[W]e conclude that the officer’s further detainment of Mr. Bishop was based on reasonable suspicion of criminal activity.

State v. Bishop

2025 – Ohio – 4743

First District Appellate Court

Hamilton County, Ohio

October 15, 2025

Why is this case important?

State v. Bishop reaffirms that a traffic stop can be extended if an officer establishes reasonable suspicion that criminal activity is afoot.

Background – Traffic Stop – Canine Alert – Firearms Charges

A Norwood Police Officer Max Murphy initiated a traffic stop after observing Mr. Tyrese Bishop commit a turn-signal violation. As the officer was completing the traffic citation, he called for a canine unit to conduct a drug sniff on Mr. Bishop’s vehicle. After the dog alerted, a legal amount of marijuana was found in the car. The officer asked Mr. Bishop if he had any contraband in his cross-body bag, and Mr. Bishop responded that he had a gun in the bag. Mr. Bishop was charged with CCW in violation of O.R.C. §2923.12(B)(1) and improper handling of firearms in a vehicle in violation of O.R.C. §2923.16(E)(1). The basis of both charges was Mr. Bishop’s failure to disclose to the officer that he had a loaded handgun in his vehicle.

Motion to Suppress

Was the Traffic Stop was Prolonged?

Bishop filed a motion to suppress the evidence against him, arguing that the canine sniff was unreliable and an unconstitutional search and seizure because marijuana is now a legal substance, and Mr. Bishop was seized after the marijuana was found. Mr. Bishop further argued that the officer unconstitutionally seized him and prolonged the traffic stop to conduct the dog sniff. Mr. Bishop did not challenge the police questioning as a Miranda violation.

Wearing a Ski Mask in May and Pulled Into a UDF

Is that suspicious?

At the hearing on the motion, the Officer Murphy testified that he initially observed Mr. Bishop when they passed each other on Carthage Avenue while traveling in opposite directions. The officer observed Mr. Bishop driving while wearing a ski-mask-style face covering. The officer turned his cruiser around and, while following Mr. Bishop, he observed Mr. Bishop activate his left-turn signal after he had come to a stop at a light. After Mr. Bishop turned left, the officer initiated the traffic stop and activated his body-worn camera (“BWC”). Mr. Bishop pulled into a United Dairy Farmers store at 5023 Montgomery Road, Norwood, Ohio and parked in a parking spot.

Mr. Bishop’s Cross Body Bag Contained a Firearm

Mr. Bishop Said He Did Not Have a Firearm

Request for Canine

Officer Murphy identified his BWC, and the video was admitted and played. When the officer initially interacted with Mr. Bishop, he noticed that Mr. Bishop’s window was rolled down about three inches, and Mr. Bishop was wearing a cross-body bag that he continued to touch. At two minutes and 21 seconds into the stop, the officer asked Mr. Bishop if he had any weapons in the vehicle. Mr. Bishop responded, “No.” Twenty seconds later, the officer called for the canine unit. When asked why he requested a canine, the officer responded, “Based on what I observed from Mr. Mr. Bishop, I suspected there was criminal activity occurring.”

The video confirmed that the officer requested a canine unit almost immediately after initiating contact with Mr. Bishop, and prior to inputting Mr. Bishop’s information into the computer and before beginning to complete the citation. The officer testified that the canine unit arrived within five-to-six minutes.

Completing the Ticket – Canine Alert – Weed and Firearm

While awaiting the canine unit, the officer began to complete the traffic citation. The video depicts Officer Murphy input Mr. Bishop’s information into the computer and fill out the citation. When the dog arrived and conducted the sniff, it alerted on Mr. Bishop’s car. The officer searched the vehicle and found a bag of marijuana and a scale in the center console and a larger bag of marijuana in a pair of pants on the back seat. After finding the marijuana, the Officer Murphy asked Mr. Bishop if he had anything in his bag, and Mr. Bishop said he had a gun. The officer discovered a loaded firearm in Mr. Bishop’s cross-body bag and arrested him.

Mr. Bishop Removed his Ski Mask when he was Stopped

On cross-examination, Officer Murphy testified that Mr. Bishop was no longer wearing the ski mask when Mr. Bishop exited from his vehicle. When the officer approached the vehicle, Mr. Bishop had his window cracked and had his license and insurance ready. Officer Murphy asked Mr. Bishop to step out of the vehicle. Mr. Bishop protested, but eventually complied and informed the officer that he did not consent to a search of the vehicle. Officer Murphy returned to his cruiser with Mr. Bishop’s identification and called for Canine Officer Ryan Ramos and Canine Beau. When Officer Murphy input Mr. Bishop’s information into his computer, he found no outstanding warrants. The officer began to write the citation six minutes and 26 seconds after the initial stop. Officer Murphy had Mr. Bishop provide his phone number for the citation but did not have him sign it. The officer retained Mr. Bishop’s identification.

No Miranda

After Canine Beau completed the sniff, Officer Murphy told Mr. Bishop, “Let’s finish this up and we’ll get you out of here.” The officer testified that he was referring to the investigation based on the dog’s alert when he said “finish this up.” Officer Murphy began searching the vehicle and had not yet given Mr. Bishop the citation. Officer Murphy found marijuana, a scale, and a ski mask and acknowledged that the marijuana was legal. Officer Murphy testified that he did not advise Mr. Bishop of his Miranda rights.

Can Officer Murhpy Explain Why Wearing a Ski Mask in May is Suspicious?

When cross-examination was complete, and the State had no redirect, the trial court asked the officer, “Officer, you said, ‘Based on what I observed from Mr. Mr. Bishop, I thought criminal activity was going on. Can you explain that?’” The officer had previously testified that he requested a canine because he suspected criminal activity. The officer responded, Yes, sir. So it was May the 9th. You can see that we’re all wearing short sleeves. I observed Mr. Mr. Bishop wearing, like, a full ski mask, and I thought that was unusual. Additionally, once the car stopped, Mr. Mr. Bishop only rolled the window down a few inches. And then when I asked him to get out of the car, he refused multiple times until I told him he would be arrested if he didn’t get out of the car. And then the other thing I observed was the cross-body bag that he was wearing that he continued to touch and pull his arms over while he was sitting in the driver’s seat.

The court asked Officer Murphy what he was thinking when Mr. Bishop continued to touch the bag. The officer explained that he “was thinking that he was concealing, illegally, contraband or items.”

Bishop Relied on Persuasive Case Law

A Great Case for His Case … IF the Stop Occurred in Colorado

The parties proceeded to closing arguments. Mr. Bishop argued that the officer unconstitutionally delayed the traffic stop to wait for a canine unit. Mr. Bishop further argued that any reasonable suspicion or probable cause provided by the dog’s alert should not be valid because the dog was trained to detect a legal substance, rendering the sniff a search. Mr. Bishop relied on a Colorado case, People v. McKnight, for the proposition that “a canine trained to detect cannabis is not a reliable source to offer probable cause for a search.” Mr. Bishop next argued that any statements he made must be suppressed because the officer failed to inform him of his Miranda

Finally, Mr. Bishop argued the traffic stop was invalid because he used his turn signal. The State argued that the stop was valid because Officer Murphy observed Mr. Bishop commit a turn-signal violation. Within minutes of the stop, Officer Murphy requested a canine unit, which is not an improper delay. The canine arrived within five-to-six minutes, which did not delay the stop. After Canine Beau alerted, Mr. Bishop informed Officer Murphy he had a firearm in his bag. I thought that was unusual. Additionally, once the car stopped, Mr. Bishop only rolled the window down a few inches. And then when I asked him to get out of the car, he refused multiple times until I told him he would be arrested if he didn’t get out of the car. And then the other thing I observed was the cross-body bag that he was wearing that he continued to touch and pull his arms over while he was sitting in the driver’s seat.

The trial court found that Officer Murphy had reasonable suspicion to prolong the stop

The trial court found that Officer Murphy had reasonable suspicion to prolong the stop to investigate for the reasons the officer put forth in his testimony. The court overruled the motion to suppress.

Bishop entered no-contest pleas to both charges and was found guilty.

Appeal

In his first assignment of error, Mr. Bishop contends that the trial court erred in denying his motion to suppress. Specifically, Mr. Bishop argues that when a police officer continues to detain a person stopped for a traffic violation to ask questions unrelated to the original purpose of the stop, without any articulable facts giving rise to a suspicion of some illegal activity, the continued detention for questioning constitutes an illegal seizure.

Motion to Suppress – The traffic stop was delayed for the canine unit to respond

In the motion to suppress, Mr. Bishop contended that his seizure was unlawfully prolonged without reasonable suspicion because “[P]olice had no authority to delay the traffic stop for a drug-detection dog to sniff the exterior of the vehicle.”

Can a Cannabis-Trained Canine Establish Probable Cause with a Positive Alert on a Motor Vehicle?

Additionally, he argued that the dog sniff was an unconstitutional search. He further argued that “any reasonable suspicion or probable cause provided by the dog’s alert should not be legal because the dog was trained to detect a legal substance, rendering the sniff a search.”

Bishop Argues Wearing a Full Ski Mask in May While Pulling into a UDF is NOT Suspicious … AND … Failed to Timely Appeal a Miranda Violation

On appeal, Mr. Bishop challenges the questioning by police that occurred after the dog-sniff and search of the vehicle because it was “not related to the purpose of the original stop” and not based on reasonable suspicion. Mr. Bishop did not include this argument in his motion to suppress. The only arguments made in the motion to suppress were that Mr. Bishop’s seizure was unlawfully prolonged without reasonable suspicion, and that the dog’s sniff was itself an unconstitutional search. During closing argument, for the first time, Mr. Bishop specifically claimed that his statements should be suppressed “because the officer failed to inform Mr. Bishop of his Miranda rights.” However, although Mr. Bishop asserted his Fifth Amendment claim, for the first time, in his oral argument, “[Mr. Bishop] never moved the trial court to amend his written motion nor did he attempt to establish ‘good cause’ for relief from the waiver.” City of Columbus v. Ridley, 2015-Ohio-4968, ¶ 27 (10th Dist.) Accordingly, the trial court did not address Mr. Bishop’s Fifth-Amendment claim when ruling on the motion to suppress. See id. (“Thus, the trial court’s ruling is properly confined to the issues raised by the written motion to suppress. Crim.R. 12(H)”). We note that Mr. Bishop did not argue on appeal that the court erred by disregarding his Miranda-violation argument. 

Established Case Law – Tardy Filings

“When filing a motion to suppress evidence, a defendant must ‘raise the grounds upon which the validity of the search or seizure is challenged in such a manner as to give the prosecutor notice of the basis for the challenge.’” State v. Wright, 2024-Ohio-1763, ¶ 13 (1st Dist.), citing State v. Billings, 2021-Ohio-2194, ¶ 15 (1st Dist.), quoting City of Xenia v. Wallace, 37 Ohio St.3d 216, 219 (1988). A motion to suppress must “state with particularity the legal and factual issues to be resolved,” thereby placing the prosecutor and court “on notice of those issues to be heard and decided by the court and, by omission, those issues which are otherwise being waived.” State v. Schindler, 70 Ohio St.3d 54, 58 (1994). 

“It is well-settled law that issues not raised in the trial court may not be raised for the first time on appeal because such issues are deemed waived.” Ridley at ¶ 28, quoting State v. Barrett, 2011-Ohio-4986, ¶ 13 (10th Dist.); Xenia at 218 (The failure of a defendant to adequately specify the grounds for his motion to suppress evidence results in a waiver of that issue on appeal.). By failing to raise the argument that his statements should be suppressed because of a violation of his Miranda rights in his motion to suppress, Mr. Bishop has waived his opportunity to raise the issue on appeal. See Wright at ¶ 13, citing State v. Wintermeyer, 2019-Ohio-5156, ¶ 10 (“Therefore, when a defendant fails to present an argument at a suppression hearing, that argument is waived.”); Schindler at 58; State v. Fricke, 2016-Ohio-2747, ¶ 24 (2d Dist.) (“If a motion to suppress fails to state a particular basis for relief, the issue is waived and cannot be argued on appeal.”). Thus, Mr. Bishop waived the argument on appeal. See Wright at ¶15.

[T]he Fifth-Amendment challenge is without merit

Notwithstanding the waiver, the Fifth-Amendment challenge is without merit. Mr. Bishop contends that once the search of the vehicle did not reveal any illegal contraband, the officer “improperly prolonged the traffic stop for additional questioning.” Mr. Bishop further contends that after the vehicle search, the traffic citation was completed, and Officer Murphy had no reason to detain him to question him about his bag. During the motion to suppress, Mr. Bishop did not pose any questions to the officer regarding his suspicions after the search was complete.

Established Case Law – Extended Traffic Stop

Once a police officer has issued a traffic citation, it is unreasonable to detain the driver further absent reasonable suspicion. See State v. Bell, 1995 Ohio App. LEXIS 4564, *4 (1st Dist. Oct. 18, 1995), citing State v. Retherford, 93 Ohio App.3d 586 (2d Dist. 1994). However, a driver may be detained “beyond [the normal] time frame when additional facts are encountered that give rise to a reasonable, articulable suspicion of criminal activity beyond that which prompted the initial stop.” State v. Batchili, 2007-Ohio-2204, ¶ 15.

At the time of the vehicle search, Officer Murphy had not issued the traffic citation to Mr. Bishop.  The officer had completed the citation but had not yet obtained Mr. Bishop’s signature.  Mr. Bishop contends that the discovery of a legal amount of marijuana did not justify the officer’s additional questioning of Mr. Bishop without other facts creating a suspicion of criminal activity.

Does Wearing a Ski Mask in May While Pulling Into a UDF Suspicious?

The focus of the hearing on the motion was the alleged illegality of the delay due to the request for a canine unit and the dog sniff.  In fact, Officer Murphy was not questioned regarding his reasonable suspicion after discovering the marijuana and scale.  Furthermore, there are factors to consider beyond the discovery of the marijuana in determining the legality of the search.  Officer Murphy articulated that he initially suspected criminal activity due to Mr. Bishop’s wearing of a ski mask while driving, his arguing with the order to get out of the car, refusing to exit from the car until threatened with arrest, and the constant touching of the bag, not only while seated in his car but during the entire time that the ticket was being written.  The additional facts based on the car search, the discovery of the marijuana and scale and the ski mask, gave rise to a reasonable suspicion of criminal activity that allows an officer to “further detain and implement a more in-depth investigation of the individual.”  State v. Robinette, 80 Ohio St.3d 234, 241 (1997); State v. Hale, 2024-Ohio-4866, ¶ 24 (officer’s discovery of more facts allowed him to extend defendant’s detention so that he could investigate his additional suspicions of criminal activity).

Conclusion and Holding

[W]e conclude that the officer’s further detainment of Mr. Bishop was based on reasonable suspicion of criminal activity

Accordingly, we overrule the first assignment of error because we conclude that the officer’s further detainment of Mr. Bishop was based on reasonable suspicion of criminal activity and because we do not reach the issue of whether Mr. Bishop’s statements should have been suppressed because Mr. Bishop waived that argument by not raising it below.

Note: Mr. Bishop was successful on a second appeal where the two firearms charges should have only been one.  That second appeal is not evaluated in this article.

Information for this article was obtained from State v. Bishop, 2025 – Ohio – 4743 and a phone interview with Officer Ryan Ramos.

State v. Bishop, 2025 – Ohio – 4743 was issued by the First District Appellate Court on October 15, 2025 by the First District Appellate Court and is binding in Hamilton County, Ohio.

Lessons Learned:

  1. Established Case Law – Extension of a Traffic Stop – On April 21, 2025 the U.S. Supreme Court held “Because addressing the infraction is the purpose of the stop, it may last no longer than is necessary to effectuate that purpose. Authority for the seizure ends when tasks tied to the traffic infraction are – or reasonably should have been completed … An officer, in other words, may conduct certain unrelated checks curing an otherwise lawful traffic stop.  But … he may not do so in way that prolongs the stop, absent the reasonable suspicion ordinarily demanded to justify detaining an individual.”.  Rodriguez v. U.S., 575 U.S. 348 (2015).  In this case Officer Murphy observed Mr. Bishop wearing a full ski mask in May while driving in a high crime area.  Wearing a ski mask in the month of May in a high crime area, established reasonable suspicion that Mr. Bishop was involved in criminal activity and therefore Officer Murphy could have extended the stop to determine if Mr. Bishop was involved in criminal activity.
  2. Canine Did Not Extend the Traffic Stop – The First District Appellate Court determined that Officer Murphy established reasonable suspicion to extend the stop. However, the court also determined that Officer Murphy did not extend the stop at all “The video confirmed that the officer requested a canine unit almost immediately after initiating contact with Mr. Bishop, and prior to inputting Mr. Bishop’s information into the computer and before beginning to complete the citation. The officer testified that the canine unit arrived within five-to-six minutes.”.  The arrival of Canine Officer Ryan Ramos and Canine Beau within a few minutes was not objectively unreasonable.
  3. What Legal Doctrine was Mr. Bishop Detained? When a law enforcement officer makes a decision to stop a person, the officer must decide what legal doctrine he is applying.  In this case the prosecutor argued the reason for the stop was a fail to signal “The State argued that the stop was valid because the officer observed Mr. Bishop commit a turn-signal violation.”  The stop began as a pre-textual stop.  The initial legal rationale is that Mr. Bishop committed a turn signal violation but the real reason was that Mr. Bishop was wearing a ski mask in May.
  4. Did Officer Murphy Unreasonably Fail to Give Mr. Bishop Miranda? On July 2, 1984 the U.S. Supreme Court held “[A person who is] temporarily detained as part of a routine traffic or investigatory stop is not generally deemed in [Miranda] custody, and hence, is not entitled to Miranda warnings.” Berkemer v. McCarty, 468 U.S. 420, 436 (1984).  Consequently, a person can be detained and not free to leave law enforcement whether it be constructive or actual custody and yet not be in Miranda-custody.  In this case the court states “The officer testified that he did not advise Mr. Bishop of his Miranda rights.”.  However, the court does not address the validity of Mr. Bishop’s statements.  Based on Berkemer v. McCarty, 468 U.S. 420, 436 (1984), Officer Murphy was not required to Mirandize Mr. Bishop until he was placed under arrest.  The reason why is that up to that point he was being detained as part of a routine traffic or investigatory detention and not until probable cause was established that Mr. Bishop was unlawfully carrying a firearm was Officer Murphy required to recite the Miranda warning to Mr. Bishop.  The key legal issue as to why Mr. Bishop’s Miranda appeal failed is that he failed to raise this issue during the Motion to Suppress.
  5. Can a Cannabis-Trained Canine Still Establish Probable Cause to Search a Motor Vehicle with a Positive Alert? This question remains un-answered; however the First District Appellate Court had an opportunity to answer that question in this case. Officer Murphy had reasonable suspicion to extend the traffic stop and investigate the actions of Mr. Bishop because he was wearing a full ski mask in the month of May while entering the parking lot of a UDF.  The canine-alert certainly added additional legal justification to further detain and search the vehicle interior but the definitive question of whether a cannabis-imprinted/trained canine can establish probable cause to search the interior of a vehicle remains un-answered.  The First District addressed a similar question prior to the legalization of recreational marijuana but after medical marijuana was legalized on May 8, 2024 in State v. Wright, 2024 – Ohio – 1763.  See Does a Cannabis-Trained Canine Alert Establish Probable Cause when Medical-Marijuana was Legal?
  6. Pre-Sent Arms! Officer Max Murphy, Officer Ryan Ramos, Canine Beau and the Hamilton County Prosecutor’s Office should be highly commended for their investigation, arrest and conviction of Mr. Bishop.  Well done!

Does your agency train on Traffic Stops and Request for a Canine?

Don’t fail your training.

Don’t let your training fail you!

Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!

Robert H. Meader Esq.