[T]he parental-discipline defense is not applicable where the alleged victim has reached the age of eighteen and is not suffering from a mental or physical handicap.
State v. Mutsago
Fifth District Appellate Court
Fairfield County, Ohio
December 31, 2024
Why is this Case Important?
This case affirms that corporal punishment may not be exacted by a parent on an adult child, even if the child has not graduated high school, lives with the parent(s) and remains financially dependent on her parents.
Suicidal Call for Service on Eighteen-Year-Old Female
The facts in this matter are not in dispute. This case arose on February 13, 2022, when deputies with the Fairfield County Sheriff’s Office were dispatched to a residence in Fairfield County regarding an attempted suicide. Deputies contacted Jane Doe, who reported she was having suicidal thoughts. Deputies determined Jane’s date of birth was November 5, 2003, and she was therefore 18 years old during this contact.

Self-Inflicted Cuts and Multiple Bodily Bruises
Deputies observed self-inflicted cuts on Jane, who reported she did not want to return to her residence because her father—Mr. Mukayi Mutsago—had beaten her the night before. Jane stated Mr. Mutsago hit her in the head with his hands and struck her all over her body with a belt. Jane showed deputies photos on her phone which depicted bruises to her body purportedly caused by Mr. Mutsago striking her.
‘Discipline’ Over Grades, Volunteer Hours and the National Honor Society
Deputies contacted Mr. Mutsago, who readily admitted he struck Jane Doe with a belt six to ten times during a dispute about Jane’s grades, volunteer hours, and National Honor Society. Mr. Mutsago stated he struck Jane repeatedly with the belt because she disrespected him in front of his wife and other children. Mr. Mutsago’s Wife confirmed Mr. Mutsago struck Jane Doe with a belt several times and Wife intervened, asking him to stop.
Mr. Mutsago was Charged with DV and Assault
Mr. Mutsago was charged by misdemeanor complaint with one count of domestic violence pursuant to O.R.C. §2919.15(A) and one count of assault pursuant to O.R.C. §2903.13(A), both misdemeanors of the first degree. Mr. Mutsago was arrested on the charges over a year later and entered pleas of not guilty. The matter was scheduled for trial by jury.
Can Parental Discipline be Exacted Upon a Legal Adult?
In advance of trial, appellee filed a motion in limine asking the trial court to prevent Mr. Mutsago from arguing the defense of parental discipline because Jane Doe was 18 at the time of the offenses. Appellee also requested the trial court to instruct the jury that parental discipline is not to be considered in their deliberations. Mr. Mutsago responded with a memorandum in opposition and the trial court heard oral arguments on the issue. On November 28, 2023, the trial court granted appellee’s motion in limine via judgment entry.
Mr. Mutsago thereupon withdrew his pleas of not guilty and entered plea of no contest to one count of domestic violence. The trial court accepted his no-contest plea, found him guilty, and sentenced Mr. Mutsago to a jail term of 180 days with all 180 suspended.
Mr. Mutsago now appeals from the trial court’s entry of conviction and sentence, incorporating the trial court’s entry granting appellee’s motion in limine.
Mr. Mutsago raises three assignments of error:
Appeal – Can Corporal Punishment be Exacted Upon an Adult?
Mr. Mutsago’s three assignments of error are related and will be considered together. He argues he should have been permitted to argue the defense of parental discipline, and the jury should have been permitted to consider the defense, even though Jane Doe was 18 years old at the time of the offense. We disagree.
Established Case Law – Domestic Violence
Mr. Mutsago was convicted upon one count of domestic violence pursuant to O.R.C. §2919.25(A), which states: “No person shall knowingly cause or attempt to cause physical harm to a family or household member.” Physical harm to persons is defined as “any injury, illness, or other physiological impairment, regardless of its gravity or duration.” O.R.C. §2901.01(C); State v. Faggs, 2018-Ohio-3643, ¶ 18 (5th Dist.), affirmed, 2020-Ohio- 523. There is no dispute in this case that Mr. Mutsago repeatedly struck his daughter with a belt. Although the facts in the record before us are limited, the uncontroverted evidence indicates Jane Doe showed police photos of bruising resulting from being struck by the belt.
Established Case Law – The Affirmative Defense of Parental Discipline
The issue the parties have framed for us is whether the trial court should have permitted Mr. Mutsago to argue the affirmative defense of reasonable parental discipline. In Ohio, “[W]here an alleged incident of domestic violence occurs between a parent and child, the parent may raise parental discipline as an affirmative defense.” State v. Durbin, 2013-Ohio-5147, ¶ 25 (5th Dist.). As we have recognized, proper and reasonable parental discipline can be employed by a parent as an affirmative defense to the charge of domestic violence for physical harm to his or her child where such discipline was reasonable under the circumstances. See, State v. Cordle, 2010-Ohio-5919, ¶ 18 (5th Dist.), citing State v. Hart, 110 Ohio App.3d 250 (3rd Dist. 1996) and State v. Adaranijo, 153 Ohio App.3d 266 (1st Dist. 2003).
The affirmative defense of proper and reasonable parental discipline arose in part from the reasoning of the Ohio Supreme Court in State v. Suchomski, 58 Ohio St.3d 74, 74–75 (1991), in which the Court considered charges of domestic violence and child endangering. The Court concluded nothing in O.R.C. §2919.25(A) prohibits a parent from using reasonable corporal punishment to discipline his or her child pursuant to O.R.C. [child endangering] and there is no conflict between O.R.C. §2919.25 and O.R.C. §2919.22. In Suchomski, the defendant came home intoxicated, pulled his 8-year-old child out of bed, punched him in the stomach, and slammed his head into the wall. The defendant was charged with both domestic violence and child endangering.
The defendant argued that if he could be charged pursuant to O.R.C. §2919.25(A) [domestic violence], he was prohibited from using the corporal punishment defense inherent in O.R.C. §2919.22 to discipline his child. Id., 75. The defendant argued the General Assembly recognized the right of a parent to administer reasonable corporal punishment so long as serious physical harm to the child does not result and therefore a conflict existed between O.R.C. §2919.25 and O.R.C. §2919.22 because the former prohibits “physical harm,” defined as, e.g., any injury. Id. citing R.C. 2901.01(C). The
Ohio Supreme Court disagreed and found:
Nothing in O.R.C. §2919.25(A) prevents a parent from properly disciplining his or her child. The only prohibition is that a parent may not cause “physical harm” as that term is defined in R.C. 2901.01(C). “Physical harm” is defined as “any injury[.]” “Injury” is defined in Black’s Law Dictionary (6 Ed.1990) 785, as “ * * * [t]he invasion of any legally protected interest of another.” (Emphasis in original.) A child does not have any legally protected interest which is invaded by proper and reasonable parental discipline. State v. Suchomski, 58 Ohio St.3d 74, 75 (1991)
The issue posed by the instant case before us is whether Jane Doe is a “child” such that Mr. Mutsago could avail himself of the affirmative defense of parental discipline to the charge of domestic violence. The First District Court of Appeals considered the meaning of “child” in State v. Miller, 134 Ohio App.3d 649, 652–53 (1st Dist.1999), and examined the rationale underlying the Suchomski decision:
The defense of reasonable and proper parental discipline as defined by Suchomski contemplates that a parent may discipline a child. Suchomski, however, does not define at what age one ceases to be a child. In his argument, Miller suggests that we look to O.R.C. §3103.03 for instruction on this issue. O.R.C. §3103.03(B) requires that parents support their children beyond the age of majority when the child is enrolled in high school on a full-time basis. Miller contends that, because Johnson was enrolled in high school and her parents were required to provide her with financial support, she was properly considered a child. We cannot accept this argument.
Conclusion and Holding
Based on our reasoning outlined above, we hold that, in a domestic violence case, the parental-discipline defense is not applicable where the alleged victim has reached the age of eighteen and is not suffering from a mental or physical handicap. Because Johnson was eighteen years old at the time of the incident giving rise to the charge in this case and was not suffering from any known physical or mental handicap, we conclude that the parental-discipline defense was inapplicable here and that the trial court should not have considered it.
Jane Doe was 18 years old at the time of the offense and corporal punishment is inapplicable as a defense, as the trial court correctly determined. Blevins, supra, at 198. The trial court did not err in sustaining appellee’s motion in limine, preventing Mr. Mutsago from raising parental discipline as a defense, and declining to instruct the jury on parental discipline.
Mr. Mutsago’s three assignments of error are overruled and the judgment of the Fairfield County Municipal Court is affirmed.
Information for this case was obtained from State v. Mutsago, 2024 – Ohio – 6100.
State v. Mutsago, 2024 – Ohio – 6100 was issued by the Fifth District Appellate Court on December 31, 2024 and is binding in the following Ohio Counties: Ashland, Coshocton, Delaware, Fairfield, Guernsey, Holmes, Knox, Licking, Morgan, Morrow, Muskingum, Perry, Richland, Stark and Tuscarawas.
Lessons Learned:
- Domestic Violence or Corporal Punishment? Law enforcement is often faced with determining whether or not ‘discipline’ exceeds corporal punishment and rises to the level of Domestic Violence. Based on established case law courts will evaluate the following factors to evaluate corporal punishment, the child’s: 1) Age, 2) Behavior, 3) Response to non-corporal punishment, 4) The location and severity of the punishment and 5) The parent’s state of mind at the time of the punishment. See State v. Faggs, 2020-Ohio-523
- Can a Parent Exact Corporal Punishment on an Adult Child? Corporal punishment may not be exacted upon the child of a parent once the child reaches the age of eighteen as the Fifth District Court held in this case; “[T]he parental-discipline defense is not applicable where the alleged victim has reached the age of eighteen and is not suffering from a mental or physical handicap.”. The fact that the victim was still living in the same household, was financially dependent on her parents and had not graduated high school are non-factors that should not be considered on evaluating corporal punishment versus assault.
- Pre-Sent Arms! This case, like so many others, began as a suicidal call but resulted in a related investigation that led to a Domestic Violence arrest. Law enforcement must always keep an open mind upon responding to calls and mirror the actions of the Fairfield County deputies by completing a substantive investigation and documenting statements and injuries.
Does your agency train on Domestic Violence?
Don’t fail your training.
Don’t let your training fail you!
Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!