There is no specific time frame contained in the statute as to how long the victim must live as a spouse, as long as it was within five years of the crime.

 

State v. Joubert

2024 – Ohio – 5052

Seventh District Appellate Court

Mahoning County, Ohio

October 18, 2024

 

Domestic Relationship Concludes at the Advance Auto Parts Parking Lot

On October 31, 2023, Mr. Jonathan Joubert was charged with one count of domestic violence pursuant to O.R.C. §2919.25(A), a first-degree misdemeanor, in Mahoning County Court #4, in Austintown. The charge arose from an incident that occurred on Monday October 30, 2023 at an Advance Auto Parts store in Austintown. Mr. Joubert and the victim had been romantic partners and were living together at his house for approximately a year before they broke off the relationship on October 24, 2023. After they broke up, Mr. Joubert told the victim to meet him at his house so that she could retrieve her personal belongings.

The victim drove to her place of employment, Advance Auto Parts, to pick up a friend prior to going to Mr. Joubert’s house. While the victim was at Advance Auto Parts, Mr. Joubert arrived there.

A Jeep Trespass and Assault

The victim was in the store when Mr. Joubert arrived. He entered the store, then went out and threw her belongings on the ground next to her Jeep. When Mr. Joubert entered the victim’s vehicle without permission, she told him to get out. As he stepped out, he began yelling at the victim and then struck her, injuring her face, before driving away. She called the police to report the attack, which led to the domestic violence charge.

Mr. Joubert assaulted his ex-girlfriend in the Advance Auto Parts parking lot at 4801 Mahoning Avenue in Austintown, Ohio.  There on and off again relationship was questioned as to whether it established a ‘family or household’ member for purposes of the Domestic Violence Statute.

Trial and Guilty Verdict

A bench trial was held on January 31, 2024. The state called three witnesses at trial: the manager of Advance Auto Parts, an employee of Advance Auto Parts who was a friend of the victim, and the victim. Mr. Joubert testified in his own defense. At the close of the state’s case, Mr. Joubert moved to dismiss the charge on the basis of insufficient evidence. The motion was overruled. The court found Mr. Joubert guilty of domestic violence and sentenced him to 30 days in jail with 20 days suspended, 12 months of reporting probation, and a $250 fine. This timely appeal followed.

Mr. Joubert Appeals

Mr. Joubert contends that there is insufficient evidence to support his conviction for domestic violence. Specifically, Mr. Joubert argues that the evidence does not support the conclusion that Mr. Joubert and the victim cohabitated or lived together within five years of the date of the crime. When the victim of domestic violence is a “person living as a spouse,” the state must prove either that the perpetrator and victim lived in a common law marriage arrangement or that they cohabited. O.R.C. §2919.25(F)(2). Mr. Joubert and the victim were not married at common law, and thus the state needed to prove that they were cohabitating. Mr. Joubert cites a number of factors set forth in Williams, supra, that must be proven in some domestic violence cases when the victim and the perpetrator are purportedly cohabitating but have not actually lived together prior to the act of violence. Mr. Joubert contends that the victim did not share living expenses with Mr. Joubert, did not have her name on the lease, and did not treat Mr. Joubert’s apartment as her sole residence. Mr. Joubert contends that these and other factors listed in Williams were not proven at trial, and thus, he and the victim were not cohabitating. Mr. Joubert believes that this was, at most, a case of simple assault and not domestic violence. Therefore, the case should have been dismissed. 

What is a Person Living as Spouse?

The issue in this appeal is whether all the elements of misdemeanor domestic violence were satisfied. O.R.C. §2919.25(A) states: “No person shall knowingly cause or attempt to cause physical harm to a family or household member.” O.R.C. §2919.25(F) defines “family or household member” (in part) as: “(1)(a) Any of the following who is residing or has resided with the offender: (i) A spouse, a person living as a spouse, or a former spouse of the offender.” A “person living as a spouse” is defined as: “a person who is living or has lived with the offender in a common law marital relationship, who otherwise is cohabiting with the offender, or who otherwise has cohabited with the offender within five years prior to the date of the alleged commission of the act in question.” O.R.C. §2919.25(F)(2).

Mr. Joubert and the victim are not and have never been married, nor are they in a common law marriage relationship. Therefore, to prove domestic violence in this case, the state was required to show that Mr. Joubert and the victim were cohabiting when the crime occurred or had been cohabitating within five years of the offense.

What is Cohabitation?

(1) Sharing of familial or financial responsibilities and (2) Consortium.

Cohabitating is not defined in the domestic violence statute. It has been judicially defined a number of times. In 1997, the Ohio Supreme Court held “the essential elements of ‘cohabitation’ are (1) sharing of familial or financial responsibilities and (2) consortium.” State v. Williams, 79 Ohio St.3d 459, 465 (1997). In Williams, the defendant and the victim did not live together, but exhibited many aspects of an ongoing shared relationship. The court was tasked with determining whether the relationship was consistent with cohabitation. The court looked at such factors as shared responsibility for shelter, food, clothing, utilities, and whether the defendant and victim had commingled assets. Id. The court also looked at whether there was evidence of mutual respect, fidelity, affection, society, cooperation, solace, comfort, aid of each other, friendship, and conjugal relations. Id. The court determined that: “[t]hese factors are unique to each case and how much weight, if any, to give to each of these factors must be decided on a case-by-case basis by the trier of fact.” Id.  

What Distinguishes Friends with Benefits from Domestic Cohabitation?

In 2014, the Ohio Supreme Court clarified the Williams holding. State v. McGlothan, 2014-Ohio-85, ¶ 13 (2014). McGlothan stressed that the additional factors set forth in Williams were used because the defendant and victim were not living together. “The victim’s testimony that for a few months she stayed more nights at Williams’s place than at her own further illustrates that they did not share a residence but rather that each had a separate residence.” Id. “[I]in order to prove cohabitation when the victim and the defendant do not share the same residence, evidence of shared financial or familial responsibilities and consortium is required.” Id. But when the victim and the assailant are proven to be in a romantic relationship and have lived together, the additional Williams factors do not have to be shown by the state. Id. at ¶ 15. 

Cohabitation Established Case Law

We recently reviewed a case in which both Williams and McGlothan were relied on by the parties. State v. Rossi, 2024-Ohio-2566, ¶ 19 (7th Dist.). We held that evidence of shared financial or familial responsibility, and evidence of consortium, “are not required to be demonstrated when the victim testified to sharing a residence.”Id. at ¶ 19. We also noted that the factors in Williams were nonexhaustive, and that some of the factors in Williams could also be used to prove that the parties were living together. The facts were similar to those in the instant case: the parties had been together for six or seven months; they lived with the defendant’s mother, moved to an apartment, then moved to the victim’s apartment where the crime occurred; the defendant kept his belongings at the victim’s apartment; and the victim referred to the defendant as her live- in boyfriend. We principally relied on McGlothan when we held that cohabitation had been proven and the additional Williams factors did not need to be shown.

Personal Items, Clothing and a Garage Door Opener

In this case, the evidence showed that the parties were living together either continuously or on and off for a year prior to the crime. The victim stated: “I pretty much lived with him at his house.” She testified that she was in a romantic relationship with Mr. Joubert for one year. She did not have her own residence. She had lived with her father for eight years prior to living with Mr. Joubert. She testified that her clothing was at Mr. Joubert’s house, her personal items were there, and that they slept in the same bed. She only went back to her father’s house after they broke up, which was a week before the crime. She was in possession of Mr. Joubert’s garage door opener, which gave her full access to Mr. Joubert’s entire house. The crime occurred when Mr. Joubert met the victim at her workplace to give her back her belongings, which she previously had kept at his house. The victim’s friend Amanda testified that the victim’s personal property was at Mr. Joubert’s house. Mr. Joubert threw the victim’s clothing and personal possessions on the ground outside Advance Auto before he attacked her.

Claims of Infidelity is a Factor to Establish Cohabitation

Mr. Joubert himself testified that he had the victim’s clothes in his car. He testified that she had his garage door opener, because she had parked her car in his garage. He testified that the garage door opener gave her access to his entire house. He admitted that they broke up because he caught her cheating on him, thus indicating that they were in an exclusive relationship. His testimony, combined with the victim’s testimony about their living situation and the details of their relationship, is sufficient under the standards set forth in Williams, McGlothan, and Rossi, to prove that Mr. Joubert was cohabitating with the victim. Further evidence of the Williams factors was unnecessary.

Impact of On and Off Again Cohabitation

Mr. Joubert tries to distort the victim’s testimony to urge that she did not live with him, and therefore the Williams factors needed to be proven. Although she said she “pretty much” lived with Mr. Joubert, the prosecutor asked follow-up questions to show that she kept her clothes and personal property at Mr. Joubert’s home and they slept in the same bed. She said that she moved back to her father’s house after she and Mr. Joubert broke up. That date was October 24, 2023, just a week before the domestic violence incident. Although it is possible to glean from this record that Mr. Joubert and the victim had broken up one or more times during the year they were together, the only dates in the record are the date they finally ended their relationship on October 24, 2023, and that they began their relationship in October of 2022. Based on the sufficiency of the evidence standard, the record reveals that the victim lived with Mr. Joubert for approximately a year; they broke up; and a week later he struck her across the face outside of her place of employment as she tried to pick up her belongings from him. Previously, he had kept her personal possessions, including her clothing, at his house and they shared the same bed. She retained access to Mr. Joubert’s apartment on the day of the crime, and Mr. Joubert still possessed her clothing and personal property when the crime occurred. Any rational juror could have found that the victim and Mr. Joubert were cohabitating under these facts. 

There is no specific time frame contained in the statute as to how long the victim must live as a spouse, as long as it was within five years of the crime.

Mr. Joubert appears to argue that the state was required to prove Mr. Joubert and the victim lived continuously together for the entire time that they cohabitated until the final breakup on October 24, 2023. This is not a requirement of the domestic violence statute or of the related case law. The statute required, in this particular case, proof that the victim was a person living as a spouse with Mr. Joubert within five years of the crime. O.R.C. 2919.25(F)(2). There is no specific time frame contained in the statute as to how long the victim must live as a spouse, as long as it was within five years of the crime.

The testimony in the McGlothan case was almost the same as the testimony in this case as to the length of the relationship: “[The victim] testified that at the time of the incident, McGlothan was her boyfriend and had lived with her in her apartment for ‘about a year.’ ” McGlothan at ¶ 3.

Mr. Joubert is Legally just like Mr. Fanelli

In another recent case affirming a domestic violence conviction, the testimony of an “on and off” relationship for eight months was sufficient to satisfy the “person living as a spouse” requirement: “The record shows T.A. testified that she and Mr. Fanelli were in a romantic relationship and lived together at her residence ‘on and off, for eight months, from July 2019 until April 2020.’ ” State v. Fanelli, 2022-Ohio-3498, ¶ 51 (6th Dist.).

On and Off Again Satisfies the Evidentiary Requirements of the Ohio Revised Code

Each domestic violence case must be viewed in light of its own unique fact pattern, and in this case it is clear that the victim and Mr. Joubert were in a romantic relationship and living at Mr. Joubert’s house either continuously or “on and off” for one year just prior to the attack. This satisfies the evidentiary requirements of the statute.

Since cohabitation was proven, the essential element of “family or household member” in the domestic violence statute was satisfied. No further factors needed to be proven by the state to establish that the victim was a family or household member of Mr. Joubert. Mr. Joubert’s sole assignment of error has no merit and is overruled.

Analysis and Holding

Mr. Joubert argues that the state did not prove cohabitation, which is an essential element of domestic violence under the facts of this case. Mr. Joubert contends that the victim did not continuously live with Mr. Joubert in the five years prior to the occurrence of the crime and therefore, the state had to prove the additional factors of cohabitation as set forth in Williams, supra. The record reflects that the victim lived with Mr. Joubert for a year prior to the attack, kept her clothing and personal property in his home, kept her car in his garage, had full access to his house, and that they shared the same bed. Therefore, the state proved that they cohabitated, and there was no need to prove the additional Williams factors. Mr. Joubert’s assignment of error is overruled, and the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.

Information for this article was obtained from State v. Joubert 2024 – Ohio – 5052.

State v. Joubert, 2024 – Ohio – 5052 was issued by the Seventh District Appellate Court on October 18, 2024 and is binding in the following Ohio Counties: Belmont, Carroll, Columbiana, Harrison, Jefferson, Mahoning, Monroe and Noble.

Lessons Learned:

  1. Like a WIFI connection with low bandwidth – This case addresses the challenge of determining if a couple who has an on then off again relationship comports to the ‘family or household’ member as the Ohio Revised Code identifies “family or household member” (in part) as: “(1)(a) Any of the following who is residing or has resided with the offender: (i) A spouse, a person living as a spouse, or a former spouse of the offender.” A “person living as a spouse” is defined as: “a person who is living or has lived with the offender in a common law marital relationship, who otherwise is cohabiting with the offender, or who otherwise has cohabited with the offender within five years prior to the date of the alleged commission of the act in question.”R.C. §2919.25(F)(2). Application of this statute becomes most challenging when the relationship is like a WIFI connection with low bandwidth that connects then disconnects.  After we begin with O.R.C. §2919.25(F)(2), now turn to the Supreme Court of Ohio that held “[T]he essential elements of ‘cohabitation’ are (1) Sharing of familial or financial responsibilities and (2) Consortium.” State v. Williams, 79 Ohio St.3d 459, 465 (1997).  In this case the Seventh District Appellate Court opined “There is no specific time frame contained in the statute as to how long the victim must live as a spouse, as long as it was within five years of the crime.”.  So even when a couple has a domestic relationship that connects and disconnects like a bad WIFI connection, that relationship comports to the legal requirements of a family or household member for purposes of Ohio’s Domestic Violence law.
  2. Claims of Infidelity is a Factor to Establish Cohabitation – The court also took note of Mr. Joubert’s claim that the victim was unfaithful to him as a factor to be consider evaluating the cohabitation element as it opined “He admitted that they broke up because he caught her cheating on him, thus indicating that they were in an exclusive relationship. His testimony, combined with the victim’s testimony about their living situation and the details of their relationship, is sufficient under the standards set forth in Williams, McGlothan, and Rossi, to prove that Mr. Joubert was cohabitating with the victim. Further evidence of the Williams factors was unnecessary.”.
  3. Review of Legally Confident – Tactically Confident 2024– Those teammates who attended Legally Confident – Tactically Confident in 2024 may recall, I reviewed State v. Woodruff, 2019 – Ohio – 5384 during the class, where the couple cohabitated for two weeks then split up. Later, but within five years, Mr. Woodruff assaulted his previous girlfriend.  Were two weeks long enough to establish cohabitation?  According to the Third District Appellate Court the answer is yes, as the court held “Based on this evidence, a rational trier of fact could have found beyond a reasonable doubt that Woodruff and P.O. were cohabitating because they were sharing familial responsibilities and were engaging in the type of companionship normally associated with marriage – consortium.  Accordingly, there is sufficient evidence that P.O. was a family or household member.”.  The key issue is whether the couple were sharing familial reasonability’s.  In both Woodruff and in this case, Mr. Joubert were sharing familial responsibilities when the assault occurred.

Does your agency train on Domestic Violence?

Don’t fail your training.

Don’t let your training fail you!

Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!

Robert H. Meader Esq.