We … hold that as incident to arrest the officer could, as precautionary matter and incident to the arrest the officer could, as a precautionary matter and without probable cause or reasonable suspicion look in closets and other spaces immediately adjoining the place of arrest from which an attack could be immediately launched. Maryland v. Buie, 494 U.S. 325 (1990)
No – An in-home protective sweep can only be made to search for humans who may launch attack not for contraband or evidence.
State v. Curry
First District Appellate Court
Hamilton County, Ohio
June 13, 2025
Why is this case important?
The Curry case re-affirms that an in-home protective sweep is limited to search for humans who may launch an attack on law enforcement. The sweep may not be conducted to search for contraband. If contraband is discovered in accordance with the Plain View Doctrine while searching for humans, then the contraband may be admissible, however, the search cannot be conducted for contraband.
Cincinnati Responds on Reports of Shots Fired at Winton Terrace
On July 25, 2023, multiple Cincinnati Police officers were dispatched to 5489 Gardenview Lane in the Winton Terrace neighborhood of Cincinnati after receiving reports that an individual, later determined to be Mr. Shawn Curry, was firing gunshots in the street. Upon arriving at the scene, officers witnessed Mr. Curry toss a firearm onto the ground and enter through a window into the residence located at 5489 Gardenview Lane.

Refused to Answer – Battering Ram Used to Enter
The following events were recorded on the body-worn cameras (“BWCs”) of several of the officers involved. Officers surrounded the residence. They knocked on the door of the apartment that Mr. Curry had entered, announced their presence, and ordered him to come outside. A woman could be heard yelling inside the apartment. When Mr. Curry did not respond or open the door, officers used a battering ram to breach the doorway of the apartment. The doorway led to a long hallway with a room off to the right at the end of the hallway. The officers could not see any people, but they could hear a woman crying and screaming and a dog loudly barking. The occupants of the apartment were ordered to exit, but when they did not comply, officers made their way down the hallway, through what turned out to be a kitchen on the right. They discovered Mr. Curry and Jamelia Brooks standing in the living room, which was accessed by walking through the kitchen and turning left. Ms. Brooks eventually walked over to the officers and was handcuffed, while Mr. Curry dropped to the floor in compliance. Mr. Curry was also handcuffed, and he and Ms. Brooks were taken outside.
Protective Sweep of the Premises
The suppression-hearing testimony revealed that the officers turned off their BWCs and conducted what they called a “protective sweep” of the entire apartment, except for a bedroom behind a closed door. Officers did not enter the bedroom because they could hear a dog barking from inside the room and were worried that the dog would be aggressive.
White Powder, Blue Pills, Scale and Firearm Discovered
Search Warrant was Obtained
During the protective sweep, the officers saw what they believed to be a digital scale, a bag containing a white powdered substance believed to be fentanyl, and a bag containing blue pills. All three items were on the kitchen counter. After a neighbor assured the officers that the dog in the bedroom was not aggressive and offered to watch it, the officers entered the bedroom to retrieve the dog and conduct a protective sweep of that room. A firearm was found in plain view on the bed. Based on the evidence observed during the protective sweeps, the officers obtained a warrant to search the apartment. When the warrant was executed, additional contraband was recovered.
Mr. Curry is Indicted
Mr. Curry was indicted for aggravated possession of drugs, aggravated trafficking in drugs, possession of cocaine, trafficking in cocaine, tampering with evidence, carrying a concealed weapon, and having a weapon while under disability.
Mr. Curry a Franks Hearing
A Franks Hearing Alleges the Affidavit Contained False Information
Mr. Curry filed a “motion for Franks Hearing and to suppress evidence.” In the motion, Mr. Curry asked the court to suppress any evidence obtained from the search of his apartment “on the grounds that said evidence is the fruit of an unconstitutional search and seizure in violation of” Mr. Curry’s rights under the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution and Article 1, Section 14 of the Ohio Constitution.
The memorandum in support of Mr. Curry’s motion argued that the officers had included false statements in the search warrant affidavit. He contended that any statements asserting that the officers observed contraband in plain view during the protective sweep were false and were contradicted by footage from the officers’ BWCs. Mr. Curry further argued that, absent these false statements, the search warrant affidavit lacked probable cause to support the issuance of the warrant.
Did the Officers Conduct a Lawful Protective Sweep?
Mr. Curry’s memorandum also argued that a warrantless search conducted after Mr. Curry was secured on the floor would have only permitted the officers to search areas in his immediate control, and that “the State cannot assert that a ‘protective sweep’ and/or the ‘plain view doctrine’ would have permitted the officers to search the residence and recover evidence of a crime.” The State did not file a written response to Mr. Curry’s motion.
Did the Body Camera Video Support or Oppose the Affidavit?
At the hearing on the motion to suppress, Mr. Curry’s opening statement focused on the false statements in the affidavit, stating, [T]here is body-camera footage before the search warrant that does reveal that some of the things that were stated in the search warrant were not correct. [The statements] were false and recklessly disregarded the truth. Because those statements were false and recklessly disregarded the truth, and without those statements in the search warrant, there was no probable cause for the officers to search.
The State, in its opening statement, argued that no false evidence had been offered in support of the search warrant. It argued that “[T]he officers are allowed to do a protective sweep in order [to] make sure that there are no people remaining in that household before they execute the search warrant. And in this case, that’s exactly what happened.”
Mr. Curry was Observed Entering the Apartment Through a Window
The first and only witness called by Mr. Curry at the suppression hearing was Cincinnati Officer #1, who signed the search warrant affidavit. Officer #1 testified that, on July 25, 2023, he was assigned to the Cincinnati Police Department’s violent crime squad and responded to 5489 Gardenview Lane after receiving reports that an individual was firing gunshots in the street. After arriving at the scene, Officer #1 saw the suspect toss the firearm on the ground and enter a nearby apartment through a window. Officer #1, along with several other officers, entered that apartment with their BWCs activated.
Note: All of the law enforcement officers were identified by name in the case though those names were redacted in this article.
Ms. Brooks Assaulted an Officer
Officer #1’s testimony established that Mr. Curry and Ms. Brooks were the only two people that the officers encountered inside the apartment. The officers had not heard any other person in the apartment or suspected that anyone else was inside it. Officer #1 assisted with securing Ms. Brooks. He explained that she assaulted an officer and was taken out of the apartment and subsequently arrested. Officer #1 further testified that Mr. Curry was prone on the living-room floor. From that position, Mr. Curry could not access the closed bedroom or the kitchen. Officer #1 stated that Mr. Curry was removed from the apartment and arrested.
Body Camera Review
Officer #1 testified that he drafted the search warrant affidavit, and the affidavit alleged that several items in the apartment were in the plain view of the officers. Because Mr. Curry’s motion to suppress argued that this statement was intentionally false and was contradicted by footage from the officers’ BWCs, Officer #1 was shown portions of footage from his own BWC, as well as footage from the BWCs of Officer #2, Officer Officer #3, Sergeant #1, and Officer #4, and was questioned about what the footage depicted. Officer #1 agreed the footage showed a black bag, a green bottle, and a coffee mug on the kitchen counter. He further stated that he saw what he believed to be a digital scale to the right of the bag.
To illustrate his point that these items had been moved, Mr. Curry then showed Officer #1 photographs taken of these items when the search warrant was executed. Officer #1 acknowledged that the items had been moved during the execution of the warrant “to document the location of where we recovered those items.” He testified that he did not take a still photograph of the items when he first observed them.
Purpose of a Protective Sweep
Officer #1 also identified and discussed a portion of the footage from Sergeant #1’s BWC footage in which Sergeant #1 asked Officer #3 if a “sweep” had been conducted. Officer #1 explained that the purpose of a sweep was to “ensur[e] that there are no other individuals in there armed with a gun that may be dangerous.”.
From Protective Sweep to Search for Contraband
On cross-examination by the State, Officer #1 explained that the officers’ initial focus upon entering the apartment was “[E]nsuring the safety of everybody that was inside the residence and apprehending the individual that was shooting a gun in the street on Winton Terrace.” Officer #1 was then asked when his focus switched from the safety of the residents and the officers to looking for contraband. He responded, “Once everybody was safely placed into custody and placed in the back of police cruisers, the focus switched from safety to investigating the criminal activity that was occurring that day.”
Officer #1 stated that a bag with blue pills and a digital scale on the kitchen counter were recovered during the sweep.
Officer #1 also discussed the protective sweep on cross-examination. He was asked what items he looked for during the protective sweep and responded “[E]vidence of the crime of discharging firearms, guns, ammo, gun magazines, things of that nature.” Officer #1 stated that a bag with blue pills and a digital scale on the kitchen counter were recovered during the sweep. After Officer #1 saw these items, he left the scene and went to the police station to draft a search warrant and affidavit. His brother officers remained on the scene to secure the apartment.
A Second Protective Sweep Discovered the Firearm
Officer #1 testified that after he left the scene, a second protective sweep was conducted in the closed bedroom. Officer #1 was notified by Officer #4 that the dog was secured and that a black handgun was found lying in plain view on a bed. Officer #1 testified that he added the information about the recovered handgun to the affidavit, but that in his haste he mistakenly stated that “affiant” had seen the weapon, rather than his fellow officer.
The State presented testimony from Officer #4, who stated that his initial role upon arriving at the scene was to maintain a perimeter position on the apartment to ensure that the suspect did not flee. Officer #4 explained that after Mr. Curry and Ms. Brooks were taken into custody, his role changed to securing the apartment while a search warrant was obtained. Officer #4 was aware that a bedroom in the apartment had not yet been entered because it contained an aggressive dog. He testified that while he was standing by the back door, a neighbor approached him and explained that the dog, which was still inside the bedroom, was not aggressive and offered to take the dog. Officer #4 removed the dog from the bedroom and conducted a quick search of the room. He saw a black semiautomatic handgun lying on the bed. Officer #4 testified that he called Officer #1 to relay the information about the handgun so that Officer #1 could include that information in the search warrant affidavit.
Sergeant #1 Testimony
The State also presented testimony from Sergeant #1. His testimony concerned the Cincinnati Police Department’s policy regarding when an officer’s BWC should be activated. He testified that the BWCs were turned off during the protective sweep per department policy.
Mr. Curry Eschews the Plain View Doctrine
During closing argument, Mr. Curry argued that the officers could only have conducted a search incident to arrest in the areas immediately accessible to Mr. Curry, which did not include the kitchen or bedroom. He also argued that the plain-view doctrine was not applicable because the drugs and the item that the officers alleged to be a scale were not in plain view and were not immediately visible without moving other objects. Relatedly, he contended that the officers lacked probable cause to believe that the black bag by itself or “the item on the counter” was contraband unless other items had been moved around.
When Does a Protective Sweep Reasonably Conclude?
Mr. Curry further argued that “protective sweep does not apply” and that “[A]lthough it does cover a larger area, the officers don’t have any articulable facts that would warrant the officers to believe that the area harbored an individual posing a danger to those on the arrest scene.” In support, Mr. Curry noted that he and Ms. Brooks had been arrested and escorted out of the apartment, the gun that was the subject of the call had been recovered outside, and the officers had no indication that any other person was in the apartment. Mr. Curry argued that when he and Ms. Brooks were taken outside, “that ended the need to conduct a protective sweep when the arrest had been made.”
Inventible Discovery Doctrine?
Mr. Curry next contended that the search could not be justified under the doctrine of inevitable discovery. He concluded by stating that, even if the court were to find that the statements in the affidavit were not intentionally false, “they were based on impermissible uses of the plain view doctrine and protective sweep, rendering probable cause invalid for the search warrant.”
Reasonable Error or Untruthful?
The State argued in closing that Mr. Curry failed to establish that Officer #1 lied in the affidavit about whether the contraband referenced in the affidavit was in plain view. When it addressed the protective sweep, it said, “[The defense] makes the assumption that the officers had no threat, and, therefore, did not have any right to conduct the protective sweep, and, therefore, I assume, they’re lying. None of this raises to the level of perjury. None of this raises to anything that would make the warrant invalid.”
Trial Court Factual Determinations
The trial court set forth the following findings of fact in the decision: Police then used a battering ram and entered the residence approximately fifteen minutes after arriving on the scene. Police made their way through the residence’s hall and then the kitchen. The Defendant was not visible. A dog was barking within the residence. First, the female occupant leaves and is detained by police. The Defendant finally complies with police commands and lies on the floor. He is then taken into custody. The large dog is still barking in the bedroom. At the command of Sergeant Kopenhaver [sic], the police sweep the residence to look for other individuals. They leave the dog in the bedroom after checking for more people. The two individuals are taken into custody. The ranking officer then gives the command to turn off the body worn cameras. While sweeping the residence but without the body worn cameras activated, Officer #1 saw a bag of blue pills and what appears to be a scale in the corner of the kitchen just below the visible syringe . . . The scale turned out to be a cell phone. Based on the items viewed Officer #1 sought a search warrant. The officers then proceeded to secure the residence and wait for the search warrant. While enroute toget the search warrant Officer #4 called Officer #1 and stated that they secured the dog in the bedroom (gave it to neighbor eventually) and discovered another firearm in the bedroom on a bed.
Trial Court Denies the Motion to Suppress
The trial court found that Mr. Curry failed to establish that the affidavit in support of the search warrant contained false representations. It stated that Mr. Curry “only offered the omission of body worn camera as proof of the falsity of Officer #1’s affidavit. This is insufficient to support Defendant’s claim.”
Trial Court Conclusion is Based on an Incorrect Application of the Law
The trial court also found Mr. Curry’s argument that the protective sweeps were unconstitutional to be without merit. After setting forth the applicable law on protective sweeps, the court stated that “[T]he Defendant does not take issue with the protective sweep but in only so far as to the discovery of the narcotics. The Court concludes that there were specific and articulable facts for the Cincinnati Police to search for other assailants, other firearms, and other possible persons in the residence.”
Mr. Curry is Sentenced to Five Years in Prison
Mr. Curry subsequently pled no contest to all charges and received an aggregate sentence of 60 months of imprisonment. He now appeals.
First District Court of Appeals
In his first assignment of error, Mr. Curry argues that the trial court erred in denying his motion to suppress. Mr. Curry challenges both the trial court’s determination that the officers were justified in conducting the protective sweeps before the warrant was obtained and its determination that he did not meet his burden of establishing that the officers made intentionally false statements in the search warrant affidavit.
Established Case Law – Protective Sweep
“‘The touchstone of the Fourth Amendment is reasonableness.’” State v. Leak, 2016-Ohio-154, ¶ 14, quoting Florida v. Jimeno, 500 U.S. 248, 250 (1991). Unreasonable searches and seizures are prohibited by the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution and Article 1, Section 14 of the Ohio Constitution. Wright, 2022-Ohio-2161, at ¶ 12 (1st Dist.). Absent an exception, warrantless searches are per se unreasonable. State v. Whitfield, 2020-Ohio-2929, ¶ 10 (1st Dist.).
Entry was Lawful Under the Exigent Circumstance – Someone Inside was in Danger
Mr. Curry does not dispute that the initial warrantless entry into the apartment was constitutionally permissible under the exigent-circumstances exception to the warrant requirement. See State v. Applegate, 68 Ohio St.3d 348, 349 (1994), quoting Katz v. United States, 389 U.S. 347, 357 (1967) (“A warrantless police entry into a private residence is not unlawful if made upon exigent circumstances, a ‘specifically established and well-delineated exceptio[n]’ to the search warrant requirement.”); State v. Buck, 2017-Ohio-8242, ¶ 19-20 (1st Dist.), quoting Michigan v. Tyler, 436 U.S. 499, 509 (1978) (“Where exigent circumstances exist, a warrantless search is reasonable because ‘there is a compelling need for official action and no time to secure a warrant.’”). Thus we express no opinion on the initial warrantless entry.
Contraband was Not in Plain View
However, there was no testimony at the suppression hearing, and the trial court did not find, that any of the contraband listed in the search warrant affidavit was in plain view of and seen by the officers during the initial warrantless entry into the apartment before Ms. Brooks and Mr. Curry were arrested.
Body Cameras Were Turned Off
The trial court specifically found that after Ms. Brooks and Mr. Curry were taken into custody, and after the officers had turned off their BWCs, the officers conducted a protective sweep of the residence, during which they found contraband in plain view. The testimony at the suppression hearing supports these factual findings and the parties do not dispute them.
Although we accept the trial court’s findings of fact, we must disagree with its legal conclusion.
The trial court concluded that the warrantless protective sweep was lawful because “there were specific and articulable facts for the Cincinnati Police to search for other assailants, other firearms, and other possible persons in the residence.” Although we accept the trial court’s findings of fact, we must disagree with its legal conclusion.
An In-Home Protective Sweep is Premised on an Individual Who May Pose a Danger – Not a Search for Contraband
A protective sweep is an exception to the warrant requirement. State v. Mathews, 2015-Ohio-1047, ¶ 10 (2d Dist.); State v. Levengood, 2016-Ohio-1340, ¶ 23 (5th Dist.). “A ‘protective sweep’ is a quick and limited search of premises, incident to an arrest and conducted to protect the safety of police officers or others.” Maryland v. Buie, 494 U.S. 325, 327 (1990); accord State v. Adams, 2015-Ohio-3954, ¶ 188. Protective sweeps are permissible where the searching officer “possessed a reasonable belief based on specific and articulable facts which, taken together with the rational inferences from those facts, reasonably warranted the officer in believing that the area swept harbored an individual posing a danger to the officer or others.” Buie at 327; accord State v. Gill, 2024-Ohio-2792, ¶ 95 (1st Dist.). Where a protective sweep is justified, it must “last no longer than is necessary to dispel the reasonable suspicion of danger.” Buie at 335-336; Gill at ¶ 95.
First, contrary to the trial court’s holding, a protective sweep does not permit officers to search for “other firearms.” The purpose of a protective sweep is not to search for weapons, but rather to ensure “that the area swept [does not] harbor an individual posing a danger to the officer or others.” Buie at 327.
Second, there were not “specific and articulable” facts in this case to support a reasonable belief that the apartment harbored an individual that could pose a danger to the officers. See Buie, 494 U.S. at 327. The officers responded to 5489 Gardenview Lane in response to a report that an individual was firing gunshots in the street. They saw the individual in question dispose of the firearm outside and they recovered the weapon. The officers subsequently entered the apartment, secured both Ms. Brooks and Mr. Curry, and removed them from the apartment.
Court Assumes that People Who May Cause the Officers Harm Would have been Outside the Residence in the Previous Fifteen Minutes
No Chance They would have been inside the residence for greater than sixteen minutes?
It was not until Ms. Brooks and Mr. Curry were taken outside that the officers conducted the first protective sweep. And at that time, they had not been presented with any “specific and articulable facts” that the apartment harbored an individual that could pose a danger to their safety. The BWCs showed that, before breaching entrance into the apartment, the officers had surveilled it for approximately 15 minutes. There was no testimony at the suppression hearing that, during that period, the officers saw or suspected that anyone else entered the apartment.
Court Applies the Totality of the Circumstance Doctrine that is Reasonable
Other than the back bedroom, the officers could plainly see that the apartment harbored no other individual. And Officer #1 testified that the officers had not heard anyone else moving around the apartment. No officer testified that police were concerned that there was another person in the bedroom. This lack of concern is evident from the officers’ comments on the BWC recordings. It was clear that officers were only concerned that there was an aggressive dog in the bedroom.
Establish Case Law – Protective Sweep
But in McLemore the Arrest Occurred Outside the Home
The facts of this case are similar to those in State v. McLemore, 2012- Ohio-521 (2d Dist.). In McLemore, officers responded to a call for a domestic dispute. Id. at ¶ 3. The defendant exited from the apartment that officers had surrounded and was secured. Id. Several officers then entered the residence to conduct a protective sweep because they were concerned that it might harbor other individuals that could pose a threat to them as they detained the defendant. Id. During the protective sweep, officers saw shotgun shells and a gun cabinet with a firearm missing. Id.
The trial court held that the protective sweep of the apartment was unconstitutional, id. at ¶ 5, and the Second District agreed, id. at ¶ 14. The Second District noted, “No perpetrators other than Defendant were implicated in the domestic violence incident for which Defendant was arrested,” and that, after the defendant was taken into custody, “there was no suggestion either that another person or persons remained inside that residence or that they posed a threat to the safety of the officers or others.” Id. at ¶ 11. The court further explained,
Upon arrival, four police officers surrounded the house, and they did not see anyone or hear any voices coming from inside the home. The officers never asked defendant if anyone else was inside the home, and they did not knock on the door or call out to inquire about any other person’s presence. After defendant exited the home and was taken into police custody outside the home, he no longer had access to any weapons or evidence inside the residence and posed no threat to the officers or anyone else. Id. at ¶ 12. [Emphasis added] The court rejected an argument that the protective sweep was justified because the officers were unaware if anyone else was in the apartment, stating, “Not knowing whether anyone else was inside the residence is an insufficient pretext for a protective sweep to learn whether anyone is, in fact, inside.” Id. at ¶ 13.
Establish Case Law – Protective Sweep
Another Arrest Outside the Home – State v. Sharpe
The facts of this case are also similar to State v. Sharpe, 2008-Ohio-267 (2d Dist.). In Sharpe, the police had a warrant to arrest Sharpe on a domestic-violence charge. Id. at ¶ 3. After receiving a tip that Sharpe could be found at a particular residence and that he might have a firearm, officers were dispatched to the specified location. Id. at ¶ 5. After several hours, Sharpe exited from the residence, surrendered to the police, and was taken into custody. Id. at ¶ 9. [Emphasis added] Officers then entered the residence to conduct a protective sweep, where they discovered drugs. Id. at ¶ 10 and 14. Sharpe filed a motion to suppress challenging the warrantless protective sweep of the residence. Id. at ¶ 18. The trial court denied the motion. Id. at ¶ 19.
The Second District reversed. Id. at ¶ 47. It explained that before a protective sweep may be conducted, officers must have “some positive indication that another person or persons remain in the residential premises where a subject is arrested and that they pose a threat to the safety of officers or others.” Id. at ¶ 46. The court noted that “[M]ere suspicion” that a weapon may be inside a residence is insufficient to justify a protective sweep, as is lack of knowledge as to whether any other persons are present. Id.
Second District Applies Non-Applicable Case Law to Uphold Their Decision
As in McLemore and Sharpe, once the officers in this case secured Ms. Brooks and Mr. Curry outside of the apartment, those two individuals no longer had access to any weapons, and the officers had no suggestion or reason to believe that any other person was in the residence. Under these circumstances, the officers lacked “a reasonable belief, based on specific and articulable facts,” that the apartment “harbored an individual posing a danger to the officer[s] or others.” See Buie, 494 U.S. at 327.
The State, to its credit, seems to concede this determination. It stated in its appellate brief that “to the extent that [Mr. Curry] raised the propriety of the ‘protective sweep’ in the first place, Defendant may actually have a fair point.” The State elaborated on this concession, stating, While the trial court ultimately found to the contrary, here the officers offered little in the way of ‘specific and articulable facts,’ beyond that of the closed bedroom door, that would have reasonably led them to believe that a ‘protective sweep’ was necessary in order to ensure their safety from some undetermined third party after they had already arrested and removed Defendant and Ms. Brooks (and themselves) from the apartment.
Holding – Protective Sweep was Unreasonable
We accordingly hold that the warrantless protective sweeps, during which the officers saw the drugs and weapon in plain view, were conducted in violation of Mr. Curry’s rights under the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution and Article 1, Section 14 of the Ohio Constitution.
Inevitable Discovery of the Firearm was Unreasonable
Note: Because the Inevitable Discovery Doctrine was not argued at trial it cannot be appealed. The court evaluated this appeal in detail though it is not evaluated in this article.
For the foregoing reasons, we hold that the trial court erred by denying Mr. Curry’s motion to suppress. We therefore reverse the judgment of conviction and remand the cause to the trial court for further proceedings consistent with the law and this opinion.
Information for this article was obtained from State v. Curry 2025 – Ohio – 2083.
State v. Curry 2025 – Ohio – 2083 was issued by the First District Appellate Court on June 13, 2025 and is binding in Hamilton County, Ohio.
Lessons Learned:
- Protective Sweep – There are two types of protective sweeps; one for a vehicle and that doctrine was established on and the other is for a home. The vehicle Protective Sweep Doctrine, established on July 6, 1983, Michigan v. Long, 463 U.S. 1032 (1983), will not be evaluated in this article. On February 28, 1990 the U.S. Supreme Court in Maryland v. Buie, 494 U.S. 325 (1990) held “We … hold as incident to arrest the officer could, as precautionary matter and incident to the arrest the officer could, as a precautionary matter and without probable cause or reasonable suspicion look in closets and other spaces immediately adjoining the place of arrest from which an attack could be immediately launched.”. To my knowledge an in-home protective sweep is THE ONLY law enforcement doctrine that does not require either reasonable suspicion or probable cause. However, to affect an in-home Protective Sweep this must begin with an in-home arrest. Thereafter to protect the arresting officers, other officers may search the rooms immediately adjoining looking for people who may initiate an attack, if the officers obtain additional information that people may launch an attack the search for persons. The U.S. Supreme Court described this extended search “The Fourth Amendment permits a properly limited protective sweep in conjunction with an in-home arrest when the searching officer possesses a reasonable belief based on specific and articulable facts that the area to be swept harbors an individual posing a danger to those on the arrest scene.”. The court describes this more expansive search provided there is a ‘reasonable belief’ there are people inside the home that may cause harm. The reasonable belief is a not a legal standard that that can be accurately contrasted with either reasonable suspicion or probable cause. However, courts are going to require some information to expand the search such as noises coming from rooms that are not ‘immediately adjoining’. In this case the officers did not have any information or ‘reasonable belief’ that a person was secluded in the room with the barking dog.
- Established Case Law – In this case, the First District Appellate Court applied two cases to establish a foundation for the analysis: State v. McLemore, 2012- Ohio-521 and State v. Sharpe, 2008-Ohio-267. In both of these other cases the Second District Appellate Court held that the in-home Protective Sweeps were unreasonable. Yet, both McLemore and Sharpe BEGAN with arrests OUTSIDE of the home. To apply the Protective Sweep Doctrine, it must begin with the in-home arrest. Consequently, I believe the court came to the correct decision in this Curry case but McLemore and Sharpe should not have been used to establish a foundation for analysis because the arrests were made outside the home.
- Plain View Doctrine – On June 4, 1990 the U.S. Supreme Court issued Horton v. California, 496 U.S. 128 (1990) that established the three part Plain View Doctrine: 1) Law must be legally on the premises from where the observation is made; 2) Law enforcement must not violate the Fourth Amendment to make the observation and 3) Incriminating nature of the item must be immediately apparent. In this case Mr. Curry successfully argued that the officers violated the Fourth Amendment to open the bedroom door because there no ‘reasonable belief’ that someone was behind the door with the barking dog.
- Improvement – Assure that you and your teammates train on the Protective Sweep Doctrine. I believe that the Protective Sweep Doctrine is THE most under-utilized legal doctrine in all of law enforcement. However, to utilize the doctrine it must begin with an in-home arrest. The Protective Sweep follows the in-home arrest is a search for humans that may cause harm to the arresting officers.
Does your agency train on the In-Home Protective Sweep Doctrine?
Don’t fail your training.
Don’t let your training fail you!
Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!