Here, officers observed Mr. Wright enter a hotel known for drug trafficking and exit carrying a suitcase while rapidly looking around at his surroundings. While being tailed by a marked police cruiser, Mr. Wright began driving evasively. When stopped by officers, Mr. Wright was immediately combative and refused several lawful orders to exit from his car. These factors, combined with Kylo’s alert, provided a sufficient probability that Mr. Wright’s vehicle contained contraband, therefore establishing probable cause to search his vehicle.

 

State v. Wright

2024 – Ohio – 1763

First District Appellate Court

Hamilton County, Ohio

May 8, 2024

 

The Stop, Sniff, and Search of Mr. Wright’s Car

In June 2022, Hamilton County Deputy Jeremy Beckwith was conducting surveillance on those who came and went from a hotel known for use by drug traffickers. Dep. Beckwith saw an individual, later identified as Mr. Travis Wright, arrive in a vehicle and enter the hotel, empty handed. Ten to fifteen minutes later, Mr. Wright exited from the hotel carrying a suitcase.

Head on a Swivel … and a Suitcase

Mr. Wright caught Dep. Beckwith’s attention because Mr. Wright was “what we call head on a swivel, looking left, looking right, kind of suspicious about his surroundings.” Dep. Beckwith testified that this behavior, combined with Mr. Wright’s entering the hotel empty-handed and leaving with a suitcase, made the situation especially odd. Mr. Wright placed the suitcase in the trunk of his vehicle and drove off. Dep. Beckwith radioed other officers in the area about Mr. Wright’s behavior and a description of the car.

Deputy VonHertsenberg Ordered Mr. Wright Out of His Car

Deputy Steven VonHertsenberg was in the area in a marked police cruiser and heard Dep. Beckwith’s call over the radio. Dep. VonHertsenberg located Mr. Wright’s vehicle and began tailing him. After Dep. VonHertsenberg started the tail, Mr. Wright began driving in an evasive manner, making several left turns, and quickly speeding up. Mr. Wright committed a marked-lanes violation for which Dep. VonHertsenberg initiated a traffic stop. When Dep. VonHertsenberg turned on his cruiser’s overhead lights, Mr. Wright’s vehicle did not stop immediately and continued for 100 feet into a cul-de-sac at the end of the street before stopping. As Dep. VonHertsenberg approached Mr. Wright’s vehicle, Mr. Wright’s window was only down about an inch, which concerned Dep. VonHertsenberg because it is easier to hear and to ensure safety when a window is down. The officer ordered Mr. Wright out of the car, but Mr. Wright did not comply. Instead, Mr. Wright argued with Dep. VonHertsenberg for more than a minute, continuing to refuse to exit from his vehicle. Once Dep. VonHertsenberg threatened to break Mr. Wright’s window, Mr. Wright exited from his car.

Sgt. Lange and Kylo the Cannabis-Trained Canine

Fewer than two minutes after Dep. VonHertsenberg stopped Mr. Wright, Sergeant Anthony Lange arrived with Kylo, a certified drug-detection dog. Kylo is trained to detect and alert to the odor of marijuana, cocaine, heroin, and methamphetamine. But Kylo is unable to distinguish between medical marijuana, hemp products, and illegal forms of marijuana because all three products come from variations of the same plant, cannabis. Kylo alerts in the same manner for all substances he is trained to detect. Sgt. Lange testified that while Kylo has never alerted to what turned out to be medical marijuana, Kylo has alerted to hemp.

Kylo Alerted to Nineteen Pounds of Marijuana

Sgt. Lange brought Kylo to Mr. Wright’s vehicle, gave Kylo a command to search, and Kylo alerted at the driver’s-side door of Mr. Wright’s car. Sgt. Lange searched Mr. Wright’s vehicle with Dep. VonHertsenberg and found nineteen pounds of marijuana in the suitcase in the trunk of the vehicle.

Trafficking in Marijuana

The state charged Mr. Wright with one count of trafficking in marijuana in violation of O.R.C. §2925.03(A)(2) and one count of possession of marijuana in violation of O.R.C. §2925.11(A).

Cannabis law in June 2022

In 2016, Ohio legalized medical marijuana, codified in O.R.C. §3796. It is now legal under Ohio law for those holding a medical-marijuana card to possess a 90-day supply of medical marijuana. O.R.C. §3796.22. Medical marijuana is “marijuana that is cultivated, processed, dispensed, tested, possessed, or used for a medical purpose.” R.C. 3796.01(A)(2).  It remains illegal under federal law to possess marijuana. 21 U.S.C. §844(a); 21 U.S.C. §812; 21 C.F.R. §1308.11(d).

In 2019, Ohio legalized the possession of hemp, a low-THC variation of cannabis.  In 2018, Congress passed the Agriculture Improvement Act, which removed hemp from the list of federally-controlled substances.  Accordingly, cannabis meeting the definition of “hemp” is legal under both Ohio and federal law. 

Cannabis Consumption for a Medical Purpose

The difference between medical marijuana and illegal marijuana under Ohio law is that medical marijuana is “produced, cultivated, processed, dispensed, tested, possessed, or used for a medical purpose.” And the difference between “marijuana” and “hemp” under Ohio and federal law is the level of THC present in the cannabis plant.

Was the sniff a search?

Don’t be Tardy …

In his first assignment of error, Mr. Wright argues that, because Kylo could alert to both legal and illegal cannabis products, his sniff was a search under the Fourth Amendment. Therefore, he asserts, police were required to have probable cause before they could use a drug-detecting dog. The state responds that Mr. Wright waived this issue by not raising it before the trial court.

Mr. Wright did not argue that Kylo’s sniff constituted a search under the Fourth Amendment before the trial court. Instead, Mr. Wright’s motion and argument at the suppression hearing asserted that Kylo’s alert did not establish probable cause. Given that Mr. Wright did not raise this argument below, he has waived it on appeal. We overrule Mr. Wright’s first assignment of error.

Was Kylo’s Alert Probable Cause?

In his second assignment of error, Mr. Wright argues that Kylo’s alert did not establish probable cause to search Mr. Wright’s vehicle because Kylo’s training did not allow him to differentiate between legal and illegal cannabis products. Mr. Wright argues that, but for the alert, the officers would not have searched his vehicle, and therefore, the existence of probable cause hinges on the reliability of the alert. The state argues that Kylo’s alert established probable cause. Further, the state asserts that other factors established probable cause to search Mr. Wright’s vehicle.

Established Case Law – Canine Alert

Here, two lines of cases are relevant to our probable-cause analysis.  First, an alert from a trained drug-detection dog will ordinarily establish probable cause to search a lawfully-detained vehicle. State v. Lopez, 2006-Ohio-2091. The alert provides probable cause to search the entire vehicle, including any packages or compartments that “ ‘may logically conceal the object of the search.’ ” State v. Gray, 2023 – Ohio – 338.

Established Case Law – The Smell of Probable Cause

Thank you OSHP Sgt. Jeff Greene!

Second, an officer develops probable cause to search the passenger compartment of a vehicle where the officer detects an odor that the officer is qualified to identify, and that odor is “a distinctive odor that undoubtably identifies a forbidden substance.” State v. Moore, 90 Ohio St.3d at 49 (2000). In Moore, the Supreme Court of Ohio held that “[I]f the smell of marijuana, as detected by a person who is qualified to recognize the odor, is the sole circumstance, this is sufficient to establish probable cause. There need be no additional factors to corroborate the suspicion of the presence of marijuana.” Id. at 50. While Moore dealt with a human sniff rather than a dog sniff, this rationale is applicable to dog sniffs to the extent that it discusses the formation of probable cause based on the perception of the odor of contraband.

Mr. Wright argues that Moore is no longer good law because it predates Ohio’s legalization of medical marijuana and hemp products. He accordingly asks us to depart from Moore and hold that an alert from a dog trained to detect marijuana does not provide probable cause to search.

Kylo’s Alert Probability – Far from Zero

At the time of this stop, most forms of marijuana were illegal in Ohio. While the legalization of medical marijuana and hemp products may have lowered the likelihood that Kylo was alerting to contraband, that likelihood was far from zero.

Holding

We hold that in determining whether police officers had probable cause to search a vehicle, courts may consider a trained drug-detecting police dog’s sniff and alert.

Kylo’s Alert was part of the Totality of the Circumstances

We need not decide whether Kylo’s alert, standing alone, provided probable cause to search. The officers relied on other factors to determine that they had probable cause to believe they would find contraband in Mr. Wright’s vehicle. While the change in the law after Moore may mean that the odor of cannabis no longer “undoubtably” identifies a forbidden substance, the Fourth Amendment requires consideration of the totality of the circumstances.

How Travis’ Behaviors Established the Totality of the Circumstances

Here, officers observed Mr. Wright enter a hotel known for drug trafficking and exit carrying a suitcase while rapidly looking around at his surroundings. While being tailed by a marked police cruiser, Mr. Wright began driving evasively. When stopped by officers, Mr. Wright was immediately combative and refused several lawful orders to exit from his car. These factors, combined with Kylo’s alert, provided a sufficient probability that Mr. Wright’s vehicle contained contraband, therefore establishing probable cause to search his vehicle. We overrule Mr. Wright’s second assignment of error.

Conclusion

For the foregoing reasons, we overrule Mr. Wright’s two assignments of error and affirm the trial court’s judgment.

Information for this article was obtained from State v. Wright, 2024 – Ohio – 1763.

State v. Wright, 2024 – Ohio – 1763 was issued by the First District Appellate Court on May 8, 2024 and is binding in Hamilton County, Ohio.

Lessons Learned:

  1. Thank you Sgt. Jeff Greene! On Sunday February 28, 1999 OSHP Sgt. Jeff Greene stopped Mr. Chris Moore for running a red light on S.R. 33. Upon first approach Mr. Moore rolled down his window and Sgt. Greene smelled freshly burnt marijuana.  This led to a search of Mr. Moore’s vehicle and the discovery of drug paraphernalia.  Moore was charged with running the red light, Drug Abuse and Drug Paraphernalia.  Mr. Moore was convicted and appealed.  On Wednesday September 20, 2000 the Supreme Court of Ohio issued State v. Moore, 90 Ohio St.3d at 49 (2000) and held “[I]f the smell of marijuana, as detected by a person who is qualified to recognize the odor, is the sole circumstance, this is sufficient to establish probable cause. There need be no additional factors to corroborate the suspicion of the presence of marijuana.” Id. at 50.
  2. Medical Marijuana – On September 8, 2016 the State of Ohio legalized Medical Marijuana that complicates a cannabis-trained canine alert, since a vehicle occupant can legally possess marijuana. The question is whether a canine-alert after Medical Marijuana established probable cause.  In this case, the court specifically addressed a cannabis – trained canine establishes probable cause “We need not decide whether Kylo’s alert, standing alone, provided probable cause to search.”. However, the First District Appellate Court held that probable cause was established based on the totality of circumstances; “The officers relied on other factors to determine that they had probable cause to believe they would find contraband in Mr. Wright’s vehicle. While the change in the law after Moore may mean that the odor of cannabis no longer “undoubtably” identifies a forbidden substance, the Fourth Amendment requires consideration of the totality of the circumstances.”.
  3. Recreational Marijuana – On Tuesday November 7, 2023 Ohio’s Issue Two passed that legalized recreational marijuana that is codified as O.R.C. §3780. So where does this leave cannabis-trained canine alerts and probable cause?  Certainly, as stated in this case, Wright, a canine alert can be one part of establishing probable cause. A cannabis-trained canine can also be used to establish probable cause for an alert if an officer asks if the vehicle occupants have any cannabis in the vehicle.  If the driver/occupants say no, that begins to open the door for use of cannabis-trained canine.  R.C. §3780.01 (A)(3) establishes that an Adult Use Consumer is someone who is twenty-one years or older.  So if an officer stops a vehicle and all of the occupants are under twenty-one then a cannabis-trained canine may be used.  Note: Canine handlers should consult with their legal advisor and/or county prosecutor before utilizing a cannabis-trained canine in the manner described herein.
  4. Pre-Sent Arms! Hamilton County Deputy Jeremy Beckwith, Deputy Steven VonHertsenberg, Sergeant Anthony Lange and of course Canine Kylo should all be highly commended for working in concert to investigate, charge and convict Mr. Travis Wright. Well done!

Does your agency train on Canines and Probable Cause?

Don’t fail your training.

Don’t let your training fail you!

Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!

Robert H. Meader Esq.