We therefore conclude that B.B.’s statements to Officer Soucek captured by the officer’s body camera were testimonial in nature and that their admission into evidence at Mr. Smith’s criminal trial violated Mr. Smith’s right to confrontation.

 

State v. Smith

2024 – Ohio – 5745

Supreme Court of Ohio

December 10, 2024

Background Information

We examine in this case whether the admission at trial of statements made by a domestic-violence victim, B.B., that were captured by a law-enforcement officer’s body camera violated appellee Garry Smith’s right to confrontation.  As explained below, we conclude that B.B.’s statements made to EMTs that were captured on the body-camera video were nontestimonial; however, we conclude that all B.B.’s statements made to Cleveland Police Officer Brian Soucek were testimonial because those statements were not given to assist the officer in responding to an ongoing emergency situation but rather, to further the officer’s investigation of a crime that had already occurred.  We therefore reverse the judgment of the Eighth District Court of Appeals as it pertains to Mr. Smith’s convictions for the March 21, 2020 incident, and we remand the case to the Eighth District to determine whether any of the statements B.B. made in response to the EMTs’ questions (i.e., the nontestimonial statements) were inadmissible hearsay, to conduct a harmless-error analysis, and to address Mr. Smith’s third, fourth, and fifth assignments of error relating to the March 21, 2020 incident, as necessary.

In November 2020, Mr. Smith was indicted on two counts of domestic violence in violation of O.R.C. §2919.25(A), a fourth-degree felony, with one pregnant-victim specification under O.R.C. §2941.1423, for an incident that occurred on March 21, 2020, in which Mr. Smith allegedly assaulted his pregnant fiancé, B.B.

See State v. Smith, Cuyahoga C.P. No. CR-20-651674-A.  Mr. Smith pleaded not guilty to the charges.

Mr. Smith filed a motion in limine seeking to preclude the State from introducing B.B.’s statements that were recorded by police officers’ body cameras without having B.B. testify at his criminal trial.  Mr. Smith argued that such evidence would constitute hearsay and prevent him from being able to cross-examine B.B., thus violating his right to confrontation.  The State informed the trial court that it had subpoenaed B.B. and intended to call her as a witness.  The State acknowledged that if B.B. failed to appear at trial, then there could be hearsay and confrontation issues concerning B.B.’s statements that were recorded by the officers’ body cameras, but the State argued that B.B.’s statements would fall under various hearsay exceptions.  The trial court initially denied Mr. Smith’s motion in limine but reserved its final ruling until the evidence was introduced at trial.

What is a Motion in Limine? Any motion, whether used before or during trial, by which exclusion is sought of anticipated prejudicial evidence. Blacks Law Dictionary, 787 (6th Ed., 1990)

The Victim Failed to Show to Three Consecutive Subpoena’s for Trial

Mr. Smith waived his right to a jury trial and the matter proceeded to a bench trial. B.B. failed to appear, and the State tried its case without her.

The State called two witnesses to testify about the March 21, 2020 incident: Detective William Cunningham and Officer Soucek, both of the Cleveland Division of Police.  Detective Cunningham investigated the incident.  He tried numerous times to speak with B.B. about the incident but was unable to get in touch with her.  Detective Cunningham identified B.B.’s medical records and photos of B.B.’s injuries that were taken while she was being treated at the hospital as the ones he had obtained using a search warrant.

Officer Soucek was the responding officer to the call for an assaulted female, and his body camera captured B.B.’s statements and demeanor on the night of the incident.  Before Officer Soucek testified, Mr. Smith challenged the admission of the officer’s body-camera video into evidence on confrontation grounds.  The trial court acknowledged the objection but did not rule on it at that time.

Report of a Female Assaulted

The State proceeded to examine Officer Soucek, who at the time of trial had been a patrol officer for 11 years.  He testified that on the evening of March 21, 2020, he and his partner received a dispatch call to a home “for a female assaulted.”, at 7912 Connecticut Avenue, Cleveland Ohio. He activated his body camera and arrived at the scene within a few minutes of the dispatch.

Cleveland Police Officer Brian Soucek and his unnamed parter were dispatched to 7912 Connecticut Avenue, Cleveland Ohio on a report of a female who was assaulted.  The assault resulted in Domestic Violence charges agains Mr. Garry Smith.  What followed was a conviction and two appeals.

Mr. Smith Opposes Transparency

The State then played Officer Soucek’s body-camera video, starting it at the twelve-second mark, which showed Officer Soucek arriving on the scene.  Mr. Smith renewed his objection to the State’s use of the body-camera video, on the ground that it violated his right to confrontation.  The trial court again noted the objection but did not rule on it.

Interview of the Victim in the Ambulance

The State skipped to the 1:02 mark of the body-camera video, which showed Officer Soucek entering an ambulance.  The footage between the 12-second mark and the 1:02 mark captured a relatively calm scene.  As Officer Soucek arrived, two EMTs walked with a woman from the front porch of a house to an ambulance.  And as Office Soucek approached the ambulance, a witness spoke to Officer Soucek’s partner outside the ambulance; the witness was explaining that she had “called EMS because [B.B.] came on [her] doorstep.”

Officer Soucek entered the ambulance and saw a woman, whom he identified as the victim, B.B., being treated by two EMTs.  Officer Soucek asked B.B., “So what happened?”  Over Mr. Smith’s objection, Officer Soucek testified about B.B.’s statement, relaying that B.B. told him that her fiancé had beaten her up because she had had an argument with his niece and that her fiancé had ripped out her hair.

The State asked Officer Soucek, “Specifically, what else?”  But then the State immediately said, “That’s all right, I’ll just hit play.”

On the body-camera video, Officer Soucek next asked B.B., “Do you live with him?”  B.B. replied, “We do live together.”  One of the EMTs then asked B.B., “Is this your niece here?  She said you’re five months pregnant?  Does that sound about right?  Did you take any kicks or punches or anything to the stomach?”  B.B. answered, “To my knee, to my chest, to my stomach.  I no longer feel my baby moving.”

While an EMT was asking B.B. questions concerning her physical condition, Officer Soucek had a conversation with his partner, who was standing to his left, outside the ambulance and off camera.  Officer Soucek asked his partner, “Did it happen here?”  His partner responded, “The niece said that [B.B.] wouldn’t tell her anything, she just showed up at her house and knocked on her door and that [B.B.] lives in East Cleveland and that [the niece] doesn’t know him at all.”  Upon receiving this information, Officer Soucek initiated the following exchange:

Officer: Where did this happen at?

B.B.: Outside.

Officer: Outside where?

EMT: In front of this house here?

B.B.: It happened there down the street.

Officer: On the street?

B.B.: Yeah.

Officer: Do you live over here?

B.B.: No.  We were on our way to her house, but it didn’t happen in her house.

Officer: But it happened down the street here?

B.B.: We had an argument and, you know, we were all, we were drinking.  I’m not even supposed to be drinking.

Officer: So, it happened in the car?

B.B.: Outside the car.

Officer: So, is he still in the area, or did he drive away? B.B.: No.  He drove way.  He left. Following that exchange, Officer Soucek asked B.B. for her Social Security number, her name, and her date of birth.

The State paused the video at the 3:04 mark, and Officer Soucek testified about B.B.’s injuries, noting her swollen face and eye and “little spots of blood and glue” where her hair had been ripped out.  He described B.B.’s clothing as disheveled, ripped, and dirty and stated that it appeared to him “that she [had been] in a fight.”

The State continued to play the body-camera video.  On the video, Officer Soucek asked B.B. for her fiancé’s name.  B.B. answered, “Garry Smith . . . two r’s.”  During this exchange, the EMTs told B.B. that she could keep talking but that they needed her to lie down on the gurney.  While the EMTs moved B.B. from her seated position in the ambulance to lie down on the gurney, Officer Soucek continued questioning B.B., and she provided him with Mr. Smith’s date of birth and the address where she lived with Mr. Smith.  Officer Soucek told his partner to “call the boss for photos.”

Elevated Heartrate

Meanwhile, the EMTs continued to provide care to B.B.  One EMT asked B.B. whether Mr. Smith had ripped out her hair, and B.B. confirmed that he had.  The other EMT told B.B. that he was going to put her on a heartrate monitor because her heart was beating so fast.

Victim States She and Mr. Smith Have No Other Children Together

Later Mr. Smith will Testify They do Have Other Children Together

After B.B. answered an EMT’s question concerning her health insurance, Officer Soucek asked B.B. how far along she was in her pregnancy.  B.B. responded that she was five months pregnant and that Mr. Smith was the father.  One EMT followed up Officer Soucek’s question by asking B.B. the due date of her baby.  She told him that her baby was due in July.  Officer Soucek then asked B.B. whether she and Mr. Smith had other children together.  B.B. responded that they did not.

Elevated Heartrate is Explained

I snorted cocaine. . . . When he beat me up, I. . . I snorted a couple lines of cocaine

After a discussion between the officers and the EMTs concerning where B.B. would be transported to receive further medical care, one EMT tried to confirm with B.B. that she had said she had been smoking and drinking; as the EMT proceeded to ask B.B. a follow-up question about her reported substance use, she shushed him.  The EMT who asked B.B. those questions looked at Officer Soucek and B.B. shushed him again.  The EMT then asked B.B. whether she had taken any drugs.  B.B., in a hushed tone, replied, “I snorted cocaine. . . . When he beat me up, I. . . I snorted a couple lines of cocaine.”  The EMT explained that the question was asked to better understand why her heart rate was so high.

Physical Assault is Explained

While one EMT prepared the equipment to monitor B.B.’s heart rate, the other EMT asked B.B. how many times she had been pregnant, and B.B. responded to his questions.  Officer Soucek then inquired more about the incident:

Officer: Can you tell me exactly what he did at the car?

B.B.: He punched me in my face and other people were trying to break it up and he pushed everybody away.  He threatened to shoot me and said he would kill me.  He was also intoxicated.  Very intoxicated. Officer: And he ripped out your hair?

B.B.: He ripped out my hair.  This is what he did to me.  He kneed me to the face, the chest, stomach. The EMT who had prepared the heart-rate-monitoring equipment interrupted B.B. to connect the equipment to her, but he informed B.B. that she could keep talking to Officer Soucek.  The officer then continued questioning B.B.: Officer: He kneed you in the stomach?

B.B.: Yes.

EMT: You’re feeling no movement from the baby, right? B.B.: No movement.  And it was moving until this incident happened

Ambulance Transports Victim to the Hospital

The State played the body-camera video until the end of this exchange, stopping it at the 6:42 mark.  The State did not play the remainder of the video for “judicial economy” reasons.  The remainder of the video shows the EMTs continuing to provide B.B. with medical care and Officer Soucek asking B.B. for a phone number where he could reach her.  Officer Soucek left the ambulance to speak with B.B.’s family member who had called 9-1-1, telling her that B.B.’s assailant had “beat her up pretty good.”  As the ambulance drove away, Officer Soucek’s partner informed him that their boss was coming to the scene to take photographs but that since the ambulance had left, they would all meet at the hospital.  At trial, Officer Soucek confirmed that his body-camera video was a fair and accurate depiction of what he saw that night.

DV Report was Completed at the Hospital

Officer Soucek testified that he and his supervisor met B.B. at the hospital to take photographs for “the domestic violence part of the report.”  Over Mr. Smith’s objection, the State asked Officer Soucek whether B.B. had “indicated on the body cam footage that [Mr. Smith had] threatened to kill her, threatened to shoot her,” to which Officer Soucek replied, “Yes.”  Officer Soucek further testified, again over Mr. Smith’s objection, that B.B. had told him that Mr. Smith possessed a weapon and that Mr. Smith had assaulted her previously.

Trial Court Determines that the Victim’s Statements were an Excited Utterance

At the close of the evidence, Mr. Smith’s counsel again objected to admission of the body-camera video into evidence, on the ground it violated Mr. Smith’s right to confrontation.  The trial court overruled the objection, explaining that B.B.’s statements on the video were nontestimonial and were being “admitted under an excited utterance hearsay exception.”

Mr. Smith Testifies to Infidelity but Not Assault

Mr. Smith testified in his own defense at trial.  Regarding the March 21, 2020 incident, he denied hitting B.B.  He maintained that when he left home that night, B.B. was “fine.”  And he suggested that B.B. had accused him of attacking her as a means of getting back at him because she thought he had cheated on her.

Mr. Smith Testifies that He and the Victim have Children in Common

During cross-examination, Mr. Smith acknowledged that he and B.B. had children together.  Mr. Smith testified, “We say we married because we been together so long.  We been together since 2002.”

Trial Court Found Mr. Smith Guilty

At the trial’s conclusion, the court found Mr. Smith guilty as charged and sentenced him accordingly.

Eighth District Court of Appeals Decision

Mr. Smith appealed his convictions to the Eighth District.  2023-Ohio-603, ¶ 71 (8th Dist.).  He argued that the admission of Officer Soucek’s body-camera video into evidence violated his right to confront witnesses against him and that the statements made in the video were inadmissible hearsay.  Mr. Smith also challenged the manifest weight of the evidence of his conviction.

State argued that the statements captured on the body-camera video were admissible as present-sense impressions or as excited utterances.

The State argued that B.B.’s statements captured on Officer Soucek’s body-camera video should be considered nontestimonial and admissible hearsay because they were made during a police interrogation under circumstances that indicated that the primary purpose of the interrogation was to respond to an ongoing emergency.  The State argued that the statements captured on the body-camera video were admissible as present-sense impressions or as excited utterances.

The appellate court thus concluded that the admission of all B.B.’s statements that were captured on the body-camera video violated Mr. Smith’s confrontation rights.

The appellate court concluded that the totality of the circumstances surrounding Officer Soucek’s interrogation of B.B. demonstrated that the primary purpose of B.B.’s statements to the police—statements in which B.B. identified Mr. Smith as her assailant and described what he had done to her—was to provide an account of the assault that had allegedly occurred (i.e., to document past events for purposes of a later criminal investigation or prosecution) and that the statements were therefore testimonial. Id. at ¶ 93.  The appellate court thus concluded that the admission of all B.B.’s statements that were captured on the body-camera video violated Mr. Smith’s confrontation rights.  Id. at ¶ 101.

Eighth District Overturned Mr. Smith’s Conviction

Because its decision regarding Mr. Smith’s confrontation-rights challenge was dispositive, the court of appeals did not consider Mr. Smith’s challenge to the trial court’s admission of B.B.’s statements on hearsay grounds or his challenge regarding the weight of the evidence for the March 2020 offenses. 2020-Ohio-603 at ¶ 112 (8th Dist.).  The court of appeals reversed the trial court’s judgment as to the March 2020 incident, vacated Mr. Smith’s convictions related to that incident, and remanded the case to the trial court for a new trial on the charges in Cuyahoga C.P. No. CR-20-651674-A.  2020-Ohio-603 at ¶ 143 (8th Dist.).

The State moved for reconsideration and en banc consideration.  The Eighth District denied the State’s motions.

Supreme Court of Ohio Analysis

Established Case Law

We consider whether the admission at Mr. Smith’s criminal trial of B.B.’s statements made to the EMTs and to Officer Soucek as captured on Officer Soucek’s body-camera video violated Mr. Smith’s rights under the Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution.  We review this issue of law de novo.  See State v. McKelton, 2016-Ohio-5735, ¶ 172.

Sixth Amendment Confrontation Clause

[T]he accused shall enjoy…

The Sixth Amendment provides that “[I]n all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right . . . to be confronted with the witnesses against him.”  In Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004), the United States Supreme Court explained that the key question for determining whether a Confrontation Clause violation has occurred is whether an out-of-court statement is “testimonial.”  Id. at 59, 68.  If a statement is testimonial, its admission into evidence will violate the defendant’s right to confrontation if the defendant does not have an opportunity to cross-examine the declarant.  Id. at 53-56.

Established Case Law – Ongoing Emergency

To determine whether a statement is testimonial, courts must look to post-Crawford decisions to ascertain whether the statement bears indicia of certain factors that would make it testimonial.  “Statements are nontestimonial when made in the course of police interrogation under circumstances objectively indicating that the primary purpose of the interrogation is to enable police assistance to meet an ongoing emergency.”  Davis v. Washington, 547 U.S. 813, 822 (2006).  Statements are “testimonial when the circumstances objectively indicate that there is no such ongoing emergency, and that the primary purpose of the interrogation is to establish or prove past events potentially relevant to later criminal prosecution.”  Id.  For example, the primary purpose of a testimonial statement is to create an out-of-court substitute for trial testimony.  Ohio v. Clark, 576 U.S. 237, 245 (2015).  That primary purpose must be measured objectively by the trial court, accounting for the perspectives of the interrogator and the declarant.  Michigan v. Bryant, 562 U.S. 344, 367-368 (2011).

When Does the Threat of a DV Suspect Returning to the Scene End?

The most important factor in informing the primary purpose of an interrogation in a domestic-violence case is whether the statement was made during an ongoing emergency, i.e., whether there was a continuing threat to the victim.  See id. at 363.  This is because domestic-violence cases “often have a narrower zone of potential victims than cases involving threats to public safety.”  Id.  A conversation that begins as an interrogation to determine the need for emergency services may evolve into a testimonial statement once the purpose of rendering emergency assistance has been achieved.  Davis at 828.

Examining two domestic-violence cases in Davis, the United States Supreme Court held that the statements the victim in Davis made to police during a 9-1-1 call were nontestimonial on several grounds, including that the victim “was ‘speaking about events as they were actually happening, rather than “describ[ing] past events,”’ that there was an ongoing emergency, that the ‘elicited statements were necessary to be able to resolve the present emergency,’ and that the statements were not formal.”  (Emphasis and brackets added in Davis.)  Bryant at 356-357, quoting Davis at 827, quoting Lilly v. Virginia, 527 U.S. 116, 137 (1999) (plurality opinion).  And in Indiana v. Hammon, the second domestic-violence case resolved in Davis, the Supreme Court held that statements the victim made to police from inside her home while her abuser was still present but was relegated to another room were “‘part of an investigation into possibly criminal past conduct.’”  Bryant at 357, quoting Davis at 829.  The Supreme Court found that there was “‘no emergency in progress,’” because the officer questioning the victim “‘was not seeking to determine . . . “what is happening,” but rather “what happened.”‘”  Id., quoting Davis at 830.  Because the victim’s statements “‘were neither a cry for help nor the provision of information enabling officers immediately to end a threatening situation,’” the Supreme Court held that those statements were testimonial.  Id., quoting Davis at 832.

And in examining a case concerning a mortally wounded victim in Bryant, the United States Supreme Court reiterated the importance of ascertaining whether the statements were made during an ongoing emergency: “The existence of an ongoing emergency is relevant to determining the primary purpose of the interrogation because an emergency focuses the participants on something other than ‘prov[ing] past events potentially relevant to later criminal prosecution’” (brackets added in Bryant), id., 562 U.S. at 361, quoting Davis, 547 U.S. at 822.  The Court emphasized that the existence of an ongoing emergency must be “objectively assessed from the perspectives of the parties to the interrogation at the time” and “not with the benefit of hindsight.”  Id. at 361, fn. 8.

Formality of the Interview … er … Interrogation

Another factor that should be considered is the degree of formality of the interrogation.  Id. at 366.  The Supreme Court noted that the questioning in Bryant occurred in a public area before emergency services arrived, as opposed to at police headquarters.  Id.  “The informality suggests that the interrogators’ primary purpose was simply to address what they perceived to be an ongoing emergency, and the circumstances lacked any formality that would have alerted [the witness] to or focused him on the possible future prosecutorial use of his statements.”  Id. at {¶ 39} Additionally, courts should consider the “statements and actions of both the declarant and interrogators.”  Id. at 367.  The interaction between the interrogators and the witness provides insight into how the witness believes his or her statements will be used.

Thus, “when a court must determine whether the Confrontation Clause bars the admission of a statement at trial, it should determine the ‘primary purpose of the interrogation’ by objectively evaluating the statements and actions of the parties to the encounter, in light of the circumstances in which the interrogation occurs.”  Bryant,562 U.S. at 370.

B.B.’s Statements to Officer Soucek Were Testimonial

To properly analyze the Confrontation Clause issue presented here, we must look at the situation from both Officer Soucek’s and B.B.’s perspectives to determine whether the primary purpose of the officer’s interrogation of the victim was to enable police to respond to an ongoing emergency.  See Bryant at 361, fn. 8 (“The existence of an ongoing emergency must be objectively assessed from the perspective of the parties to the interrogation at the time, not with the benefit of hindsight.”)  Reviewing the facts of this case from Officer Soucek’s perspective, we find no evidence of an ongoing emergency when B.B. was responding to Officer Soucek’s questions.

What is the definition of an Interrogation? – In criminal law, the process of questions propounded by police to person arrested or suspect to seek solution of crime.  Blacks Law Dictionary, 818 (6th Ed., 1990)

What is the definition of an Interview? – A meeting at which information is obtained from a person. Merriam Webster’s School Dictionary, 502 (2004)

Supreme Court of Ohio Concludes the Victim was Interrogated

Officer Soucek testified at trial that he had received a dispatch call to respond to a female who had been assaulted and that “as [he] arrived on the scene, the female was already being escorted into the EMS wagon.”  Additionally, Officer Soucek’s body camera captured a witness explaining to Officer Soucek’s partner that she had “called EMS because [B.B.] came on [her] doorstep.”  The body-camera video captured a relatively calm scene with one witness speaking to Officer Soucek’s partner outside the ambulance and two EMTs walking with a woman to an ambulance; there was no shouting, arguing, or overall commotion.  See Davis, 547 U.S. at 830.  So before his interrogation of B.B. began, Officer Soucek (1) knew from his dispatcher that a female had been assaulted, (2) heard from a witness that the victim had arrived at the 9-1-1 caller’s home already battered, and (3) observed the victim walk with EMTs to the ambulance where she began receiving medical care.  An objective assessment of this information demonstrates that Officer Soucek knew that any active threat against the victim, B.B., had been eliminated and that he was investigating a situation in which a female had been assaulted.

Supreme Court of Ohio Again Concludes that the Suspect Will Not Return to the Scene

It is true that “[A]n assessment of whether an emergency that threatens the police and public is ongoing cannot narrowly focus on whether the threat solely to the first victim has been neutralized because the threat to the first responders and public may continue,” Bryant, 562 U.S. at 363.  And generally, such an assessment could not have occurred until Officer Soucek ascertained what had happened to B.B.  However, Officer Soucek’s approach to interrogating B.B. confirms that he did not believe that he was responding to an ongoing emergency.

At trial, Officer Soucek testified that he “began to interview [B.B.] about the incident,” and he did so by asking, “So what happened?”  After B.B. confirmed that she had been assaulted by her fiancé, whom she later identified as Mr. Smith, Officer Soucek did not follow up with questions that would allow him to further assess the situation or determine whether Mr. Smith presented any possible threat to his own safety or the safety of others, such as by asking B.B. questions about Mr. Smith, where the incident occurred, or whether Mr. Smith had a weapon.  Instead, Officer Soucek asked B.B., “Do you live with him?”  

Supreme Court of Ohio Concludes an Officer’s Questions is the Determinative Factor Whether the Suspect will Return to the Scene

This follow-up question did nothing to establish whether Mr. Smith presented a danger to others.  And Officer Soucek did not need to eliminate Mr. Smith as an ongoing threat to B.B., because she was safe with Officer Soucek and the EMTs in the ambulance.  This question is relevant only when an officer is considering whether to pursue an arrest warrant or seek prosecution against a person, see O.R.C. §2935.09, since a person can be charged with domestic violence only if the victim is a family or household member, see O.R.C. §2919.25.  This question had no bearing, at least in this case, on whether there was an ongoing emergency.

And while Officer Soucek eventually questioned B.B. about Mr. Smith and the location of the attack, he did so only after he received information from his partner that the assault had not occurred inside the home from which B.B. had just exited.  There is no evidence in the record that Officer Soucek or his partner sought more information about Mr. Smith to ensure that he was not a threat to others.  Indeed, there is no evidence that Officer Soucek or his partner called for backup or ordered a search for Mr. Smith while B.B. was receiving medical care in the ambulance.  As demonstrated in the body-camera video, no other officers arrived on the scene, and Officer Soucek told his partner to call their supervisor only to photograph B.B.’s injuries.

Supreme Court of Ohio Presumes the Emergency is Over Upon Arrival of First Responders

The facts of this case demonstrate that Officer Soucek had information that he was responding to a female who had been assaulted and was being treated by EMTs prior to his arrival at the scene, and his actions demonstrate that he did not treat the assault on B.B. as an ongoing emergency but rather, as an investigation into past criminal conduct of B.B.’s assailant.  As the United States Supreme Court has stated, “the emergency is relevant to the ‘primary purpose of the interrogation’ because of the effect it has on the parties’ purpose, not because of its actual existence,” Bryant, 562 U.S. at 361, fn. 8.

Supreme Court of Ohio Concludes that Snorting Cocaine is Determinative Whether the Suspect will Return to the Scene

And B.B. did not treat the situation as an ongoing emergency, as demonstrated by her own statements and actions.  B.B. knew she was pregnant at the time of the incident.  She knew that Mr. Smith had hit her, ripped out her hair, then drove away, leaving her near a family member’s home.  And after the fight, B.B. snorted “a couple lines of cocaine” before her family member called 9-1-1.

The body-camera video demonstrates that B.B. sought assistance from her family member and medical attention from the EMTs before the police interrogation began inside the ambulance.  At no time does the body-camera video show B.B. actively calling for help or providing police with information that would indicate that Mr. Smith was a continued threat to her or others.  See Davis, 547 U.S. at 828-832.  And while B.B. had not informed Officer Soucek of the full extent of the situation prior to the interrogation, it is apparent that she or her family member had already discussed the situation with the EMTs, given the extent of their questions during the first few minutes of the body-camera video.

These facts demonstrate that B.B.’s purpose in answering Officer Soucek’s questions was not to aid in the officer’s response to an ongoing emergency but rather, to tell her account of the incident.

B.B. knew that Mr. Smith was not a threat to her at the time of the police interrogation.  The body-camera video shows that B.B. spoke to Officer Soucek about the incident without reservation and that she was much more hesitant to answer questions when it came to her own criminal activity: B.B. shushed an EMT when he asked her about the extent of her drug use.  B.B.’s selective disclosure of information and hesitancy to admit her own criminal activity in front of a police officer demonstrates that she had testimonial intent when she made statements to the officer concerning the assault.  See Davis at 830 (“statements [made during] an official interrogation are an obvious substitute for live testimony because they do precisely what a witness does on direct examination” [emphasis in original]).  These facts demonstrate that B.B.’s purpose in answering Officer Soucek’s questions was not to aid in the officer’s response to an ongoing emergency but rather, to tell her account of the incident.

Supreme Court of Ohio Again Confuses an Interview with an Interrogation

Additionally, the formality of the encounter between Officer Soucek and B.B. is far from the harried 9-1-1 call that was at issue in Davis.  The interaction between Officer Soucek and B.B. in this case more closely resembles the interrogation in Hammon, in which the officer interviewed the victim inside her home while she was separated from her husband, questioned her about what had happened, and had her sign a battery affidavit.  See Davis at 819-820, 830.

Supreme Court of Ohio Assumes that a Predatory Suspect will Not Attack the Victim in the Ambulance

Officer Soucek’s interrogation of B.B. was not conducted at the police station; B.B. spoke to Officer Soucek in the back of an ambulance where she was being attended by EMTs—away from any witnesses to the assault and safely away from her attacker.  And while Officer Soucek did not ask B.B. for a signed affidavit, his body camera recorded the entire exchange.  Officer Soucek’s body camera recorded him actively taking handwritten notes of B.B.’s answers.  And as discussed above, B.B. freely spoke with Officer Soucek about the incident but was hesitant to answer questions when it came to her own criminal activity.

Holding

Reviewing these facts objectively from both Officer Soucek’s and B.B.’s perspectives, and considering the formality of the interrogation, we do not find that the primary purpose of Officer Soucek’s interrogation of B.B. in the ambulance was to respond to an ongoing emergency.  Rather, the primary purpose of the interrogation was to establish or prove past events potentially relevant to later criminal prosecution of B.B.’s assailant.  We therefore conclude that B.B.’s statements to Officer Soucek captured by the officer’s body camera were testimonial in nature and that their admission into evidence at Mr. Smith’s criminal trial violated Mr. Smith’s right to confrontation.

B.B.’s Statements to the EMTs Were Nontestimonial

Officer Soucek’s body camera recorded not only B.B.’s responses to his questions but also B.B.’s responses to the EMTs’ questions concerning her medical history.  We have held that statements made for purposes of medical diagnosis and treatment are nontestimonial and that their admission into evidence at trial does not violate the Confrontation Clause.  State v. Arnold, 2010-Ohio-2742, ¶ 41.

B.B. was actively receiving medical care when her statements were captured by Officer Soucek’s body camera.  Every statement B.B. made in response to the EMTs’ questions was for the primary purpose of receiving medical care, not creating a record for use at trial.  So those statements were nontestimonial and the admission of those statements at Mr. Smith’s trial did not violate Mr. Smith’s right to confrontation.

Remanded to the Eighth District for Re-Intrepretation

We conclude that the Eighth District Court of Appeals erred in its determination that all statements made by B.B. that were captured by Officer Soucek’s body camera while B.B. was in the ambulance must be excluded on constitutional grounds.  Only those statements that B.B. made in response to Officer Soucek’s questions should have been excluded on that basis.  We therefore reverse the judgment of the court of appeals as it pertains to Mr. Smith’s convictions for the March 21, 2020 incident.

Because this appeal is limited solely to the Confrontation Clause issue, we decline to address admissibility issues pertaining to B.B.’s statements under the Ohio Rules of Evidence.  Instead, we remand the case to the Eighth District.  On remand, the court of appeals must determine whether any of the statements B.B. made in response to the EMTs’ questions (i.e., the nontestimonial statements) were inadmissible hearsay, thereby addressing Mr. Smith’s second assignment of error.  After making that determination, the Eighth District must revisit its harmless-error determination and address Mr. Smith’s third, fourth, and fifth assignments of error relating to the March 21, 2020 incident, as necessary.

Information for this article was obtained from State v. Smith, 2024 – Ohio – 5745 and my attendance at the Supreme Court of Ohio oral argument on July 24, 2024.

State v. Smith, 2024 – Ohio – 5745 was issued by the Supreme Court of Ohio on December 10, 2024 and is binding throughout the State of Ohio.

Lessons Learned:

  1. Body Camera Video Cannot be Used without the Victim Appearing in Court – The Supreme Court of Ohio determined that body camera video could not be used in this case without direct testimony from the victim and therefore Mr. Smith’s Domestic Violence conviction is overturned, with a caveat. The caveat is that now the trial court must determine if the victim’s statements can be admissible as hearsay under the Ohio Rules of Evidence.  But Mr. Smith’s conviction should not hinge on the Ohio Rules of Evidence, rather, his conviction should have been upheld based on either the Present Sense Impression or Excited Utterance hearsay exceptions. This holding is based on the Sixth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution Confrontation Clause.
  2. Court Concludes that the Fleeing Suspect was not a Threat to Return to the Scene to Cause the Victim More Harm – I estimate that I conservatively responded to over 2,500 domestic violence calls for service in eighteen years in patrol. I further estimate that dozens of times that I was at scene that a suspect whom had fled the scene, returned.  In this case the Supreme Court of Ohio matter-of-factly assumes that since the victim was inside an ambulance and the police were at scene that there was no threat of the suspect returning to harm the victim.  As the court opined “And Officer Soucek did not need to eliminate Mr. Smith as an ongoing threat to B.B., because she was safe with Officer Soucek and the EMTs in the ambulance.”.  This sentence is one of a few that demonstrate the court’s conclusory belief that predatory domestic violence suspects will not return to the scene to cause the victim further harm.
  3. Are Victims Interrogated or Interviewed? Throughout the holding the Supreme Court of Ohio explains that Cleveland Police Officer Brian Soucek ‘interrogated’ the victim. Based on his interrogation of the victim that prompted application of established case law based on interrogations.  I do not believe victims are interrogated, rather, they are interviewed.

What is the definition of an Interrogation? – In criminal law, the process of questions propounded by police to person arrested or suspect to seek solution of crime.  Blacks Law Dictionary, 818 (6th Ed., 1990)

What is the definition of an Interview? – A meeting at which information is obtained from a person. Merriam Webster’s School Dictionary, 502 (2004)

Clearly the victim admitted to violating the Drug Abuse O.R.C. §2925.11 when she stated “I snorted cocaine. . . . When he beat me up, I. . . I snorted a couple lines of cocaine.”.  However, at no time did Officer Soucek question the victim as to this admitted felony.  Therefore, the victim was interviewed NOT interrogated.

  1. Hardest Job in America – Law enforcement may help courts include statements made at scene by asking victims if they believe that the suspect may return ‘in the moment’. This may then guide the court to determine that the victims’ statements will comport Hearsay exceptions of either Present Sense Impression or Excited Utterance.

Does your agency train on Domestic Violence?

Don’t fail your training.

Don’t let your training fail you!

Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!

Robert H. Meader Esq.