But Mr. Helms’s mental-health struggles did not bar the deputies from using the force required to get control of him and end his resistance—even if that resistance sprang from his delusions.

Helms v. Boyd County Sheriff’s Department

No. 24 – 5853

Sixth Circuit Appellate Court

June 17, 2025

 

Why is this case important?

Helms v. Boyd County Sheriff’s Department provides a review of the application of force on a person who is not under arrest but is in the process of being transported to a mental health facility.

Background

Brian “Rusty” Helms suffers from a mental illness that led a medical counselor to order his involuntary hospitalization. Mr. Helms called his mother when deputy sheriffs attempted to carry out this hospitalization order. While listening on the phone, his mother says that she heard the deputies mock Mr. Helms and gratuitously beat and tase him. But the deputies respond that they used the force required to overcome Mr. Helms’s resistance. And their firsthand accounts about what happened stand alone because Mr. Helms did not sit for a deposition. We thus must consider whether Mr. Helms’s mother created a genuine issue of material fact to dispute the deputies’ accounts by describing what she heard over the phone. We agree with the district court that she did not. And because the deputies used reasonable force under their view of events, the court properly granted them summary judgment on Mr. Helms’s excessive-force claim.

From Bricklayer to Meth Addict

Mr. Helms grew up in Ashland, Kentucky. After graduating from high school, he worked as a bricklayer. He unfortunately became addicted to methamphetamine while in his thirties, which exacerbated his struggles with anxiety and panic attacks. In 2017, he exhibited more serious mental-health problems. Mr. Helms started to suffer from “delusions” and “hallucinations” and showed signs of schizophrenia when off his medications.

Court Ordered Mental Health Order

In October 2017, Mr. Helms’s father petitioned a state court to involuntarily hospitalize Mr. Helms because he had been “threatening to harm” his family and himself. The petition noted that Mr. Helms was suffering from “psychotic breaks 24/7,” “stuck in [a] delusional state,” “[E]xtremely paranoid,” and “[A]ggressive.” Id. It added that Mr. Helms had asked his “parents to take him in the woods and shoot him in the head.” Id. The court ordered the Boyd County Sheriff’s Department to take Mr. Helms to Pathways, a mental-health provider, for an evaluation and possible hospitalization.

Delay in Enforcing the Order

The sheriff’s department failed to fulfill this order for over a month. After a phone call from Mr. Helms’s father, department staff stated that they would dispatch someone to transport Mr. Helms to Pathways on November 29. That morning, two deputy sheriffs took Mr. Helms into custody and transported him for his evaluation.

Egyptian Artifacts and Disarming Police Officers

Sergeant Carl Hall with the sheriff’s department met Mr. Helms at Pathways. While waiting on a medical counselor to complete the evaluation, Sgt. Hall tried to develop a rapport with Mr. Helms by talking about, among other things, their family connections. Sgt. Hall could tell that Mr. Helms was struggling with his mental health because Mr. Helms made many incoherent statements (including about collecting “Egyptian artifacts”). More disturbingly, Mr. Helms noted that he knew “how to disarm police officers.”.

A Kentucky Pink Slip and Mr. Hall Threatens to Sue

The medical counselor eventually told Sgt. Hall (in Mr. Helms’s presence) that Mr. Helms must go to Eastern State Hospital for a 72-hour commitment. According to this counselor, Mr. Helms’s drug abuse had caused him to experience paranoid delusions, psychosis, and suicidal ideation. The counselor hoped that the hospitalization would stabilize Mr. Helms’s psychosis and “prevent harm to [him]self and others.” When Mr. Helms heard this order, though, he became visibly upset. Sgt. Hall tried to “de-escalate” things by telling Mr. Helms that he would seek to persuade the counselor to change his mind if Mr. Helms agreed to wait in Sgt. Hall’s cruiser. Mr. Helms obliged. But when Sgt. Hall told Mr. Helms that he could not budge the counselor from the hospitalization order, Mr. Helms began to hit his head on the car, threatened to sue everyone, and stated that he would not get out. Sgt. Hall drove an agitated Mr. Helms back to the sheriff’s department so that a transport deputy from the Boyd County Justice Center could take him to Eastern State Hospital.

A Phone Call to Mom

The parties dispute what happened back at the department. We start with the deputies’ accounts. The department assigned Deputy B.J. Kimmle to transport Mr. Helms. While waiting for Dep. Kimmle, Sgt. Hall noticed Mr. Helms in his cruiser’s backseat talking to his mom on the phone. Sgt. Hall made a mental note that they would have to secure this phone when they switched cars. Dep. Kimmle got delayed, so Sgt. Hall decided to drive Mr. Helms over to the Justice Center to make the transfer.

Future Plaintiff:

Fuck you, fuck them. Fuck this. I am not going.

When Sgt. Hall arrived there, he told Dep. Kimmle about Mr. Helms’s phone and his comments that he would not get out of Sgt. Hall’s cruiser. Dep. Kimmle opened the door to the cruiser and asked Mr. Helms for the phone. Mr. Helms responded: “Fuck you, fuck them. Fuck this. I am not going.” The deputies repeatedly ordered Mr. Helms to put his hands behind his back and to get out. But Mr. Helms resisted all efforts to extract him. Instead, he lay down in a supine position with his legs up and his left foot pulled back in an attempt to kick Dep. Kimmle. Sgt. Hall thus went to the vehicle’s other side to help remove him. Yet Mr. Helms continued to struggle and yell. Once the deputies’ verbal orders failed, Sgt. Hall escalated to using three compliance “strikes” to Mr. Helms’s back. When this force also did not work, Dep. Kimmle pulled Mr. Helms out of the car by the belt loops on his pants.

After Being Drive-Stunned for Two-Seconds Future Plaintiff: “Mr. Helms then “complie[d] readily” with the deputies and even apologized for his conduct.”

According to the deputies, Mr. Helms continued to struggle against their efforts to handcuff him while on the pavement. Sgt. Hall tried to grab Mr. Helms’s arms while Dep. Kimmle tried to get him on his stomach by his feet. In the meantime, Deputy David White had seen the commotion and come by to help. White decided to deploy his taser and alerted the others by shouting “Taser” several times. He used his taser in drive-stun mode. Mr. Helms immediately “quit fighting” and became “compliant,” so White turned off the Taser after only “two seconds” rather than wait the usual five. Mr. Helms then “complie[d] readily” with the deputies and even apologized for his conduct. Sgt. Hall. Dep. Kimmle handcuffed him. Sgt. Hall placed Mr. Helms’s phone on the transport vehicle. Dep. Kimmle eventually got Mr. Helms into that vehicle and began the drive to Eastern State.

Kathy Helms, Mr. Helms Mother Listed to the Incident on an Open Phone Line

During this encounter, Mr. Helms’s mother thought she heard something far different. Her son had called her while Sgt. Hall drove back from Pathways. This phone call ended up staying connected for some 30 to 45 minutes. Mr. Helms’s mother thus heard the struggle between Mr. Helms and the deputies.

Kathy Helms Disputed Recitation

At the start of the call, Mr. Helms complained about having to go to Eastern State. His mother tried to calm him down. She next said she was going to disconnect because she heard a deputy in the background order him to give up his phone. But she stayed on the line when Mr. Helms asked her not to hang up. Still, Mr. Helms believed that she had left and told a deputy: “See there, she hung up on me.” His mother then heard “scuffling” and her son “screaming out in pain and begging them to stop.” Id. She believes that the deputies called her son a “crazy psycho” and told him that he “had this coming all morning.”. (The deputies denied these statements.) She also heard a deputy say: “Tase the motherfucker.” The altercation lasted about “five to eight minutes.” Id., Mr. Helms repeatedly cried for help, and his mother yelled into the phone for the deputies to stop.

As the confrontation was ongoing, Mrs. Helms decided to drive to the sheriff’s department with the phone in her passenger seat. As she walked to her car, her husband and daughter arrived home and chose to accompany her. On her way to the department, she heard a deputy start “driving” Mr. Helms. Mr. Helms asked this deputy for a drink. The deputy responded with “more profanity” about Mr. Helms being a “psycho.” Id. He also allegedly added: “I’m taking you straight to Eastern and dropping you off. If you move, I’ll put a bullet in your head.” Id. For what it is worth, Dep. Kimmle admitted that he tried to make Mr. Helms compliant by saying that he should “stop moving” or Dep. Kimmle would “put a bullet in his ass.” Mr. Helms allegedly had been “thrashing around” in the transport vehicle.

The family then talked to Sheriff Bobby Jack Woods.

When the Mr. Helms family arrived at the sheriff’s department, they spotted Sergeant Sgt. Hall and asked to speak with him. Sgt. Hall responded: “Just as soon as I get your son’s blood off my hands.” The family then talked to Sheriff Bobby Jack Woods. Woods ordered Dep. Kimmle to return to the sheriff’s department. When Dep. Kimmle got back, Woods and Mr. Helms’s father checked on Mr. Helms. They disconnected the phone call. Mr. Helms had a cut on his head, a “busted lip,” “abrasion[s]” on his back, and “lacerations” on his legs.

Helms Family Sues Boyd County SO

As a result of these events, Mr. Helms brought this suit under 42 U.S.C. §1983 against (among other defendants) Boyd County, Sheriff Woods, Sergeant Sgt. Hall, and Deputies Kimmle and White. As relevant now, the complaint alleged that the deputies had used excessive force against Mr. Helms in violation of the Fourth Amendment. It also alleged that they had retaliated against him for his speech in violation of the First Amendment. And it alleged that they had treated him differently due to his disability in violation of the Equal Protection Clause. Mr. Helms sought to hold the County and Sheriff liable for the failure to adequately train the deputies.

Mr. Helms Incurred Worse Delusion Behaviors

Shortly after Mr. Helms sued, he began to suffer from even worse “delusional behaviors.” So a state court appointed his mother as his guardian and conservator. She took over this case on his behalf. According to his mother, Mr. Helms could not answer basic questions about the events. He thus did not sit for a deposition, did not provide a supporting affidavit, and would not have testified at trial.

Mr. Helms’s lack of participation all but doomed his case.

Mr. Helms’s lack of participation all but doomed his case. The district court held that his mother’s testimony about the phone call did not create a genuine dispute of material fact over the deputies’ claims that Mr. Helms had acted aggressively at the sheriff’s department. See Mr. Helms v. Boyd County Sheriff’s Dep’t, 2024 WL 3881842, at *4–7 (E.D. Ky. Aug. 20, 2024). And under the deputies’ version of events, the court added, they used reasonable force to restrain him. The court also rejected Mrs. Mr. Helms’s free-speech claim because she did not point to any protected speech. See id. at *7–8. It likewise rejected Mrs. Helms’s equal-protection claim because she lacked evidence that the deputies used force on Mr. Helms because of his disability. Lastly, the court held that Mrs. Helms could not assert a failure-to-train claim against Sheriff Woods in his personal capacity and that she could not hold Boyd County liable on this theory because she had not shown any underlying constitutional violation.

We review this decision de novo.

[H]er attempt to salvage her free-speech claim in her reply brief “came far ‘too late.’” She has thus forfeited these claims.

The briefing strategy of Mrs. Helms’s counsel has reduced the claims that we must consider on appeal. Her opening brief did not “adequately develop” any challenge to the dismissal of her free-speech or equal-protection claims against the deputies or her failure-to-train claims against Sheriff Woods and Boyd County. Blick v. Ann Arbor Pub. Sch. Dist., 105 F.4th 868, 881–82 (6th Cir. 2024). And her attempt to salvage her free-speech claim in her reply brief “came far ‘too late.’” She has thus forfeited these claims.

Excessive Force Claim Survives

This forfeiture leaves only an excessive-force claim under the Fourth Amendment against Sergeant Sgt. Hall and Deputies Kimmle and White. The deputies assert that they complied with the Fourth Amendment or, at the least, that they did not violate clearly established law and so should receive qualified immunity. See District of Columbia v. Wesby, 583 U.S. 48, 62–63 (2018). We opt to resolve this appeal on the constitutional merits under our established precedent.

Established Case Law – Mental Health Seizures

The Fourth Amendment prohibits police officers from making “unreasonable” “seizures” of individuals. U.S. Const. amend. IV. Courts typically consider the validity of a seizure when police officers arrest suspects for alleged criminal violations. See, e.g., Torres v. Madrid, 592 U.S. 306, 311–18 (2021); United States v. Watson, 423 U.S. 411, 415–24 (1976). But the Fourth Amendment’s language also restricts the government’s ability to seize individuals for mental- health reasons. See, e.g., Hoogland v. City of Maryville, 2022 WL 1773416, at *4 (6th Cir. June 1, 2022); Est. of Hill v. Miracle, 853 F.3d 306, 312–16 (6th Cir. 2017); Caie v. West Bloomfield Township, 485 F. App’x 92, 96–97 (6th Cir. 2012); Monday v. Oullette, 118 F.3d 1099, 1102–04 (6th Cir. 1997). To make that type of seizure, officers must have probable cause that individuals pose a danger to themselves or others. See Machan v. Olney, 958 F.3d 1212, 1214 (6th Cir. 2020). Mrs. Helms agrees that the deputies had this probable cause here because they were trying to take her son to Eastern State Hospital based on a court order and a counselor’s diagnosis.

Is There a Different Use of Force Standard for Mental Health Seizures?

Even if officers have probable cause for a mental-health seizure, though, they still must carry out the seizure in a reasonable way. See Monday, 118 F.3d at 1104. They thus may not use excessive force when taking an individual to a hospital. See Hoogland, 2022 WL 1773416, at *4. We evaluate whether force was excessive by considering the need for the force from the perspective of a reasonable officer under the totality of the circumstances. See Caie, 485 F. App’x at 95. And we balance a police officer’s interests in using the force against the individual’s interests in avoiding it. See Chaney-Snell v. Young, 98 F.4th 699, 715–16 (6th Cir. 2024). This balancing focuses on different factors for mental-health seizures than those that apply to criminal seizures. See Est. of Hill, 853 F.3d at 314. In the criminal context, for example, the reasonableness of force depends in part on the crime that an individual allegedly committed (the more serious the crime, the more reasonable the force). See Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386, 396 (1989). But this factor makes little sense for mental-health seizures because individuals suffering from mental impairments have not thereby committed crimes. See Est. of Hill, 853 F.3d at 314. In that context, then, we instead ask such questions as whether individuals posed an immediate risk of harm to themselves or others and whether the amount of force was reasonably necessary. See id.

Established Case Law – Use of Force on Mental Health Seizures

Under this framework, we have generally upheld the use of a taser and similar levels of force when individuals actively resist an officer’s attempts to take control of them. See Roell v. Hamilton County, 870 F.3d 471, 482–83 (6th Cir. 2017); Hagans v. Franklin Cnty. Sheriff’s Off., 695 F.3d 505, 509 (6th Cir. 2012); Caie, 485 F. App’x at 96. Consider Caie. There, a man’s friends alerted authorities that he was intoxicated and suicidal. See Caie, 485 F. App’x at 93–94. When officers found the man in a lake, he asked them to shoot him. Id. at 94. After he came to the shore, the officers tried to arrest him to take him to a hospital. Id. But he refused to comply and tried to run from the officers “while flailing his arms violently.” Id. So the officers took the man to the ground and eventually tased him when he resisted their handcuffing efforts. Id. We found this force reasonable. Id. at 96. Given his suicidal and intoxicated nature, the officers reasonably believed that he was a threat to himself or others. Id. And they reasonably used a taser while the man was on the ground because he was “actively resisting [their] attempts to secure his arms behind his back.” Id. at 97; see also Monday, 118 F.3d at 1104–05.

[A] medical counselor had just found him suicidal and delusional and ordered him immediately hospitalized because of this risk of harm.

This case is like Caie under the deputies’ version of the facts. The deputies reasonably believed that Mr. Helms posed an “immediate threat” to himself and others. Est. of Hill, 853 F.3d at 315. Among other evidence, a court had ordered Mr. Helms to undergo a mental-health evaluation because he had been “threatening to harm” his family and himself. And a medical counselor had just found him suicidal and delusional and ordered him immediately hospitalized because of this risk of harm. Mr. Helms had also disclosed his knowledge of “how to disarm police officers” to Sgt. Hall. And he had acted upset after learning of the involuntary hospitalization.

Reasonably Necessary Force

Likewise, the deputies used the force “reasonably necessary” to transfer Mr. Helms to Eastern State Hospital. Est. of Hill, 853 F.3d at 315. Mr. Helms engaged in “active resistance” when the deputies tried to get him out of Sgt. Hall’s cruiser and into the transport vehicle. Hagans, 695 F.3d at 509. He disobeyed commands to hand over his phone and exit the cruiser. He also tried to kick Dep. Kimmle to prevent his removal. Sgt. Hall

[I]f a suspect actively resists arrest and refuses to be handcuffed, officers do not violate the Fourth Amendment by using a taser to subdue him.

So the deputies used the type of force (compliance strikes and pulling on Mr. Helms’s body) reasonably related to overcoming his “resistance” and getting him out of the car. See Chaney, 98 F.4th at 717. Deputy White next reasonably used a taser. Mr. Helms continued to struggle with Sgt. Hall and Dep. Kimmle on the ground to try to avoid getting handcuffed. Dep.White also tased Mr. Helms only for the “two seconds” required to make Mr. Helms “compliant” and then stopped once Mr. Helms ended his resistance. White So this force falls within our general rule that “[I]f a suspect actively resists arrest and refuses to be handcuffed, officers do not violate the Fourth Amendment by using a taser to subdue him.” Hagans, 695 F.3d at 509.

She is mistaken.

Mrs. Helms responds with both factual and legal points. Factually, she argues that the district court improperly rejected her testimony as hearsay and wrongly resolved evidentiary disputes in the deputies’ favor. She is mistaken. For starters, Mrs. Helms misconstrues the district court’s decision when she suggests that it rejected her testimony on hearsay grounds. It did no such thing. So her arguments about the federal hearsay rules are beside the point. Instead, the court held that—even accepting Mrs. Helms’s testimony as true—she heard nothing during her phone conversation with Mr. Helms that conflicted with the deputies’ accounts of her son’s combative conduct.

 But the language does not itself qualify as excessive force.

This case thus turns on whether Mrs. Mr. Helms identified enough circumstantial evidence to create a factual dispute over whether Mr. Helms actively resisted. On that front, we agree with the district court that she did not. As her best evidence, she allegedly heard an unknown deputy call her son a “[C]razy psycho motherfucker” and tell him that he “had this coming” and “deserve[d] what [he was] getting” during the struggle. Even accepting that a deputy made these statements (they denied it), the statements would not allow a reasonable jury to reject the deputies’ testimony that they used force because of Mr. Helms’s refusal to exit Sgt. Hall’s cruiser and get handcuffed. As the district court noted, the deputies used “unprofessional” language that must have been “terribly difficult” for Mrs. Helms to hear. But the language does not itself qualify as excessive force. And the claim that it might show that Mr. Helms did not resist amounts to the type of “speculation” that cannot withstand a summary-judgment motion. Buetenmiller v. Macomb Cnty. Jail, 53 F.4th 939, 945 (6th Cir. 2022).

[I]t should not be surprising that he would object in this way because he was delusional and did not want to get hospitalized.

Mrs. Helms also heard her son repeatedly cry out and ask for help. But this fact supports the deputies’ accounts. As Sgt. Hall explained, Mr. Helms was “hollering and screaming” “stop” and “quit” as he resisted their efforts to remove him from Sgt. Hall’s cruiser. And it should not be surprising that he would object in this way because he was delusional and did not want to get hospitalized.

Dep. Kimmle had no intention of shooting Mr. Helms and threatened to “put a bullet in his ass” as an “intimidation technique” to convince Mr. Helms to stop moving.

Mrs. Helms next points out that she heard Dep. Kimmle threaten to “put a bullet in [her son’s] head” if he moved. But this conversation happened well after the use of force while Dep. Kimmle drove Mr. Helms to Eastern State Hospital. According to Dep. Kimmle, Mr. Helms was “thrashing around” in the backseat, had gotten his seatbelt off, and was trying to move in a way that would get his cuffed hands from “behind” his back to “in front of him.” Dep. Kimmle had no intention of shooting Mr. Helms and threatened to “put a bullet in his ass” as an “intimidation technique” to convince Mr. Helms to stop moving. This language may well have been bad police work—as evidenced by Sheriff Woods’s decision to “verbally reprimand” Dep. Kimmle for it. But the comment says nothing about what happened earlier during the physical encounter.

Mrs. Helms’ Conjecture

Apart from what she overheard on the call, Mrs. Helms separately tries to undercut Sgt. Hall’s account with alleged inconsistencies in his testimony. Sgt. Hall, for example, at one point suggested that Mr. Helms’s phone use kept him calm but later suggested that Mr. Helms became animated when speaking to his mom. Similarly, some confusion exists about how Mr. Helms’s cellphone got from the floor of Sgt. Hall’s cruiser to the floor of Dep. Kimmle’s transport vehicle (where Sheriff Woods allegedly found it). Mrs. Helms infers that Dep. Kimmle must have taken Sgt. Hall’s cruiser to Eastern State. And she finds it suspicious that Sgt. Hall drove to the Justice Center to meet Dep. Kimmle, suggesting that he did so to be in a more isolated area. Yet this “conjecture” would not allow a reasonable jury to second guess the deputies’ undisputed testimony that Mr. Helms struggled with them to avoid his hospitalization. Arendale v. City of Memphis, 519 F.3d 587, 605 (6th Cir. 2008).

But Mr. Helms’s mental-health struggles did not bar the deputies from using the force required to get control of him and end his resistance—even if that resistance sprang from his delusions.

Legally, Mrs. Mr. Helms suggests that the deputies unreasonably seized her son because they did not account for Mr. Helms’s mental state when deciding to physically restrain him. True, deputies should consider a party’s “diminished capacity” as a factor in the totality of circumstances on the proper force. Roell, 870 F.3d at 482. But Mr. Helms’s mental-health struggles did not bar the deputies from using the force required to get control of him and end his resistance—even if that resistance sprang from his delusions. See id.; Caie, 485 F. App’x at 96–97.

Conclusion and Holding

[T]he deputies ended their force once Mr. Helms’s resistance stopped.

Mrs. Helms lastly relies on three cases with far different facts. See, e.g., Palma v. Johns, 27 F.4th 419, 430–32 (6th Cir. 2022); Stewart v. City of Euclid, 970 F.3d 667, 673–74 (6th Cir. 2022); Martin v. City of Broadview Heights, 712 F.3d 951, 961 (6th Cir. 2013). In Palma, for example, a man “never physically resisted” and simply failed to follow an officer’s orders before an officer tased (and later shot) him. 27 F.4th at 430. The undisputed testimony from the deputies in this case, by contrast, shows that Mr. Helms was physically resisting when White tased him. Next, Stewart found that an officer had unconstitutionally shot and killed a suspect to get the suspect to stop his car. 970 F.3d at 672–74. This lethal force says nothing about the deputies’ non-lethal force. And Martin held that officers had used excessive force by tackling and placing their weight on top of a mentally unstable suspect until he died from asphyxiation. 712 F.3d at 957–60. Here, however, the deputies ended their force once Mr. Helms’s resistance stopped.

We affirm.

Information for this article was obtained from Helms v. Boyd County Sheriff’s Department, No. 24 – 5853 (6thCir., 2025).

Helms v. Boyd County Sheriff’s Department, No. 24 – 5853 (6th Cir., 2025) was issued by the Sixth Circuit Appellate Court on June 17, 2025 and is binding in Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee.

Lessons Learned:

  1. Use of Force Standard During Mental Crisis – On February 28, 2022 the Sixth Circuit established a seven-part use of force test to evaluate force on a person who is mentally ill; (1) Why the officer was called to the scene, (2) Whether the officer knew or reasonably believed that the person was armed, (3) Whether the person verbally or physically threatened the officer or disobeyed the officer, (4) How far the officer was from the person, (5) The duration of the entire encounter, (6) Whether the officer knew of any ongoing mental or physical health conditions that may have affected the person’s response to the officer, and (7) Whether the officer could have diffused the situation with less forceful tactics. Palma v. Johns, 21 – 3315 (6th Cir., 2022). For more information see; The Sixth Circuit Dangerously Limits the way Officers Can Protect Themselves During Dangerous Encounters with a Convoluted Seven-Part Use of Force Test.  
  2. Boyd County SO Use of Force on Mr. Helms – In this case Mr. Helms was in a mental health crisis as the court described “Sgt. Hall could tell that Mr. Helms was struggling with his mental health because Mr. Helms made many incoherent statements (including about collecting “Egyptian artifacts”). More disturbingly, Mr. Helms noted that he knew “how to disarm police officers.”. Thereafter “Mr. Helms responded: “Fuck you, fuck them. Fuck this. I am not going.” The deputies repeatedly ordered Mr. Helms to put his hands behind his back and to get out. But Mr. Helms resisted all efforts to extract him. Instead, he lay down in a supine position with his legs up and his left foot pulled back in an attempt to kick Dep. Kimmle. Sgt. Hall thus went to the vehicle’s other side to help remove him. Yet Mr. Helms continued to struggle and yell. Once the deputies’ verbal orders failed, Sgt. Hall escalated to using three compliance “strikes” to Mr. Helms’s back. When this force also did not work, Dep. Kimmle pulled Mr. Helms out of the car by the belt loops on his pants.”, he had to be tasered and restrained prior to being transported to a mental health facility.  The minimal force exacted upon Mr. Helms for his own safety comported to the seven-part mental health use of force test established in Palma. However, the Sixth Circuit in this case does not apply their own standard to the use of force in the Helms case rather they apply the use of force standard during a medical emergency.
  3. Use of Force During a Medical Emergency – On April 4, 2017 the Sixth Circuit established a three-part test to use force on a person during a medical emergency.  1) Was the person experiencing a medical emergency that rendered him incapable of making a rational decision under circumstances that posed an immediate threat of serious harm to himself or others? 2) Was some degree of force reasonably necessary to ameliorate [lower] the immediate threat? 3) Was the force used more than reasonably necessary under the circumstances [was the fore excessive]? Estate of Miracle v. Hill, 853 F.3d 306 (6th Cir., 2017).  In this case the Sixth Circuit concluded “Likewise, the deputies used the force “reasonably necessary” to transfer Mr. Helms to Eastern State Hospital. Est. of Hill, 853 F.3d at 315.”.  Of course the Miracle use of force test is legal fiction, specifically the phrase ‘reasonably necessary’.  If a person points a firearm at a police officer and threatens to kill the officer then the officer shoots the suspect and maims or kills the suspect, the use of deadly force would be reasonable.  However, if the suspects gun is BB gun, unloaded or inoperable the use of deadly force would not be ‘necessary’.  Nonetheless the Sixth Circuit determined the Miracle ‘reasonably necessary’ test should have been applied to the mentally deficient Mr. Helms. 
  4. Bullet in his ass – During Mr. Helms’ transport to the mental health facility Dep. Kimmle “[T]hreatened to “put a bullet in his ass”.  As the court evaluated the statement in context it opined “Dep. Kimmle had no intention of shooting Mr. Helms and threatened to “put a bullet in his ass” as an “intimidation technique” to convince Mr. Helms to stop moving.”.  Dep. Kimmle’s statement was unprofessional, however, in context it is clear that the deputy was simply trying to get Mr. Helms to stop thrashing around and attempting to get his cuffed hands in front of him during the transport.  As the court opined “Mr. Helms was “thrashing around” in the backseat, had gotten his seatbelt off, and was trying to move in a way that would get his cuffed hands from “behind” his back to “in front of him.”.  Law enforcement is often faced with recalcitrant suspects who REPEATEDLY fail to follow lawful commands.  Mr. Helms is the latest example.  

Does your agency train on Mental Ill Use of Force and Transports?

Don’t fail your training.

Don’t let your training fail you!

Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!

Robert H. Meader Esq.