Det. Goble saw Mr. Hawkins leave 314 Highview Landing carrying two distinctive trash bags and throw those bags away into a community dumpster. Det. Goble and another detective then immediately retrieved those bags, which contained drug residue. Det. Goble’s affidavit also established significant corroborating evidence connecting Mr. Hawkins to drug trafficking, including that Mr. Hawkins left a controlled buy and returned to the 327 Highview Landing area, that Mr. Hawkins left from 314 Highview Landing and immediately returned home after a suspected drug transaction, and that Facebook messages between Mr. Crockett and Mr. Hawkins suggested Mr. Hawkins was actively engaged in drug trafficking.

 

U.S. v. Hawkins

No. 24 – 3839

Sixth Circuit Appellate Court

November 19, 2025

Why is this case important?

U.S. v. Hawkins reinforces the legal requirements for an objectively reasonable trash pull. The Sixth Circuit makes clear that officers do not need to witness drug sales at the home to establish probable cause; instead, the focus is on the totality of the circumstances and whether the investigation shows a “fair probability” that contraband will be found. An officer does NOT need to be right – only objectively reasonable! This case gives officers confidence that thorough, well-documented investigative steps—especially observing a suspect personally discard drug-related trash—will withstand suppression challenges and support search warrants.

Background

Defendant Shedrick Hawkins pled guilty to possession with intent to distribute fentanyl and cocaine, as well as being a felon in possession of a firearm, after police executed a search warrant at his residence. The affidavit supporting the search stated that police conducted a trash pull outside Mr. Hawkins’s residence, which discovered residue of cocaine, fentanyl compound, or methamphetamine. The affidavit also contained significant corroborating evidence connecting Mr. Hawkins to drug trafficking, including that police witnessed Mr. Hawkins leave his residence and immediately return home following a suspected drug transaction. It further detailed how police uncovered messages between Mr. Hawkins and a known drug trafficker in which they shared videos of marijuana and discussed drug prices and meeting locations.

Mr. Crockett’s Felonious Messages

On appeal, Mr. Hawkins argues that the district court erred in denying his motion to suppress because the search warrant was not supported by probable cause and lacked a nexus between his residence and the evidence sought. We affirm the judgment of the district court. In April 2023, the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office Special Investigations Unit received a complaint stating that James Crockett was selling drugs in Columbus, Ohio. The complaint also shared Mr. Crockett’s Facebook profile. Detective Christina Goble contacted Mr. Crockett on Facebook Messenger, arranging for several controlled buys with Mr. Crockett in April and May 2023.

$700 Worth of Cocaine

On May 9, 2023, an undercover detective (“UD”) arranged to buy one ounce of cocaine from Mr. Crockett. When the UD arrived at the meeting location, Mr. Crockett asked the UD to drive him to pick up the drugs. Mr. Crockett then contacted multiple individuals, including someone at the telephone number 614-808-5022 (“PN5022”), whom he agreed to meet at a new location. Someone in a maroon Nissan Maxima was waiting for the UD and Mr. Crockett when they arrived at the designated location. After receiving a call from the holder of PN5022, Mr. Crockett got out of the UD’s car and entered the Maxima. About five minutes later, Mr. Crockett exited the Maxima with a bag containing a white powdery substance, which later tested positive for cocaine, and entered the UD’s vehicle, exchanging the bag for $700.

Vehicular Surveillance

After witnessing the sale, police began surveilling the Maxima, which they followed back to 327 Highview Landing. A registration search of the Maxima revealed that the vehicle’s registered owner was Spectrum Motor 1 LLC (“Spectrum”). A cellphone ping warrant for PN5022 also indicated that PN5022 had been in the same area as the Maxima during the sale.

327 Highview Landing, Columbus, Ohio

Search Warrant for a GPS and the Investigation Expands

Three days later, Det. Goble executed a warrant to place a GPS tracker on the Maxima, which was now parked nearby at 314 Highview Landing. The car was later moved to the Spectrum car dealership parking lot, where it remained from May 20 to May 23. On May 23, Det. Goble returned to 314 Highview Landing to further surveil the property and found a Dodge Charger located in the same spot where the Maxima had been parked. Det. Goble’s investigation revealed that the Charger was registered to Mr. Hawkins and that Mr. Hawkins lived at 314 Highview Landing. During her surveillance, Det. Goble discovered two other cars—a white Dodge Durango and a silver Chevrolet Malibu—parked in the same spot as the Maxima and Charger at 314 Highview Landing. The Durango was registered to Spectrum, while the Malibu was registered to both Mr. Hawkins and Spectrum. Mr. Hawkins posted a picture of himself on Facebook in front of a white Dodge Durango, which looked similar to the Durango that Det. Goble saw at 314 Highview Landing.

Search Warrant for Mr. Crockett’s Cell Phone

On May 26, a Franklin County municipal judge issued a search warrant for Mr. Crockett’s cellphone. Det. Goble executed that warrant and found Facebook messages between Mr. Hawkins and Mr. Crockett where they shared videos of marijuana and discussed drug prices and meeting locations. The affidavit did not give more specific details about Mr. Hawkins’s messages with Mr. Crockett, such as the quantity of drugs trafficked and the extent of their communications. On the same day, Det. Goble observed Mr. Hawkins leave his apartment, which caused PN5022 to transmit location signals consistent with Mr. Hawkins’s movement.

Pink Trash Bag with Red Lettering

On June 5, Det. Goble saw Mr. Hawkins leave 314 Highview Landing carrying a pink trash bag and a white bag with red lettering, both of which he threw out in his property’s community dumpster. After Mr. Hawkins left, Det. Goble and another detective immediately checked the dumpster and retrieved the bags, which were the only pink bag and white bag with red lettering they saw in the dumpster.

Clear Plastic Bag with White Powdery Substance

Police discovered a “clear plastic bag containing residue of a white powdery substance” inside one of the bags, which later tested positive for cocaine, fentanyl compound, or methamphetamine. The next day, Det. Goble observed Mr. Hawkins leave the area of 314 Highview Landing in a white Ford Explorer and followed the car to 2351 Taylor Avenue. When Mr. Hawkins arrived, an unknown male exited the home and approached the Explorer’s passenger front window. The man walked away from the car holding a brown bag about two minutes later. Det. Goble followed Mr. Hawkins directly from the suspected drug transaction back to 314 Highview Landing.

2351 Taylor Avenue, Columbus, Ohio

After executing the search warrant, police seized four firearms, 1,197 grams of fentanyl, 1,806 grams of cocaine, approximately $17,775.00 in cash, drug paraphernalia, firearm magazines, and boxes of ammunition. Based on these facts, police obtained a warrant to search Mr. Hawkins’s residence for evidence related to suspected drug trafficking. After executing the search warrant, police seized four firearms, 1,197 grams of fentanyl, 1,806 grams of cocaine, approximately $17,775.00 in cash, drug paraphernalia, firearm magazines, and boxes of ammunition. Soon after, Mr. Hawkins was indicted on one count of possession with intent to distribute 400 grams or more of fentanyl and 500 grams or more of cocaine (“Count One”), in violation of 21 U.S.C. §§ 841(a)(1), 841(b)(1)(A)(vi), and 841(b)(1)(B)(ii), and one count of being a felon in possession of a firearm (“Count Two”), in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 922(g)(1) and 924(a).

Motion to Suppress is Denied

Mr. Hawkins moved to suppress the evidence seized from the search of his residence. He alleged that the search warrant was not supported by probable cause and that it lacked a nexus between his residence and the evidence sought. The district court denied Mr. Hawkins’s motion, holding that “the totality of the circumstances established a strong nexus between illegal drugs and Mr. Mr. Hawkins’s apartment.” Because the district court found that probable cause existed, it did not apply the good-faith exception.

Mr. Hawkins is Sentenced to Eleven Years in Federal Prison

Mr. Hawkins then entered a plea agreement where he pled guilty to Count One and Count Two of his indictment but reserved the right to appeal the district court’s denial of his motion to suppress. The district court sentenced Mr. Hawkins to 135 months in prison on both counts, served concurrently, as well as five years of supervised release on Count One and three years of supervised release on Count Two, also served concurrently. Mr. Hawkins timely appealed, challenging the district court’s denial of his motion to suppress.

Established Case Law – Trash Pull

Here, Det. Goble’s affidavit established a sufficient nexus between Mr. Hawkins’s drug dealing activities and his residence. “It is well established in this Circuit that drug paraphernalia recovered from a trash pull establishes probable cause to search a home when combined with other evidence of the resident’s involvement in drug crimes.” United States v. Abernathy, 843 F.3d 243, 251–52 (6th Cir. 2016).

[T]he affidavit included ample circumstantial corroborating information.

Det. Goble saw Mr. Hawkins leave 314 Highview Landing carrying two distinctive trash bags and throw those bags away into a community dumpster. Det. Goble and another detective then immediately retrieved those bags, which contained drug residue. Det. Goble’s affidavit also established significant corroborating evidence connecting Mr. Hawkins to drug trafficking, including that Mr. Hawkins left a controlled buy and returned to the 327 Highview Landing area, that Mr. Hawkins left from 314 Highview Landing and immediately returned home after a suspected drug transaction, and that Facebook messages between Mr. Crockett and Mr. Hawkins suggested Mr. Hawkins was actively engaged in drug trafficking. As the district court summarized, the affidavit included ample circumstantial corroborating information:

  1. Mr. Crockett had contacted the user of PN5022 to buy drugs to sell to the UC.
  2. PN5022 had multiple cellphone pings at 314 Highview Landing during [police surveillance].
  3. Mr. Crockett got cocaine from the driver of the Maxima.
  4. The Maxima drove to the apartment complex at 327 Highview Landing after the May 9 controlled buy and was found parked at 314 Highview Landing a couple of days later.
  5. Multiple cars, including the Maxima, switched in and out of the same parking spot at 314 Highview Landing within few days, consistent with someone involved in drug activities.
  6. Mr. Hawkins was the registered owner of at least three of those four cars;
  7. Facebook communications between Mr. Mr. Hawkins and Mr. Mr. Crockett discussed narcotics prices and meeting locations and shared pictures of marijuana.
  8. Hawkins left 314 Highview Landing to engage in suspected drug activity—he drove to another house, handed a brown bag to a man, and then went back to his apartment; and
  9. Cellphone pings for PN5022 were consistent with Mr. Mr. Hawkins’s movement and suspected drug sales.

In Abernathy Officers Did Not See the Defendant Throw Away the Trash

The contrast between Det. Goble’s affidavit and the affidavit in Abernathy underscores that there was probable cause here. In Abernathy, we held that drugs found in a trash pull outside the defendant’s house “were insufficient, standing alone, to create probable cause to search [the] Defendant’s residence.” 843 F.3d at 256–57 (emphasis added). Because the police did not see the defendant throw out the relevant trash bags, “there [was] no way of knowing with certainty that the trash pull evidence . . . (i) came from Defendant’s residence at all; or (ii) if it did, that it was in the residence recently.” Id. at 254–55. We explained that “[T]he inability to tell when drugs were last in the home diminishes any inference that drugs were still in the home.” Id. at 255. Moreover, we expressly distinguished other cases finding probable cause where “the warrant application either contained corroborating evidence tying the defendant to drug activity in addition to the trash pull evidence, or [where] the police recovered more evidence from the trash pull than was present here.” Id. at 256.

Here, Det. Goble saw Mr. Hawkins discard the trash bags containing the drugs and therefore knew with certainty that the contraband had recently come from Mr. Hawkins’s home. And, as noted earlier, the affidavit contained significant evidence connecting Mr. Hawkins to drug trafficking. Indeed, we have found affidavits containing similar evidence to establish probable cause in other cases. See, e.g., Marcilis v. Twp. of Redford, 693 F.3d 589, 600–01 (6th Cir. 2012) (probable cause to search residence where police recovered “torn, clear, plastic bags” containing substances that tested positive for cocaine and marijuana in trash pull, “police officers observed multiple instances of suspected drug transactions involving” plaintiff, and plaintiff “made trips to the [residences] during these transactions”); United States v. Talley, 692 F. App’x 219, 222 (6th Cir. 2017) (probable cause to search residence where trash pull uncovered small amount of marijuana in sealed bag, detectives smelled odor of unburnt marijuana emanating from home during investigation several days earlier, and suspect had an extensive criminal history, including a drug trafficking conviction).

Mr. Hawkins Argued Because White Powdery Plastic Bags Were Thrown Away Does Not Mean There is Cocaine Inside the Residence

Mr. Hawkins’s arguments to the contrary are unpersuasive. Mr. Hawkins first argues that even though police had probable cause to arrest him for drug possession and that the trash pull evidence suggested someone at 314 Highview Landing used drugs, these facts do “not create an inference that the apartment contained additional drugs.”. Specifically, he contends that there was no nexus to his residence because police did not observe any sales, controlled buys, or deliveries that occurred at 314 Highview Landing. But police did not need to “observe [Mr. Hawkins] selling from his apartment.” United States v. Higgins, 141 F.4th 811, 816 (6th Cir. 2025). Nor did the police need “ironclad evidence that contraband [would] be present before” conducting a search. Id. We instead judge the affidavit “on the adequacy of what it does contain, not on what it lacks, or on what a critic might say should have been added.” United States v. Allen, 211 F.3d 970, 975 (6th Cir. 2000). And here, the affidavit contained sufficient information to establish “a fair shot of finding contraband” in Mr. Hawkins’s residence. Higgins, 141 F.4th at 816.

But courts may consider “an officer’s ‘training and experience’ . . . in determining probable cause.”

Second, Mr. Hawkins argues that Det. Goble improperly invoked her training and experience to “fill in . . . gaps in critical facts,” including that the Taylor Avenue interaction was a suspected drug transaction. But courts may consider “an officer’s ‘training and experience’ . . . in determining probable cause.” United States v. Schultz, 14 F.3d 1093, 1097 (6th Cir. 1994); accord United States v. Williams, 544 F.3d 683, 686 (6th Cir. 2008) (“[C]ourts may afford considerable weight to the conclusion of experienced law enforcement officers regarding where evidence of a crime is likely to be found.”. While “training and experience . . . cannot substitute for the lack of evidentiary nexus,” Schultz, 14 F.3d at 1097 there is no lack of evidentiary nexus here. Det. Goble’s extensive investigation revealed a positive trash pull, Mr. Hawkins travelling directly from 314 Highview Landing to a suspected drug transaction and then returning immediately home, and Facebook messages between Mr. Hawkins and Mr. Crockett where they discussed drug trafficking.

Conclusion and Holding

In sum, Det. Goble’s affidavit contained sufficient information to establish a “fair probability” that evidence of drug activity would be found at Mr. Hawkins’s residence. Sanders, 106 F.4th at 461. Moreover, “[B]ecause we find that the warrant was supported by probable cause, we need not address the issue of whether the good faith exception would apply.” United States v. Dyer, 580 F.3d 386, 393 (6th Cir. 2009).

For the foregoing reasons, we affirm the judgment of the district court. Information for this article was obtained from U.S. v. Hawkins, No. 24 – 3839 (6th Cir., 2025).

U.S. v. Hawkins, No. 24 – 3839 (6th Cir., 2025) was issued by the Sixth Circuit Appellate Court on November 19, 2025 and is binding in Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee.

Lessons Learned:

  1. One Man’s Trash is Another Man’s Evidence – On May 16, 1988 the U.S. Supreme Court issued California v. Greenwood 486 U.S. 35 (1988) and the court held “Accordingly, having deposited their garbage “in an area particularly suited for public inspection and, in a manner of speaking, public consumption, for the express purpose of having strangers take it,” Mr. Billy Greenwood could have had no reasonable expectation of privacy in the inculpatory items that he discarded.” Based on Greenwood, the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office could have searched Mr. Hawkins trash without a search warrant. The other critical factor was that the deputies observed Mr. Hawkins exit 314 Highview Landing with a distinctive pink trash bag and place it in the dumpster. Immediately thereafter, Detective Christina Goble retrieved the bag that included the felonious plastic baggie with methamphetamine and fentanyl residue. When retrieving trash bags from common trash receptacles, officers must make a direct connection with a trash bag to the suspect. A bag left in a common use trash bin may, without observation by law enforcement as to who placed ‘that’ bag in the trash, may not be directly attributed to the suspect, without other corroborating or circumstantial evidence.
  2. Did Mr. Hawkins Trash Establish Probable Cause? On December 8, 2016 the Sixth Circuit Appellate Court issued S. v. Abernathy, 843 U.S. 243 (6th Cir., 2016) and that court held “. “It is well established in this Circuit that drug paraphernalia recovered from a trash pull establishes probable cause to search a home when combined with other evidence of the resident’s involvement in drug crimes.” Id at 251-252. In this case Mr. Hawkins trash included “Police discovered a “clear plastic bag containing residue of a white powdery substance” inside one of the bags, which later tested positive for cocaine, fentanyl compound, or methamphetamine.”. This bag along with the GPS information and surveillance of Mr. Hawkins well established probable cause that he was a drug trafficker.
  3. Probable Cause – “ Hawkins first argues that even though police had probable cause to arrest him for drug possession and that the trash pull evidence suggested someone at 314 Highview Landing used drugs, these facts do “not create an inference that the apartment contained additional drugs.”. The Sixth Circuit Appellate Court upheld the probable cause identified in the affidavit because law enforcement does not have to be right, only reasonable. All of the factors identified by the FCSO Special Investigations Unit clearly established probable cause that Mr. Hawkins was a drug trafficker as the court opined “Det. Goble saw Mr. Hawkins leave 314 Highview Landing carrying two distinctive trash bags and throw those bags away into a community dumpster. Det. Goble and another detective then immediately retrieved those bags, which contained drug residue. Det. Goble’s affidavit also established significant corroborating evidence connecting Mr. Hawkins to drug trafficking, including that Mr. Hawkins left a controlled buy and returned to the 327 Highview Landing area, that Mr. Hawkins left from 314 Highview Landing and immediately returned home after a suspected drug transaction, and that Facebook messages between Mr. Crockett and Mr. Hawkins suggested Mr. Hawkins was actively engaged in drug trafficking.”.
  4. Pre-Sent Arms! The Franklin County Sheriff’s Office Special Investigations Unit [SIU] Detective Christina Goble and the other unidentified detectives with SIU should be highly commended for their investigation and legal acumen for the arrest, conviction and successful appeal defense of Mr. Hawkins conviction. Well done!

Does your agency train on Trash Pulls?

Don’t fail your training.

Don’t let your training fail you!

Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!

Robert H. Meader Esq.