Mr. Godschild was charged and tried in the county where victim lived and where she received the email … Therefore, the trial court did not err.
State v. Godschild
Ninth District Appellate Court
Medina County, Ohio
November 10, 2025
Why is This Case Important?
State v. Godschild clarifies the application of venue rules in Ohio for crimes involving electronic communications, particularly violations of Civil Protection Orders. In an era where digital interactions are common, Godschild addresses how courts handle indirect contact via email or similar means, where the offender sends messages to third parties with the reasonable expectation that the electronic communication will reach the protected individual.
Background
Defendant-Appellant Taurean Godschild appeals the judgment of the Medina County Court of Common Pleas finding him guilty of violating a protection order arguing the court lacked venue and sentencing him on this offense. For the following reasons, this Court affirms.
Civil Protection Order – Contact with Protected’s Sister
This matter arises from an event that transpired after P.S. obtained a civil protection order against Mr. Godschild that was later extended. The protection order prohibited Mr. Godschild from initiating or having any contact with P.S., either directly or “through another person.” While the active protection order was in place, Mr. Godschild sent an email to P.S.’s sister that was subsequently forwarded to P.S.

AI rendition of Mr. Godschild’s Protection Order
Indicted
The Medina County Grand Jury indicted Mr. Godschild on one count of violating a protection order in violation of O.R.C. §2919.27(A)(1)/(B)(3)(c), a felony of the fifth degree. Mr. Godschild pleaded not guilty to the charge and the matter proceeded to a jury trial.
Victim Arrives at Brunswick Police
Officer Daniel Leone testified at trial that he was working his usual shift as a City of Brunswick police officer when P.S. came into the police department with questions about “a potential protection order violation.” He verified that P.S. had an active protection order against Mr. Godschild. P.S. was previously married to Mr. Godschild and they have two children together. P.S. showed Officer Leone the email that Mr. Godschild sent to her sister. The sister had forwarded the email to P.S.
Sister Received the Email in Brunswick and Forwarded the Email
P.S.’s sister testified that she was surprised to receive the email from Mr. Godschild and that she was aware of the existing protection order. The sister interpreted the email as threatening in nature and she immediately called P.S. to tell her about the email. P.S.’s sister was at her home in Akron when she received Mr. Godschild’s email. The sister forwarded the email to P.S. who was in Brunswick. P.S. testified that she was in Medina County, Ohio when she received the forwarded email from her sister.
Seventy-Six Recipients of the Email
Mr. Godschild had blind carbon-copied (“BCC’d”) 76 individuals on the e-mail. Those who were BCC’d on the email included P.S.’s aunts and cousins, Mr. Godschild’s mother and father, and Mr. Godchild’s past associates and friends.
Mr. Godschild did not testify at trial or call any witnesses to testify on his behalf.
Mr. Godschild Moved for Dismissal Due to Lack of Jurisdiction
Mr. Godschild moved for dismissal pursuant to Crim.R. 29 at the close of the State’s case in chief, arguing that he “doe[s] not believe jurisdiction has been established” He “renew[ed] [his] Rule 29 motion based on lack of jurisdiction” after the jury returned a guilty verdict, again asserting that “[t]here was no evidence that the crime happened in Medina County[.]” The trial court denied Mr. Godschild’s Crim.R. 29 motions.
Jury Verdict – Guilty
The jury found Mr. Godschild guilty of violating a protection order as charged in the indictment. The trial court adopted the jury’s verdict and sentenced Mr. Godschild to ten months in prison with credit for time served. Mr. Godschild appeals the judgment of the trial court asserting two assignments of error for this Court’s review.
Appeal – Was Proper Venue Established?
Mr. Godschild argues in his first assignment of error that the trial court erred in denying his Crim.R. 29 motion. Specifically, he argues that the State failed to establish venue by a sufficiency of the evidence at trial. We disagree.
Established Case Law – Venue
Although venue is not an element of an offense, “it is a fact that must be proved at trial beyond a reasonable doubt, unless it has been waived by the defendant” State v. Foreman, 2021-Ohio-3409, ¶ 13; State v. Young, 2017-Ohio-1400, ¶ 13 (9th Dist.). “When a defendant challenges the sufficiency of the evidence demonstrating venue, this Court assesses the evidence to determine whether such evidence, if believed, would convince the average mind that venue was proper in the county in which it was held.” State v. Reinhardt, 2009-Ohio-1297, ¶ 15 (9th Dist.). This Court reviews the evidence in the light most favorable to the prosecution when making this determination. Id. “‘In essence, sufficiency is a test of adequacy.’” Id., quoting State v. Thompkins, 78 Ohio St.3d 380, 386 (1997).
[T]hat the defendant committed the alleged offense or an element of the offense in the charging county.
To establish venue, the State must prove “that the defendant committed the alleged offense or an element of the offense in the charging county.” Foreman at ¶ 13. Venue can be established by direct or circumstantial evidence. Id.; State v. Headley, 6 Ohio St.3d 475, 477 (1983). A conviction must be reversed if venue has not been established. Foreman at ¶ 31.
Where was P.S. Sister When the Email Arrived?
Mr. Godschild’s sole argument in his first assignment of error is that the trial court erred in denying his Crim.R. 29 motion because there was insufficient evidence to establish venue in Medina County, Ohio. He contends that “the State never proved that any element of the offense occurred in Medina County.” The State argued that it established venue at trial and it points to P.S.’s trial testimony that “she received the e-mail while she was in Medina County.”
[T]he offender may be tried in any jurisdiction containing any location of the computer.
Ohio’s venue laws are codified in O.R.C. §2901.12. Because Mr. Godschild was charged with violating a protection order based on an email that was sent, O.R.C. §2901.12(I)(1) is applicable. O.R.C. §2901.12(I)(1) states: When the offense involves a computer, computer system, computer network, telecommunication, telecommunications device, telecommunications service, or information service, the offender may be tried in any jurisdiction containing any location of the computer, computer system, or computer network of the victim of the offense, in any jurisdiction from which or into which, as part of the offense, any writing, data, or image is disseminated or transmitted by means of a computer, computer system, computer network, telecommunication, telecommunications device, telecommunications service, or information service, or in any jurisdiction in which the alleged offender commits any activity that is an essential part of the offense.
The sister testified that she received the email while at home in Akron and that she forwarded the email to P.S. in Brunswick.
Mr. Godschild has not disputed that he sent the email while a valid order of protection was in place and that P.S. is a protected party under the protection order. Further, Mr. Godschild has not disputed that he sent the email to P.S.’s sister. The sister testified that she received the email while at home in Akron and that she forwarded the email to P.S. in Brunswick. The State asked P.S. at trial:
Q. . . . When your sister forwarded you the email from the Defendant, were you in Medina County, Ohio?
A. Yes.
Well if one of yall choose to betray me this time, at least don’t be a coward about it as your name will come up in the discovery and I’ll find out anyway so feel free to give me a heads up you feel me!
Mr. Godschild sent the email to P.S.’s sister and 76 other individuals, including his parents and numerous other close relatives. Mr. Godschild acknowledged that the email will likely be forwarded as he wrote: this email last year to my babies around this same time was used to get a CPO against me. You think I would learn a lesson for sending emails and speaking my TRUTHS by now right? Especially considering it was the betrayal of my parents that forwarded my emails that helped put me in jail! I guess I’m just hard-headed and stubborn like that and will never be silenced! . . . I wonder if 12 (police) will contact me about this one too, guess it depends on how someone takes it or if it gets forwarded to people I didn’t send it too like the previous emails??? Well if one of yall choose to betray me this time, at least don’t be a coward about it as your name will come up in the discovery and I’ll find out anyway so feel free to give me a heads up you feel me!
Venue of Criminal Cases O.R.C. §2901.12
Pursuant to O.R.C. §2901.12(I)(1), venue is proper “in any jurisdiction in which the alleged offender commits any activity that is an essential part of the offense.” See State v. Bates, 2013-Ohio-1270, ¶ 57 (6th Dist.) (pursuant to O.R.C. §2901.12(I), venue is proper in the county in which the victim’s computer was located); State v. Cline, 2008-Ohio-1866, ¶ 50 (2d Dist.) (noting that venue was also proper pursuant to O.R.C. 2901.12(I) in the county where the victim resided and had a computer network).
Conclusion and Holding
Mr. Godschild was charged and tried in the county where victim lived and where she received the email.
In this case, the email was the basis of the charged offense. P.S.’s sister testified that she forwarded the email to P.S. in Brunswick. P.S. testified that she received Mr. Godschild’s email when she was at home in Brunswick which is in Medina County, Ohio. Mr. Godschild was charged and tried in the county where victim lived and where she received the email. It was reasonable for Mr. Godschild to believe the victim would receive the email in Medina County. Viewing the evidence in a light most favorable to the State, venue was proper under O.R.C. §2901.12(I)(1). Therefore, the trial court did not err in denying Mr. Godschild’s Crim.R. 29 motion regarding venue. Mr. Godschild’s first assignment of error is overruled.
Note: There was a second appeal for the court failing to consider felony sentencing factors. That appeal was also overruled but is not evaluated in this article.
Information for this article was obtained from State v. Godschild, 2025 – Ohio – 5085.
State v. Godschild, 2025 – Ohio – 5085 was issued by the Ninth District Appellate Court and is binding in the following Ohio Counties: Lorain, Medina, Summit and Wayne.
Lessons Learned
- How is Venue Established? Venue of Criminal Cases – O.R.C. §2901.12(I)(1) states “When the offense involves a computer … may be tried in any jurisdiction containing any location of the computer … in any jurisdiction from which or into which, as part of the offense … data … is … transmitted by means of a computer … any jurisdiction in which the alleged offender commits any activity that is an essential part of the offense.”. Additionally on May 29, 2013 the Sixth District Appellate Court issued State v. Bates, 2013 – Ohio – 1270 and the court held “[A]n appropriate venue for a course of conduct case is the jurisdiction in which the victim’s computer is located.”. The statute coupled with case law provides the foundation of venue. Consequently, venue is not limited to the sender’s location. If the victim receives the communication in your county, that county likely has venue. Keep in mind that the Protection Order travels with the victim, even outside of the county where the Protection Order was issued.
- Protection Order – Contact Through Another Person – Mr. Godschild Protection Order stated in pertinent part “directly or through another person” and these communications extend to foreseeable indirect transmissions. Here, Mr. Godschild’s email to the P.S.’s sister, which she forwarded to P.S., consequently this constituted a criminal violation because the Mr. Godschild anticipated it might reach the victim. Proof was also evidenced by his own words in the email “[O]r if it gets forwarded to people I didn’t send it too like the previous emails???”. This highlights the broad scope of protection orders in preventing harassment via intermediaries, setting a warning for similar cases involving social media, texts, emails or any electronic communication.
- Documentation – To establish probable cause enroute to Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt law enforcement must 1) Establish the Protection Order is valid. 2) Identify the method of communication. 3) Assure that the criminal charges are filed in the correct jurisdiction. As identified in this case O.R.C. §2901.12 establishes that whever the victim is located can be the proper jurisdiction, even if the suspect is not also in the same jurisdiction.
- Pre-Sent Arms! Brunswick Police Officer Daniel Leone and the Medina County Prosecutor’s Office should be highly commended for their investigation, prosecution and successful appeal defense of Mr. Godschild. Well done!
Does your agency train on Protection Orders?
Don’t fail your training.
Don’t let your training fail you!
Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!