capps had broken another window. Ms. Bly also indicated Ms. Capps was on the ground, bleeding. Because officers were delayed in responding, Perry County Sheriff’s Office dispatcher Stacie Hinkle contacted Ms. Bly at 4:53 p.m. for an update on the situation. At 4:57 p.m., Mr. Capps called 9-1-1, stating he had shot his daughter because she had broken a fifth window.

Upon Arrival of Deputies they Heard a Shotgun Rack Twice

Deputy Austin Wamack with the Perry County Sheriff’s Office was field training with Sergeant Aaron Wolfe when they were dispatched to Mr. Capps’s residence at 7267 State Route 345, New Lexington. As the officers approached the residence, they “heard a shotgun rack twice.” The officers then observed Ms. Capps lying on the ground and Mr. Capps standing on a ladder, holding a shotgun. Deputy Wamack provided medical attention to Ms. Capps, who was unconscious, until EMS arrived.

Mr. Donald Capps shot his daughter Ms. Toni Capps after she broke windows at his home 7267 State Route 345, New Lexington, Ohio.  Was the shooting reasonable or criminal?

Officer Miller Renders Aid to Ms. Capps

New Lexington Police Officer Brianna Miller was also dispatched to Mr. Capps’s residence on July 13, 2024. Officer Miller was advised a female was breaking windows at the house, the situation had escalated, and the female had been shot. Upon arriving at the scene, Officer Miller saw Mr. Capps had been detained and proceeded to help administer first aid to the female.

Mr. Capps Becomes Agitated for Being Detained After Shooting his Daughter

Sergeant Aaron Wolfe responded to Mr. Capps’s residence with Deputy Wamack. When the officers arrived at the scene, Sergeant Wolfe heard the unloading of a pump action shotgun. Sergeant Wolfe and Deputy Wamack made their way around the side of the house and immediately observed Toni Capps lying on the ground “with an obvious birdshot wound to the left side of her body, the back.” Sergeant Wolfe asked Mr. Capps what was going on. Initially, Mr. Capps responded appropriately, but quickly became agitated and had to be detained.

Evidence Technician Collects Evidence

Perry County Sheriff’s Office evidence technician Dana Wilson was called to the scene. Wilson collected a 20-gauge shotgun, a spent shotgun shell, wadding from the shell, two unused 20-gauge rounds, and a bottle of water. Wilson located blood in different areas around the property, including beyond the tree line on the side yard, inside the laundry room, and on the broken window leading into the laundry room. She also located a 2 x 4 board under a broken window. Wilson photographed the scene and each piece of evidence in its location at the scene.

Crawl Towards the Bottle of Water

Callie Baker was asleep on the couch when her boyfriend woke her up after hearing shots coming from across the street. Ms. Baker and her boyfriend watched from an upstairs window as the events unfolded. Ms. Baker observed Mr. Capps holding a gun and his daughter laying on the ground in the yard. Toni Capps was crawling around, asking for help and water. Ms. Baker heard Mr. Capps tell Ms. Capps he had called for help and to crawl toward the water bottle he had thrown in the opposite direction. Ms. Capps crawled toward the house. Mr. Capps continued to hold the gun.

Pictures from Across the Street

Ezra Dupler was upstairs in the home he shared with Ms. Baker when he heard what sounded like something breaking. Mr. Dupler proceeded downstairs. When he reached the landing, he looked out the front window and saw a female on the ground and Mr. Capps, holding a shotgun, standing over her. The female was laying “right beside the road, kind of in between the two trees that were in the yard.” Mr. Dupler took a photo of the female on the ground, which was time-stamped 4:42 p.m. Mr. Dupler continued to watch and observed the female crawl toward the house, coming to rest by a large tree. Mr. Dupler took another photo, which was time-stamped 4:57 p.m. Mr. Dupler heard the female ask for help and water. Paramedics arrived soon thereafter.

Three to Four Alcoholic Drinks – A Punch to the Face and a Retaliatory Bite

Toni Capps lived in a camper on the State Route 345 property owned by her parents, Mr. Capps and Ms. Bly. Ms. Capps was working at the Panther, a restaurant in New Lexington, Ohio, on July 13, 2024. Ms. Capps had consumed three of four alcoholic beverages, but did not feel impaired. She did, however, not feel well and had Mr. Capps and Ms. Bly pick her up early. An argument ensued between Ms. Capps and her parents during the ride home. When they arrived at 7267 State Route 345, Ms. Capps intended to get her daughter, who was in the house, and return to their camper to settle in for the evening. Mr. Capps and Ms. Bly would not allow Ms. Capps to see her daughter. The argument escalated. Ms. Bly punched Ms. Capps in the face, forced her to the ground, and continued to punch her in the face. Ms. Capps bit Ms. Bly in order to get Ms. Bly off of her. Ms. Bly retreated into the house.

She did not attack or threaten Mr. Capps while she was breaking the windows.

Ms. Capps “was still really upset and [she] wanted [her] daughter.” She picked up a 2 x 4 board and started breaking out windows. Ms. Capps broke the window on the back door and entered the house through the window. However, an interior door was locked and she was not able to get further into the house. Ms. Capps exited through the back door window and resumed breaking more windows. After breaking a window on the west side of the house, Ms. Capps turned, threw the 2 x 4 board, and started to walk away. As she was walking away, Mr. Capps shot her in the back. Ms. Capps underwent surgery to remove the BBs from her kidneys, but because of the number, doctors were unable to remove all of the BBs. She did not attack or threaten Mr. Capps while she was breaking the windows.

Mr. Howard opined Mr. Capps was 40 feet, plus or minus 6 inches, from Ms. Capps when he shot her.

Steven Howard, a shooting incident and reconstruction expert and investigator, was retained by the State. As part of his investigation, Howard examined Ms. Capps’s injuries and measured the size of the shotgun pellet pattern on her body. Ms. Capps was struck on the left side, just below her shoulder blade, and down to her hip. The pattern measured approximately 15 inches. According to Mr. Howard, a shot will spread out one inch for every 3 feet it travels. As such, the 15-inch pattern indicates a starting point of approximately 45 feet. Using the exact gun and ammunition, Mr. Howard opined Mr. Capps was 40 feet, plus or minus 6 inches, from Ms. Capps when he shot her.

Convicted and Sentenced Six to Nine Years

After hearing all the evidence and deliberating, the jury found Mr. Capps guilty of two counts of felonious assault and the attendant firearm specifications. Mr. Capps appeared before the trial court for sentencing on June 23, 2025. The State elected to have Mr. Capps sentenced on Count 1 of the Indictment. The trial court sentenced Mr. Capps to an aggregate minimum term of imprisonment of six years to a maximum term of nine years.

In his fifth assignment of error, Mr. Capps challenges his conviction as against the manifest weight of the evidence.

Note: There were six appeals and all were upheld by the Fifth District Appellate Court.  I will only evaluate one of the appeals in this article.

Mr. Capps Alleges He Shot his Daughter – Toni Capps in Self Defense

Mr. Capps posits the State failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt Mr. Capps did not act in self-defense, defense of another, or defense of residence. Mr. Capps continues the State failed to establish Mr. Capps was at fault in creating the situation which gave rise to the affray and failed to establish Mr. Capps did not have reasonable grounds to believe and an honest belief, even if mistaken, he or his residence was in imminent or immediate danger of harm from Toni Capps.

Ms. Capps intended to get her daughter, who was in the house, and return to their camper.

We find the evidence presented at trial belies Mr. Capps’s position. Mr. Capps and Ms. Bly picked up Ms. Capps from her place of employment. On the drive home, an argument ensued between Ms. Capps and her parents. When they arrived at their residence, Ms. Capps intended to get her daughter, who was in the house, and return to their camper. Mr. Capps and Ms. Bly would not allow Ms. Capps to see her daughter. The argument escalated. Ms. Bly punched Ms. Capps in the face, forced her to the ground, and continued to punch her in the face. Ms. Capps bit Ms. Bly in order to get Ms. Bly off of her. Ms. Capps was admittedly “still really upset and [she] wanted [her] daughter.” She picked up a 2 x 4 board and started breaking out windows. After breaking a number of windows, Ms. Capps turned, threw the 2 x 4 board, and started to walk away.

As she was walking away, Mr. Capps shot her in the back. She had not attacked or threatened Mr. Capps or Ms. Bly while she was breaking the windows.

Conclusion and Holding

The jury was free to accept or reject any or all of the evidence offered by the parties and assess the witnesses’ credibility. Indeed, the jurors need not believe all of a witness’ testimony, but may accept only portions of it as true. State v. McGregor, 2016- Ohio-3082, ¶ 10 (5th Dist.). “While the jury may take note of the inconsistencies and resolve or discount them accordingly * * * such inconsistencies do not render defendant’s conviction against the manifest weight or sufficiency of the evidence.” We find the jury did not lose its way in finding the State proved beyond a reasonable doubt Mr. Capps did not act in self-defense, defense of another, or defense of residence. We further find the judgment of conviction was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.

Mr. Capps’s fifth assignment of error is overruled.

Information for this article was obtained from State v. Capps, 2026 – Ohio – 1185.

State v. Capps, 2026 – Ohio – 1185 was issued by the Fifth District Appellate Court on March 31, 2026 and is binding in the following Ohio Counties: Ashland, Coshocton, Delaware, Fairfield, Guernsey, Holmes, Knox, Licking, Morgan, Morrow, Muskingum, Perry, Richland, Stark and Tuscarawas.

Lessons Learned

  1. Self Defense Doctrine – In order for a person to claim self-defense his behaviors must comport with a three-part test established by the Supreme Court of Ohio in 1979: (1) Defendant was not at fault in creating the situation giving rise to the affray, (2) Defendant had reasonable grounds to believe and an honest belief even if mistaken that he was in imminent danger of death or great bodily harm and that he did not use more force than necessary to defend against the attack, and (3) Defendant must not have violated any duty to retreat or avoid the danger. State v. Robbins, 58 Ohio St.2d 74, 79 (1979). The third element was modified on April 6, 2021 by the state legislature when it updated O.R.C. §2901.09 (B) the Self-Defense statute [often called Stand Your Ground law] that states in pertinent part “[A] person has no duty to retreat before using force in self-defense, defense of another, or defense of that person’s residence if that person is in a place in which the person lawfully has a right to be.”.  In this case, Mr. Capp could reasonably argue he did not create the situation giving rise to the affray.  However, the Fifth District Appellate Court determined that Mr. Capps did not meet.  The expert witness Mr. Howard determined and the jury agreed that Ms. Toni Capps was walking away from the home at the time she was shot by her father.  Therefore, Mr. Capps did not establish that “[H]e was in imminent danger of death or great bodily harm and that he did not use more force than necessary to defend against the attack.”
  2. Was the Castle Doctrine a Reasonable Defense?  No.  On April 6, 2021 O.R.C. §2901.05(B)(1) became effective “A person is allowed to act in self-defense, defense of another, or defense of that person’s residence. If, at the trial of a person who is accused of an offense that involved the person’s use of force against another, there is evidence presented that tends to support that the accused person used the force in self-defense, defense of another, or defense of that person’s residence, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused person did not use the force in self-defense, defense of another, or defense of that person’s residence, as the case may be.”.  This is commonly called the Castle Doctrine where a person is permitted to use force to defend their home from an intruder.  In this case, though Ms. Toni Capps was busting out windows of her parents’ home – at the moment she was shot – she was walking away from the home.  Consequently, Ms. Toni Capps was not attempting to enter the home at the moment her father shot her.  The fact that this was a chaotic scene does not justify the use of deadly force.
  3. Hardest Job In America – Domestic disputes can often turn violent and in some instances deadly.  When the deputies arrived they heard a shotgun being racked.  Your officer safety should be of the highest priority on domestic calls for service and this incident where a father shot his daughter over broken windows is the latest example.
  4. Pre-Sent Arms!  Perry County Sgt. Aaron Wolfe, Deputy Austin Wamack, New Lexington Police Officer Brianna Miller, Perry County Sheriff’s Office Evidence Technician Dana Wilson and the Perry County’s Prosecutor’s Office should all be highly commended for responding, investigating, prosecuting and successfully defending the appeal of Mr. Capps.  Well done!

Does your agency train on the Self Defense Doctrine?

Don’t fail your training.

Don’t let your training fail you!

Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!

Robert H. Meader Esq.