We find that Mr. Rodriguez’s domestic violence was supported by sufficient evidence. Mr. Leiva testified he believed that Mr. Rodriguez was going to harm him because Mr. Rodriguez not only threatened to kill him, he also warned Mr. Leiva, “they’re going to need to lock me up because I’m going to do something bad.”

 

State v. Rodriguez

2024 – Ohio – 5632

Twelfth District Appellate Court

Butler County

December 2, 2024

Why is this Case Important?

State v. Rodriguez provides that verbal threats alone can sustain a domestic violence conviction if the threats create a reasonable fear of imminent harm. Law enforcement should focus on the victim’s perception, the suspect’s intent, and the context of the threat rather than just whether the suspect had an immediate ability to carry out the threat.

Background

On November 1, 2023, Mr. Jonathan Rodriguez was charged by complaint with two counts of domestic violence, both fourth-degree misdemeanors, in two separate cases. Mr. Rodriguez entered a not guilty plea to the charges and a bench trial was held on February 7, 2024. Trial testimony revealed the following facts.

Jonathan REALLY Wanted to Borrow the Car

[T]hey’re going to need to lock me up because I’m going to do something bad.

Mr. Rodriguez’s mother (“Mother”) is married to Mr. Luis Leiva (“Mr. Leiva”). Mr. Leiva and Mother reside in Hamilton, Ohio. During the late evening hours of September 11, 2023, while Mr. Leiva and Mother were in bed, Mr. Rodriguez called them about 30 times regarding borrowing a car. Mother eventually passed the phone to Mr. Leiva. Mr. Leiva told Mr. Rodriguez that they were not lending him the car and that Mr. Rodriguez needed to stop bothering them. Mr. Rodriguez then threatened to kill Mr. Leiva, made other violent threats, told Mr. Leiva he was going to come to their house, and stated, “they’re going to need to lock me up because I’m going to do something bad.” After being told by Mother that he was not welcome there, Mr. Rodriguez stated he could come to their home whenever he felt like it. Concerned, Mr. Leiva called 9-1-1 and went to the Hamilton Police Department to report the incident. The following day, September 12, 2023, Mr. Rodriguez called Mr. Leiva and made several threats. He subsequently drove to Mr. Leiva’s home. However, Mr. Leiva was not home.

History of Heated Arguments

Mr. Rodriguez moved the trial court for acquittal at the close of the state’s case- in-chief. The trial court granted Mr. Rodriguez’s motion for acquittal regarding the September 12, 2023 incident and denied the motion regarding the September 11, 2023 incident. Mr. Rodriguez then testified on his own behalf. Mr. Rodriguez admitted repeatedly calling Mr. Leiva and Mother late at night on September  11, 2023, to borrow a car and being angry that he could not borrow the car. Mr. Rodriguez admitted he told Mr. Leiva that he would kill him but denied he intended to go to their house that night. Mr. Rodriguez explained that while he and Mr. Leiva have had several heated arguments in the past, this was their ugliest and most serious argument. Mr. Rodriguez described his demeanor that evening as being the most angry and forceful that he had ever been with Mr. Leiva. The recording of Mr. Leiva’s 9-1-1 call on September 11, 2023, and some of Mr. Rodriguez’s calls were played and admitted into evidence.

Guilty and Two Appeals

Based upon the foregoing, the trial court found Mr. Rodriguez guilty of fourth- degree misdemeanor domestic violence and sentenced him to a suspended 30-day jail sentence, two years of community control, and no contact with Mr. Leiva. Mr. Rodriguez appeals his conviction, raising two assignments of error.

Was Mr. Rodriguez Guilty Even if the Threat was Not Imminent?

Mr. Rodriguez argues that his domestic violence conviction is not supported by sufficient evidence because the state failed to prove that his threat to kill Mr. Leiva was imminent.

Domestic Violence – Threat of Force

Mr. Rodriguez was convicted of domestic violence in violation of O.R.C. §2919.25(C), which provides, “No person, by threat of force, shall knowingly cause a family or household member to believe that the offender will cause imminent physical harm to the family or household member.” For a violation of O.R.C. §2919.25(C), the state must prove that the victim believed the offender would cause him or her imminent physical harm at the time the incident took place. State v. Casey, 2024-Ohio-689, ¶ 11 (12th Dist.). The state of mind of the victim is an essential element of the crime. Id. “Thus, there must be some evidence that a victim either stated, or from other evidence it could be inferred, that the victim thought the accused would cause imminent physical harm.” Id.

Because the Threat was by Phone Mr. Rodriguez Claims the Threat was NOT Imminent

Mr. Rodriguez argues that his physical harm threat was not imminent because the threat was conveyed through a phone call and not in person and Mr. Leiva was aware that Mr. Rodriguez placed the call from his home in Covington, Kentucky. Mr. Rodriguez further argues that the threat was conditional because it depended on Mr. Leiva and Mother allowing Mr. Rodriguez to borrow the car.

Established Case Law Disproving Mr. Rodriguez’s Legal Theory

Threat “represents a range of statements or conduct intended to impart a feeling of apprehension in the victim.” State v. Cress, 2006-Ohio-6501, ¶ 39. Imminent has been defined as “ready to take place,” “near at hand,” “impending,” “hanging threateningly over one’s head,” or “menacingly near.” State v. Tackett, 2005-Ohio-1437, ¶ 14 (4th Dist.). Imminent “does not mean that the offender [will] carry out the threat immediately or be in the process of carrying it out.” State v. McKinney, 2009-Ohio-2225, ¶ 16 (9th Dist.). Rather, the critical inquiry is “whether a reasonable person would be placed in fear of imminent (in the sense of unconditional, non-contingent), serious physical harm.” Tackett at ¶ 14. A threat is conditional where a prerequisite must occur before the actor intends or is empowered to carry out the threat. State v. Diroll, 2007- Ohio-6930, ¶ 56 (11th Dist.).

The Threat was NOT Conditional

We find that Mr. Rodriguez’s domestic violence was supported by sufficient evidence. Mr. Leiva testified he believed that Mr. Rodriguez was going to harm him because Mr. Rodriguez not only threatened to kill him, he also warned Mr. Leiva, “they’re going to need to lock me up because I’m going to do something bad.” While Mr. Leiva lived in Hamilton, Ohio and told the 9-1-1 dispatcher that Mr. Rodriguez lived in Covington, Kentucky, there is no evidence in the record that Mr. Leiva knew Mr. Rodriguez was in Kentucky when he threatened to kill Mr. Leiva. Mr. Leiva did not know where Mr. Rodriguez was when he placed the call. The fact that Mr. Leiva went to the police station to report the incident is evidence of Mr. Leiva’s belief that physical harm was imminent. Tackett, 2005-Ohio-1437. Moreover, the evidence does not support Mr. Rodriguez’s assertion that the threat was conditional. Mr. Leiva told Mr. Rodriguez he could not borrow the car and Mr. Rodriguez responded by threatening to kill Mr. Leiva. While the threat may have been prompted by Mr. Leiva’s refusal to let Mr. Rodriguez borrow the car, it was not contingent upon Mr. Rodriguez borrowing the car such as, “loan me the car or I’ll kill you,” or “if you don’t let me borrow the car, I’ll kill you.” Construing the evidence in the light most favorable to the state, we find that a rational trier of fact could have found that Mr. Rodriguez’s threat caused Mr. Leiva to believe he would suffer imminent physical harm.

Mr. Rodriguez’s first assignment of error is overruled.

Did Mr. Rodriguez ‘Knowingly’ Commit Domestic Violence?

Mr. Rodriguez argues that his domestic violence conviction is against the manifest weight of the evidence because the state failed to prove he knowingly caused Mr. Leiva to believe he would cause him imminent physical harm. In support of his argument, Mr. Rodriguez asserts that (1) it was unlikely he would go to Mother’s house without her consent and at that late hour in the night, (2) the parties were in two separate locations, 20-30 minutes away from one another, (3) Mr. Rodriguez’s threat was conditional, and (4) despite prior heated discussions, there had never been a history of physical violence between Mr. Rodriguez and Mr. Leiva. “A person acts knowingly, regardless of purpose, when the person is aware that the person’s conduct will probably cause a certain result or will probably be of a certain nature. A person has knowledge of circumstances when the person is aware that such circumstances probably exist.” O.R.C. §2901.22(B).

While Mr. Rodriguez’s Location was Unknown Mr. Leiva Went to the Police Station

Upon reviewing the record, we find that Mr. Rodriguez’s domestic violence conviction is not against the manifest weight of the evidence. The state of mind of the victim is an essential element of the crime. Casey, 2024-Ohio-689 at ¶ 11. Although Mr. Leiva and Mr. Rodriguez lived in two separate states 20-30 minutes away from one another, there is no evidence in the record that Mr. Rodriguez was in Kentucky or that Mr. Leiva knew Mr. Rodriguez was in Kentucky when he threatened to kill Mr. Leiva. Mr. Leiva did not know where Mr. Rodriguez was when he placed the call. The fact that Mr. Leiva went to the police station to report the incident is evidence of Mr. Leiva’s belief that physical harm was imminent. Tackett, 2005-Ohio-1437 at ¶ 15-16. Moreover, as we stated above, the evidence does not support Mr. Rodriguez’s assertion that the threat was conditional. While the threat may have been prompted by Mr. Leiva’s refusal to let Mr. Rodriguez borrow the car, it was not contingent upon Mr. Rodriguez borrowing the car. Finally, while there had never been a history of physical violence between Mr. Rodriguez and Mr. Leiva, Mr. Rodriguez admitted he threatened to kill Mr. Leiva, his demeanor that evening was the most angry and forceful he had ever been with Mr. Leiva, and this was their ugliest and most serious argument.

The trial court did not lose its way and create a manifest miscarriage of justice in believing the state witnesses’ testimony such that Mr. Rodriguez’s domestic violence conviction must be reversed and a new trial ordered.

Mr. Rodriguez’s second assignment of error is overruled.

In all other respects, the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.

Information for this article was obtained from State v. Rodriguez, 2024 – Ohio – 5632.

State v. Rodriguez, 2024 – Ohio – 5632 was issued by the Twelfth District Appellate Court on December 2, 2024 and is binding in the following Ohio Counties: Brown, Butler, Clermont, Clinton, Fayette, Madison, Preble and Warren.

Lessons Learned:

  1. What is an “Imminent” Threat? Courts provide latitude on the doctrine of imminency. Here the court opined “Imminent “does not mean that the offender [will] carry out the threat immediately or be in the process of carrying it out.” State v. McKinney, 2009-Ohio-2225, ¶ 16 (9th Dist.). Rather, the critical inquiry is “whether a reasonable person would be placed in fear of imminent (in the sense of unconditional, non-contingent), serious physical harm.” State v. Tackett, 2005-Ohio-1437.  Though the court did not explicitly identify the doctrine of Totality of Circumstances, that is certainly how ‘imminency’ is evaluated.
  2. Physical Location as Applied to Imminent – The court emphasized that the victim Mr. Leiva was unaware of the location of Mr. Rodriguez when he made his homicidal threats “ Leiva did not know where Mr. Rodriguez was when he placed the call. The fact that Mr. Leiva went to the police station to report the incident is evidence of Mr. Leiva’s belief that physical harm was imminent.”. This should also be inferred that if the victim knows that the suspect is a great distance away that would be favorable to the suspect that the ‘imminency’ of the threat would be diminished.
  3. Victims Response to the Threat – How victims respond to threats is a critical factor to determine the validity of a threat. Here the court evaluated Mr. Rodriguez’s appeal based in part on Mr. Leiva’s physical response to the homicidal threat “The fact that Mr. Leiva went to the police station to report the incident is evidence of Mr. Leiva’s belief that physical harm was imminent.”. Law enforcement should always ask and include in the written report how the victim responded to the threat.
  4. Pre–Sent Arms! The involved Hamilton Police Officers, Hamilton Dispatchers and the Butler County Prosecutors Office should be highly commended on their investigation, successful prosecution and successful appeal on this case.  Well done!

Does your agency train on Domestic Violence?

Don’t fail your training.

Don’t let your training fail you!

Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!

Robert H. Meader Esq.