At all times relevant, Mr. Harvey knowingly sold or offered to sell substances that he represented to be heroin in amounts that exceeded the bulk amount identified under O.R.C. §2925.03(C)(6)(e) and in the vicinity of a juvenile and/or a school … Therefore, Mr. Harvey’s trafficking- in-heroin convictions under Counts Two, Three, and Four are based on sufficient evidence.
State v. Harvey
Third District Appellate Court
Allen County, Ohio
February 10, 2025
Why is this case important?
If a suspect represents fake heroin as heroin, the suspect now defendant, can be successfully prosecuted for Aggravated Trafficking.
Background
On October 15, 2020, the Allen County Grand Jury indicted Mr. Jaquaveius Harvey on Count One of trafficking in heroin in violation of R.C. 2925.03(A)(1), (C)(6)(d), a third-degree felony; Counts Two, Three, and Four of trafficking in heroin in violation of R.C. 2925.03(A)(1), (C)(6)(e), all first-degree felonies; and Count Five of engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity in violation of R.C. 2923.32(A)(1), (B)(1), a first-degree felony. On January 22, 2021, Mr. Harvey appeared for arraignment and entered pleas of not guilty.
After a bench trial on May 22, 2023, the trial court found Mr. Harvey guilty of all five counts.

Seventeen to Twenty-Two Years in Prison
On June 7, 2023, the trial court sentenced Mr. Harvey to 36 months in prison on Count One; four years in prison on Counts Two, Three, and Four, respectively; and ten years minimum to 15 years maximum in prison on Count Five. The trial court ordered that the sentences imposed on Counts Two, Three, and Four be served concurrently with each other. The trial court further ordered that the sentences imposed on Counts One and Five be served consecutively to the sentences imposed on Counts Two, Three, and Four for a total aggregate sentence of 17 years minimum to 22 years maximum in prison.
https://appgateway.drc.ohio.gov/OffenderSearch/Search/Details/A816894
In his first and second assignments of error, Mr. Harvey argues that his trafficking-in-heroin convictions under Counts Two, Three, and Four and his engaging-in-a-pattern-of-corrupt-activity conviction are based on insufficient evidence. As to the trafficking-in-heroin convictions under Counts Two, Three, and Four, Mr. Harvey argues that these convictions are based on insufficient evidence because “the lab reports analyzing the substances sold . . . revealed no controlled substances were detected.”
What is the Mens Rea of Knowingly?
O.R.C. §2901.22(B)
A person acts “knowingly” when the person is aware that the person’s conduct will probably cause a certain result or will probably be of a certain nature. A person has knowledge of circumstances when the person is aware that such circumstances probably exist. When knowledge of the existence of a particular fact is an element of an offense, such knowledge is established if a person subjectively believes that there is a high probability of its existence and fails to make inquiry or acts with a conscious purpose to avoid learning the fact.
Knowingly Sold Fake Heroin
On appeal, Mr. Harvey argues that his trafficking-in-heroin convictions under Counts Two, Three, and Four are based on insufficient evidence because the substances sold were tested and found to contain no controlled substance.
Established Case Law
Mr. Harvey’s sufficiency-of-the-evidence argument is without merit. See State v. Burse, 2024-Ohio-2027, ¶ 14-17 (3d Dist.). Our review of the record reveals that the State presented sufficient evidence to show that Mr. Harvey knowingly sold or offered to sell substances that he represented to be heroin in amounts that exceeded the bulk amount identified under O.R.C. §2925.03(C)(6)(e) and in the vicinity of a juvenile and/or a school. See O.R.C. §2925.03(I). Specifically, the State presented the testimony of Investigator Aaron Montgomery (“Investigator Montgomery”) of the Lima Police Department, assigned to the West Central Ohio Crime Task Force, who testified that the task force conducted four controlled drug buys to purchase heroin from Mr. Harvey. The State also presented the testimony of a confidential informant (“the CI”) used in all four controlled drug buys. In addition, the State presented audio recordings of the controlled drug buys and a video recording of the jail interview conducted by Investigator Montgomery wherein Mr. Harvey admitted to trafficking in heroin.
First Controlled Buy – February 19, 2020
The first controlled drug buy (Count One) took place on February 19, 2020. Investigator Montgomery testified that the task force, with the assistance of the CI, purchased $700 worth of heroin from Mr. Harvey. The evidence from the drug transaction—being “[O]ne (1) knotted plastic bag containing off-white substance” weighing approximately 9.08 grams—was tested by the Bureau of Criminal Investigation (“BCI”) and found to contain heroin.
Second Controlled Buy – February 24, 2020
The second controlled drug buy (Count Two) took place on February 24, 2020. The CI testified that he contacted Mr. Harvey by phone to purchase 15 grams of heroin. The “deal” struck between Mr. Harvey and the CI was 15 grams of heroin for $1,200. The CI further testified that the task force provided the money for the purchase and a “wire” to record the drug transaction. When the CI arrived at the buy location, a juvenile (later identified as Mr. Harvey’s minor cousin C.C.) completed the drug transaction. As the CI was driving away from the buy location, Mr. Harvey called the CI to confirm that the CI received the drugs. During the phone conversation, the CI asked Mr. Harvey if the “little dude” was “cool” and Mr. Harvey responded affirmatively. Thereafter, the CI met with the task force and turned over the drugs. Investigator Montgomery testified that the evidence from the drug transaction—being “[O]ne (1) knotted plastic bag containing off-white substance”weighing approximately 14.74 grams, was tested by BCI and “[N]o controlled substance found.”
Third Controlled Buy – February 27, 2020
The third controlled drug buy (Count Three) took place on February 27, 2020. The CI contacted Mr. Harvey by phone to purchase heroin and the “deal” was 15 grams of heroin for $1,200. As with the first and second controlled drug buys, the task force provided the money for the purchase and a recording device. When the CI arrived at the buy location, Mr. Harvey was present and completed the drug transaction. C.C. was also present during the drug transaction. Thereafter, the CI met with the task force and turned over what he had purchased from Mr. Harvey. Investigator Montgomery testified that the evidence from the drug transaction—being “[O]ne (1) knotted white plastic bag with off-white substance” weighing approximately 12.95 grams, was tested by BCI and “[n]o controlled substance found.” Investigator Montgomery further testified that the third controlled drug buy took place within the vicinity of a school.
Fourth Controlled Buy – March 2, 2020
He got some new shit
The fourth controlled drug buy (Count Four) took place on March 2, 2020. The CI testified that he received a text message from Mr. Harvey stating, “He got some new shit.” The CI interpreted the text message to mean that Mr. Harvey had heroin to sell. The CI contacted Mr. Harvey by phone to purchase 15 grams of heroin. The “deal” struck between Mr. Harvey and the CI was 15 grams of heroin for $1,200. (Id. at 55). As with the prior controlled drug buys, the task force provided the money for the purchase and a recording device. When the CI arrived at the buy location, the CI called Mr. Harvey and Mr. Harvey told the CI where to park. After the CI parked his vehicle as directed by Mr. Harvey, C.C. entered the front passenger side and completed the transaction. Thereafter, the CI met with the task force and turned over the drugs. Investigator Montgomery testified that the evidence from the drug transaction—being “[O]ne (1) knotted white plastic bag with white substance” weighing approximately 15.01 grams, was tested by BCI and “[N]o controlled substance found.”
Miranda Waiver and Self Incrimination
A couple of days after the fourth controlled drug buy, Mr. Harvey was arrested on suspicion of drug trafficking and Investigator Montgomery conducted a jail interview. After informing Mr. Harvey of his Miranda rights, Investigator Montgomery asked, “How much have you been selling?” Mr. Harvey stated that he does not sell, instead, he has other people sell for him to make money. Investigator Montgomery then asked, “How much do you have them push for you?” Mr. Harvey stated that he “pushes” about ten grams a week. Mr. Harvey further stated that his supply comes from “Deontrae” in Detroit. Mr. Harvey explained that he does not travel to Detroit to pick up the supply, rather, he has other people do that for him. When Investigator Montgomery asked if he sells “heroin” and nothing else, Mr. Harvey responded affirmatively. Mr. Harvey also stated that he does not “step on it” and that the heroin is sold as it comes to him.
At trial, Investigator Montgomery testified that, during the jail interview, he and Mr. Harvey discussed Deontrae Forrest (“Forrest”). Investigator Montgomery further testified that, during the jail interview, he and Mr. Harvey reached an agreement wherein “if [Mr. Harvey] provided a phone number for who we talk about Deontrae Forrest who is involved, at that time, that if it worked out to be something I would give the prosecutors awareness of such.”
At some point subsequent to the jail interview, Mr. Harvey provided a phone number for Forrest. At trial, Investigator Montgomery testified that the number “was no good, [led] to nowhere.” Approximately seven months later, Mr. Harvey was indicted on the charges in this case.
Conclusion and Holding
Based on the evidence presented, and when reviewing it in a light most favorable to the prosecution, we conclude that any rational trier of fact could have found the essential elements of O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(1), (C)(6)(e) were proven beyond a reasonable doubt. See Burse, 2024-Ohio-2027, at ¶ 17 (3d Dist.). See also State v. Brown, 2024-Ohio-2027, ¶ 32 (3d Dist.). At all times relevant, Mr. Harvey knowingly sold or offered to sell substances that he represented to be heroin in amounts that exceeded the bulk amount identified under O.R.C. §2925.03(C)(6)(e) and in the vicinity of a juvenile and/or a school. See O.R.C. §2925.03(I). Therefore, Mr. Harvey’s trafficking- in-heroin convictions under Counts Two, Three, and Four are based on sufficient evidence.
Mr. Harvey’s first assignment of error is overruled.
Information for this article was obtained from State v. Harvey, 2025 – Ohio – 430.
State v. Harvey, 2025 – Ohio – 430 was issued by the Third District Appellate Court on February 10, 2025 and is binding in the following Ohio Counties: Allen, Auglaize, Crawford, Defiance, Hancock, Hardin, Henry, Logan, Marion, Mercer, Paulding, Putnam, Seneca, Shelby, Union, Van Wert and Wyandot.
Lessons Learned:
- Established Case Law Selling Fake Narcotics – Harvey was convicted of Aggravated Traffickingin Heroin – O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(1). Yet, Mr. Harvey never sold heroin, he sold fake heroin. On May 28, 2024 the Third District Appellate Court evaluated a case with similar facts in State v. Burse, 2024-Ohio-2027, and held “[W]e conclude that the State presented sufficient evidence that Burse sold or offered to sell a drug. That is, Burse sold or offered to sell a substance that he represented to be heroin or a substance that he represented to be a compound, mixture, preparation, or substance containing heroin in an amount that exceeded the bulk amount identified under O.R.C. §2925.03(C)(6)(d).” The fact that the product was fake heroin and not actually heroin is not relevant when the suspect represents the product as heroin.
- Mirandized Interview – How the suspect represents the product as the actual narcotic is critical to conviction. In this case Lima Police Investigator Aaron Montgomery Mirandized interview of Mr. Harvey was critical. Investigator Montgomery was able to obtain inculpatory statements from Mr. Harvey that he believed the product was actually heroin “Investigator Montgomery then asked, “How much do you have them push for you?” Mr. Harvey stated that he “pushes” about ten grams a week. Mr. Harvey further stated that his supply comes from “Deontrae” in Detroit.”.
- Circumstantial Evidence – In 1991 the Supreme Court determined that circumstantial evidence can establish proof of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt “[T]here is but one standard of proof in a criminal case, and that is proof of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. This tenant of the criminal law remains true, whether the evidence against a defendant is circumstantial or direct.” State v. Jenks, 61 Ohio St.3d 259 (1991). Here, the controlled buys and the Mirandized interview of Mr. Harvey established circumstantial evidence Mr. Harvey ‘knowingly’ believed he was selling heroin.
- Pre-Sent Arms! Lima Police Investigator Aaron Montgomery, his team on the West Central Ohio Crime Task Force and the Allen County Prosecutor’s Office should be highly commended for working in concert in this investigation and conviction. Well done!
Does your agency train on Laws of Arrest?
Don’t fail your training.
Don’t let your training fail you!
Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!