Mr. Sigurani had been orally notified by Mr. Desmond, the [Mediation Response Unit] MRU, and the responding police officers that his presence at the apartment building was not authorized. As such, “actual communication to the offender” about the trespass had occurred.
State v. Sigurani
Second District Appellate Court
Montgomery County
May 2, 2025
Why is this case important?
State v. Sigurani provides a review of Criminal Trespass and what constitutes a violation after someone is given consent to be on the property.
Background
Mr. Verti Sigurani was arrested on July 31, 2024, and charged by complaint on August 1, 2024, in Dayton Municipal Court with obstructing official business, failure to disclose one’s personal information, and criminal trespass. He pled not guilty the same day.
Mr. Sigurani was tried on August 14 and was found guilty of each of the offenses. The same day, he was sentenced to jail terms for each offense, with credit for 15 days and the remainder of each sentence suspended. The court also imposed a post- conviction no contact order that required Mr. Sigurani to have no contact with the complainant in the criminal trespass for three years and ordered him not to possess any deadly weapons during the period of the order.
Mr. Sigurani appeals.
Note: Mr. Sigurani filed an appeal on the trial court judge failing to grant a continuance. That appeal will not be evaluated in this article but this was the court’s holding on that appeal:
We are also unpersuaded by Mr. Sigurani’s strained suggestion that the prosecutor’s office should have been bound by the prior prosecutor’s alleged agreement to delay the trial, which was evidenced only by defense counsel’s statements.
Mr. Desmond Accuses Mr. Sigurani of Trespassing
The complainant in the criminal trespass offense, Joshua Desmond, testified that he was the manager of an apartment building with addresses of 301 to 309 Troy Street and 1217 and 1219 Kiefer Street in Dayton. Mr. Desmond was acquainted with Mr. Sigurani, who had been working at Mr. Desmond’s father’s farm. According to Mr. Desmond, Mr. Sigurani had been “originally picked up” by Mr. Desmond’s father in early July and had stayed at Mr. Desmond’s apartment building for a night at that time. Then, Mr. Sigurani went to Mr. Desmond’s father’s house to do work and stay in a camper; Mr. Desmond saw Mr. Sigurani occasionally. Then, in late July, Mr. Desmond was told by his father that Mr. Sigurani was no longer welcome because of an altercation the previous day. Mr. Sigurani went to the apartment building; he was told by Mr. Desmond’s father that he was allowed to stay for one night and was offered $100 “to catch a bus.” The next day, Wednesday afternoon (July 31, 2024), Mr. Desmond and his father told Mr. Sigurani that he (Mr. Sigurani) needed to move on and was no longer welcome. In other words, according to Mr. Desmond, Mr. Sigurani was trespassed from the apartment building; he was told he had to leave multiple times. Mr. Desmond testified that Mr. Sigurani did not have a deposit or a lease at any of the apartment units.
Dispute Over Verbal Agreement Led to “call the police”
According to Mr. Desmond, Mr. Sigurani responded that it was up to him (Mr. Sigurani) when he was going to vacate the apartment. The conversation continued for 10 to 15 minutes. Mr. Desmond then called the police, and a Mediation Response Unit (“MRU”) arrived. Mr. Desmond overheard the conversation between MRU and Mr. Sigurani; he hoped that the mediators would be able to talk him into leaving on his own, but Mr. Sigurani, who was in the apartment, shut the door, stopped communication, and said “call the police.”
Mr. Desmond had Consent to Sleepover One Night
The police were contacted by MRU, and Mr. Desmond waited for them to arrive. Mr. Desmond explained the situation to the responding officers, and he observed them speak to Mr. Sigurani from a distance. Mr. Desmond still hoped that Mr. Sigurani would leave on his own accord without being arrested. Mr. Desmond stated that, although his father had allowed Mr. Sigurani to stay one night, as the manager of the building, he (Mr. Desmond) had the authority to make Mr. Sigurani leave.
Trespass Charge Filed
Mr. Desmond testified that he also went to the Safety Building downtown to speak to a prosecutor, Gravunder, and that he was referred to the Dayton Municipal Court. He filed a complaint for criminal trespass against Mr. Sigurani on August 1, 2024, and he identified this document at trial.
Mr. Sigurani eventually “shut down and stopped communication all together.”
Officer Joshua Blankley of the Dayton Police Department testified that on July 31, 2024, he responded to the area of 301 Troy Street as requested by MRU as a crisis intervention trained officer (“CIT”). Officer Terrell Moore, another CIT, also arrived. According to Officer Blankley’s testimony, Mr. Sigurani initially stated that he had been told by another police officer that if he resided somewhere for two weeks, he had “residency.” The officers walked Mr. Sigurani across the street to provide some separation the MRU and “one of the stake holders from the property,” then they tried to “work with” Mr. Sigurani. Officer Blankley stated that Mr. Desmond’s father informed the officers that Mr. Sigurani had been trespassed from the property. Officer Blankley tried to talk to Mr. Sigurani and get his information to verify whether he was trespassing. Ultimately, Mr. Sigurani was informed by both the officers and the mediator that he needed to leave the property, and he was offered transportation to the Gateway Shelter, but Mr. Sigurani eventually “shut down and stopped communication all together.”.

Did Mr. Sigurani have a legal privilege to remain at 301 Troy Street or was he trespassing?
Mr. Sigurani’s Unsubstantiated Evidence
According to Officer Blankley, before Mr. Sigurani “shut down,” he had provided several different timeframes for his “residence” at the apartment, from two weeks to “some months.” When Officer Blankley asked him to provide a lease or any kind of documentation, Mr. Sigurani claimed he had evidence but was never able to provide it, despite being given an opportunity to retrieve it. He stated that it was unclear what Mr. Sigurani meant by “evidence.”.
Mr. Sigurani is Arrested as John Doe for Failing to Leave or Provide his Personal Information
Regarding the alleged trespass, Officer Blankley testified that Mr. Desmond had provided Mr. Sigurani’s name. Officer Blankley ran the name through law enforcement computer systems and got no “returns” that provided him with a Social Security number, date of birth, or anything else that could be used to further identify Mr. Sigurani. Officer Blankley testified that, in the law enforcement context, he could not simply accept an individual’s statement as to his or her identification; some documentation identifying that individual was required. After the computer check, Mr. Sigurani was given an additional opportunity to provide identifying information which would allow the officers to confirm whether he had been trespassed or was then trespassing on the property. Officer Blankley decided to arrest him for criminal trespass when he continued to refuse to leave the property that day. Mr. Sigurani was booked into the jail as a “John Doe”; several hours later, an FBI fingerprint database confirmed his identity.
Mr. Sigurani’s identity had been confirmed at the jail
Officer Blankley testified that Mr. Sigurani’s refusal to cooperate or to leave the premises had obstructed Officer Blankley’s ability to perform his duties. He stated that, if Mr. Sigurani had provided his identification information, the officers could have resolved the trespassing issue more quickly and easily and moved forward with finding Mr. Sigurani a new residence or at least getting him off the property. Officer Blankley was on scene with Mr. Sigurani for 30 to 45 minutes, and then once Mr. Sigurani’s identity had been confirmed at the jail, Officer Blankley, who had resumed routine patrol, had to return to the jail to update his written report and create a new booking under the proper identification.
What Personal Information is a Suspect Required to Provide?
On cross-examination, Officer Blankley reiterated that he had been given Mr. Sigurani’s first and last name in the call comments from MRU, but no address, date of birth, or Social Security number, so there “was nothing to corroborate that name,” notwithstanding his search in state, local, and nationwide law enforcement databases. After the FBI database returned a match, Officer Blankley learned that Mr. Sigurani was a resident of Arizona, and Officer Blankley was able to enter his address, Social Security number, and date of birth into the booking. Officer Blankley was not able to confirm a previous criminal trespass complaint. On redirect, Officer Blankley stated that Mr. Sigurani had been required by law to provide his name and date of birth and failed to do so. The August 1, 2024 complaint for criminal trespass signed by Mr. Desmond against Mr. Sigurani was admitted into evidence as State’s Exhibit 1.
Defense Counsel Argued that Mr. Sigurani had Not Been Previously Trespassed from the Property
Defense counsel moved for an acquittal. She argued that Officer Blankley had been provided with Mr. Sigurani’s name, and there had been “no delay or obstruction.” Counsel asserted that there was no evidence presented that Mr. Sigurani had ever been trespassed from the property previously. The court denied the motion and proceeded to find Mr. Sigurani guilty on all three charges.
Mr. Sigurani Argues He had a Privilege to be on the Property
Mr. Sigurani makes several points in support of his sufficiency and manifest weight arguments. Regarding the trespass offense, Mr. Sigurani asserts that “he had privilege as a tenant to be on the property,” and that Mr. Desmond’s father had brought him to the property and given him permission to stay. Regarding failure to disclose his identification, Mr. Sigurani contends that, because he “was not detained and was free to go,” he was not under any obligation to provide identifying information. Finally, regarding obstructing official business, Mr. Sigurani asserts that he committed no overt act, citing State v. Prestle, 2005-Ohio-2536 (2d Dist.). According to Mr. Sigurani, the charge was based upon his alleged failure to disclose his name, even though the officers knew his name and had in fact run a computer check which revealed nothing; he contends that Officer Blankley “chose” to book Mr. Sigurani as a John Doe, and thus it was the officer’s decision and not Mr. Sigurani’s action which allegedly caused more work for the officer.
Failure to Disclose
Mr. Sigurani’s conviction for failure to disclose was supported by sufficient evidence
O.R.C. §2921.29(A)(1) states: “No person who is in a public place shall refuse to disclose the person’s name, address, or date of birth, when requested by a law enforcement officer who reasonably suspects . . . [t]he person is committing, has committed, or is about to commit a criminal offense.” Officer Blankley testified that he and Officer Moore had responded to the scene after being contacted by MRU on the report of a criminal trespass, and Mr. Desmond had confirmed that Mr. Sigurani was trespassing. Mr. Sigurani refused to leave the property with no evidence of a legitimate basis to be there. Thus, the officers reasonably suspected that Mr. Sigurani was committing or had committed a criminal offense. Mr. Sigurani refused to disclose his name, address, or date of birth when Officer Blankley repeatedly asked him to do so. Based on this evidence, Mr. Sigurani’s conviction for failure to disclose was supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
Obstructing Official Business
O.R.C. §2921.31 proscribes obstructing official business and states: “No person, without privilege to do so and with purpose to prevent, obstruct, or delay the performance by a public official of any authorized act within the public official’s official capacity, shall do any act that hampers or impedes a public official in the performance of the public official’s lawful duties.” “‘Ohio courts have consistently held that in order to violate the obstructing official business statute a defendant must engage in some affirmative or overt act or undertaking that hampers or impedes a public official in the performance of the official’s lawful duties.’ ” State v. Harrell, 2007-Ohio-4550, ¶ 12 (2d Dist.), quoting State v. Prestel, 2005-Ohio-5236, ¶ 16 (2d Dist.).
Established Case Law – Obstructing Official Business
In State v. Folley, 2011-Ohio-4539 (2d Dist.), law enforcement officers responded to an apartment building on a complaint of a criminal trespass. Folley was involved in an argument and creating a disturbance outside the building. Id. at ¶ 2. Apartment management wanted her removed because she refused to leave on her own. After an officer told Folley to leave, she began to walk toward the entrance to the building, stating that she did not have to leave; she was then arrested for criminal trespass and placed in a cruiser. Id. at ¶ 3. She refused to provide any personal information. Id. The officers eventually obtained her identifying information from the apartment leasing office. Folley was convicted of obstructing official business and failure to disclose her identity, and she appealed. Id. at ¶ 4.
A Person Must be Suspected of a Crime to be Successfully Prosecuted for Fail to Disclose
As to the obstructing official business offense, Folley argued on appeal that her refusal to provide the officers with any personal information, standing alone, could not form the basis of a conviction for obstructing official business; the State asserted that Folley’s affirmative act had been attempting to enter the apartment building after being told to leave. Id. at ¶ 10. The State relied on Prestle, 2005-Ohio-2536 (2d Dist.), but we distinguished that case, noting that the defendant in Prestle had not been under arrest at the time that he refused to provide his personal information and had not been suspected of criminal activity. Id. But Folley had refused to provide her personal information to officers after she was arrested for criminal trespass and after she attempted to walk toward the entrance of the apartment building, at which point the officers both had already directed her to leave the property. Id. at ¶ 11. We concluded that, under those circumstances, “Folley’s refusal to provide identifying information was an affirmative act which clearly interfered with the officers’ ability to perform their duties upon the trespass arrest and delayed their clearing of the call.” Id.
Failing to Disclose Personal Information is an Affirmative Act Under Obstructing Official Business
The same is true in this case. Officers arrested Mr. Sigurani for the criminal trespass after spending 30-45 minutes asking him for proof of his residence at the building and, in the absence of such evidence, trying to get him to leave. Thereafter, he failed to disclose his information as required by law for someone suspected of criminal activity. His refusal to provide his identifying information before and after his arrest interfered with Officer Blankley and Officer Moore’s ability to perform their duties and delayed their ability to clear the call.
We note that Adm.Code 5120:1-8-01, which sets forth the standards to which all jails must adhere in the reception and release of inmates, states that a booking and identification record will be made of every commitment that includes the name, the date of birth, the home address and telephone number, and the Social Security number of each inmate. Adm.Code 5120:1-8-01(C)(2),(5),(9),(11). Officer Blankley had to initially enter Mr. Sigurani into the jail as a “John Doe” and subsequently interrupt his patrol duties to return to the jail to update his written report and enter Mr. Sigurani’s correct information because Mr. Sigurani had not provided the information initially. Under these circumstances, Mr. Sigurani’s conviction for obstructing official business was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
Criminal Trespass and Privilege
For criminal trespass, Mr. Sigurani was convicted of violating O.R.C. §2911.21(A)(3), which states: “No person, without privilege to do so, shall . . . [r]ecklessly enter or remain on the land or premises of another, as to which notice against unauthorized access or presence is given by actual communication to the offender.” “ ‘Privilege,’ as that term is utilized in Ohio’s criminal statutes, ‘means an immunity, license, or right conferred by law, or bestowed by express or implied grant, or arising out of status, position, office, or relationship, or growing out of necessity.’ ” State v. Clelland, 83 Ohio App.3d 474, 490 (4th Dist. 1992), quoting former R.C. 2901.01(L), now R.C. 2901.01(A)(12). See also State v. Johnson, 2002-Ohio-6471, ¶ 7 (11th Dist.) (finding an oral advisement sufficient to put the defendant on notice where an officer testified that he had advised the defendant that he was banned from the property).
Mr. Sigurani’s conviction for criminal trespass was supported by sufficient evidence
Mr. Sigurani had been orally notified by Mr. Desmond, the MRU, and the responding police officers that his presence at the apartment building was not authorized. As such, “actual communication to the offender” about the trespass had occurred, and Mr. Sigurani nonetheless remained at the property, refusing to leave, until his arrest. Mr. Sigurani’s conviction for criminal trespass was supported by sufficient evidence and was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
The second assignment of error is overruled.
Conclusion and Holding
An abuse of discretion is not demonstrated in the denial of Mr. Sigurani’s motion for a continuance, and his convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and not against the manifest weight of the evidence. Accordingly, the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
Information for this article was obtained from State v. Sigurani, 2025 – Ohio – 1573.
State v. Sigurani, 2025 – Ohio – 1573 was issued by the Second District Appellate Court on May 2, 2025 and is binding in the following Ohio Counties: Champaign, Clark, Darke, Greene, Miami and Montgomery.
Lessons Learned:
- Criminal Trespass – To arrest and sustain a conviction for O.R.C. §2911.21(A)(3), which states: “No person, without privilege to do so, shall . . . [r]ecklessly enter or remain on the land or premises of another, as to which notice against unauthorized access or presence is given by actual communication to the offender.”; the actual communication element can be either verbal or written. Additionally, there does not need to be a previous incident. If the suspect is refusing to leave the property by the owner or authorized agent, the suspect may be charged.
- Privilege – A person may not be convicted of Criminal Trepass if they have the legal ‘privilege’ to be on the property. Privilege,’ as that term is utilized in Ohio’s criminal statutes, ‘means an immunity, license, or right conferred by law, or bestowed by express or implied grant, or arising out of status, position, office, or relationship, or growing out of necessity.’. Mr. Sigurani reasonably argued that since Mr. Desmond’s father had permitted him to stay the night before he had ‘privilege’ to remain on the property. However, someone’s privilege to be on the property may be revoked. In this case, Mr. Sigurani’s privilege was revoked and he had to leave the property. Though Privilege was a reasonable argument, once he was told to leave the privilege was revoked and Mr. Sigurani should have left.
- Failure to Disclose Personal Information – To arrest and sustain a conviction for O.R.C. §2921.29(A)(1) states: “No person who is in a public place shall refuse to disclose the person’s name, address, or date of birth, when requested by a law enforcement officer who reasonably suspects . . . [t]he person is committing, has committed, or is about to commit a criminal offense.”; the person must first be suspected of a criminal offense. Thereafter a law enforcement may only request the person’s name, date of birth and home address. In this case Mr. Sigurani defense counsel argued that Mr. Sigurani provided his name and when Officer Blankley ran that name through a law enforcement computer system that was sufficient to identify Mr. Sigurani. However, the name that Mr. Sigurani provided did not provide a match in the computer system, hence Mr. Sigurani was convicted of Failure to Disclose Personal Information. Law enforcement must specifically request name, address and date of birth and not an identification card. See Is Asking a Suspect for His Identification Card the Same as Requesting a Person’s Name, Address and Date of Birth?.
- Obstructing Official Business – O.R.C. §2921.31 proscribes obstructing official business and states: “No person, without privilege to do so and with purpose to prevent, obstruct, or delay the performance by a public official of any authorized act within the public official’s official capacity, shall do any act that hampers or impedes a public official in the performance of the public official’s lawful duties.”. The question in this case is whether Mr. Sigurani’s failure to disclose his personal information was an affirmative act that ‘hampered or impeded’ the officer’s trepass investigation. In this case the court held that failure to disclose personal information did in fact impede the officer’s investigation “Under these circumstances, Mr. Sigurani’s conviction for obstructing official business was supported by sufficient evidence.”.
- Pre-Sent Arms! Officer Joshua Blankley, Officer Terrell Moore and the Dayton City Attorney’s Office should all be commended for the investigation, prosecution and successful appeal opposition of Mr. Sigurani. Well done!
Does your agency train on Criminal Trespass, Failure to ID and Obstructing Official Business?
Don’t fail your training.
Don’t let your training fail you!
Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!