We find that the officers were justified in subjecting Mr. Zaller to a protective search for weapons based on his agitated and erratic behavior. Mr. Zaller repeatedly refused to comply with the officers’ demands, was argumentative, and was evasive in his conduct. Circumstances such as these have been found sufficient to justify a protective search.

State v. Zaller

2024 – Ohio – 2323

Eleventh District Appellate Court

Trumbull County, Ohio

June 17, 2024

Improper Turn – Traffic Stop – Metallic Object on Passenger Floorboard

On Friday February 18, 2022, Officer William Fowler of the Warren City Police Department observed a yellow Cobalt traveling eastbound on Porter Street onto Elm Road. The yellow Cobalt, driven by Mr. Matthew Zaller, made an improper turn by bypassing the curb lane and turning directly into the center lane in violation of the Warren City ordinances. Officer Fowler initiated a traffic stop of Mr. Zaller’s vehicle. Officer Fowler approached the vehicle and advised the driver and sole occupant, later identified as Mr. Zaller, of the reason for the stop. Officer Fowler also requested Mr. Zaller’s driver’s license. During this initial exchange, Officer Fowler observed a metallic object with a black bottom on the passenger side floorboard, which Officer Fowler believed to be a magazine for a firearm.

Warren Police Officer William Fowler observed a yellow Chevy Cobalt make an illegal turn at Elm Road and Porter Street.  Officer Fowler stopped the vehicle driven by Mr. Matthew Zaller and discovered Mr. Zaller was unlawfully carrying a firearm.  Did Officer Fowler establish criminal activity  to extend the traffic stop or did the criminal activity evaporate?

Request for Back Up AND a Request to Leave

Due to this observation, Officer Fowler requested another police unit to respond to the stop. Officer Fowler also ran Mr. Zaller’s personal information through dispatch. Dispatch advised Officer Fowler that Mr. Zaller had a valid license and did not have any active warrants for his arrest. Dispatch also did not advise Officer Fowler that Mr. Zaller had an active license to carry a concealed firearm. Officer Fowler testified that dispatch typically provides this information to officers during a traffic stop. Officer Fowler then re-approached Mr. Zaller and requested his proof of insurance. Officer Fowler testified that Mr. Zaller started to get agitated and began requesting to leave.

Zaller is Ordered Out of the Cobalt and Gets Agitated

Approximately two minutes into the stop, Officer Wilson arrived on scene to assist. Officer Fowler signaled to Officer Wilson over the top of the vehicle to indicate he believed there was a firearm in the vehicle. Officer Fowler then instructed Mr. Zaller to step out of the vehicle. Mr. Zaller became increasingly more agitated and he refused Officer Fowler’s request to exit the vehicle. Officer Fowler testified that based upon his training and experience, Mr. Zaller’s refusal to comply with his orders and agitated state, indicated to him that there was something inside the vehicle. Mr. Zaller’s actions caused Officer Fowler to be concerned with officer safety.

Metallic Object is a Lighter but Agitated Behavior Delays the Traffic Stop

As Officer Wilson started to explain that Mr. Zaller’s failure to cooperate could result in his arrest, Officer Fowler realized that the item he believed to be a firearm magazine was a lighter. However, based upon Mr. Zaller’s behavior, Officer Fowler continued to request that Mr. Zaller step out of the vehicle for officer safety.

Evasive Behavior Results in a Pat Down and a Firearm

When Mr. Zaller exited the vehicle, he started toward the front of his vehicle and away from officers. Alarmed by this sudden movement, Officer Fowler asked Mr. Zaller to walk toward the officers. Officer Fowler testified that Mr. Zaller’s conduct of walking away towards the front of the vehicle was not normal behavior for a typical traffic stop. Based on the behavior of Mr. Zaller and concerns for officer safety, officers detained Mr. Zaller. Officer Fowler informed Mr. Zaller that he would be conducting a pat down. However, prior to Officer Fowler beginning the pat down, Mr. Zaller voluntarily stated that he had a firearm in his pocket.

Indicted

On March 30, 2022, the Trumbull County Grand Jury returned a five-count Indictment against Mr. Zaller, charging him with three counts of Carrying Concealed Weapons, felonies of the fourth degree in violation of O.R.C. §2923.12(A)(2) and (F)(1), and two counts of Improperly Handling Firearms in a Motor Vehicle, felonies of the fourth degree in violation of O.R.C. §2923.16(B) and (I).

Motion to Suppress is Denied

On November 14, 2022, the trial court denied Mr. Zaller’s Motion to Suppress.

No Contest

On January 23, 2023, Mr. Zaller entered a plea of “no contest” to three counts of Attempted Carrying Concealed Weapons, felonies of the fifth degree in violation of O.R.C. §2923.02 and O.R.C. §2923.12(A)(2) and (F)(1).

Sentenced

On April 12, 2023, the trial court sentenced Mr. Zaller to five years of community control for each count to be served concurrently and to be subject to the general supervision of the Adult Probation Department under any terms and conditions they deem appropriate.

Appeal

On April 24, 2023, Mr. Zaller filed a Notice of Appeal. On appeal, he raises the following assignment of error: “The trial court erred and violated appellant’s constitutional rights by denying appellant’s motion to suppress evidence.”

Mr. Zaller’s Appeal is Based on Evaporating Criminal Activity

On appeal, Mr. Zaller argues the police officers lacked constitutional authority to order him to exit his vehicle and to conduct a pat-down search: “In the case at bar, any reasonably articula[ble] suspicion of criminal activity on the part of Mr. Zaller ‘evaporated’ when the arresting officers discovered that the item [thought to be a magazine] was not a weapon or related to a weapon but was rather a lighter. At that point in time, the officers had no justification to further detain Mr. Zaller and he should have been permitted to leave.” We disagree.

Established Case Law on Reasonable Suspicion

The United States Supreme Court has summarized the constitutional implications of the Fourth Amendment on traffic stops as follows:

A seizure for a traffic violation justifies a police investigation of that violation. “[A] relatively brief encounter,” a routine traffic stop is “more analogous to a so-called ‘Terry stop’ . . . than to a formal arrest.” Knowles v. Iowa, 525 U.S. 113, 117 (1998). Like a Terry stop, the tolerable duration of police inquiries in the traffic-stop context is determined by the seizure’s “mission”—to address the traffic violation that warranted the stop, Illinois v.Caballes, 543 U.S. 405, 407 (2005) and attend to related safety concerns, infra, at 1619-1620. Because addressing the infraction is the purpose of the stop, it may “last no longer than is necessary to effectuate th[at] purpose.” Ibid. See also Caballes, 543 U.S., at 407. Authority for the seizure thus ends when tasks tied to the traffic infraction are—or reasonably should have been—completed. United States v. Sharpe, 470 U.S. 675, 685 (1985) (in determining the reasonable duration of a stop, “it [is] appropriate to examine whether the police diligently pursued [the] investigation”). Rodriguez v. United States, 575 U.S. 348, 354, 135 S.Ct. 1609, 191 L.Ed.2d 492 (2015).

Mr. Zaller’s Behaviors Applied to Established Case Law

In the present case, Mr. Zaller was stopped for a traffic violation. In the course of advising Mr. Zaller of the reason for the stop and obtaining his license, Officer Fowler observed what he thought was “a magazine for a pistol” on the passenger side floorboard. Believing there was “possibly a firearm in the vehicle,” Officer Fowler requested another unit and then proceeded to run Mr. Zaller’s driver’s license number. Officer Fowler testified that dispatch “didn’t advise me that [Mr. Zaller] had a CCW permit or anything like that, which typically if somebody does they would tell us right away.” Officer Fowler returned to the vehicle, asked for Mr. Zaller’s insurance, and advised him that he was waiting for dispatch. Mr. Zaller began to question why he would have to wait and asserted that he had a right to leave. Officer Fowler advised that he was not finished with his business and Mr. Zaller asked for his ticket so he could leave. As Officer Wilson approached the vehicle, Officer Fowler asked Mr. Zaller to step out. This was approximately three minutes after Officer Fowler’s initial approach. Officer Fowler’s reasonable belief that there was a firearm in the vehicle justified the minimal extension of the stop to await Officer Wilson’s arrival before ordering Mr. Zaller out of the vehicle. “Police officers may take steps that are ‘reasonably necessary to protect their personal safety and to maintain the status quo during the course of [a] stop.’” State v. Hairston, 2019-Ohio-1622. Moreover, where “the officer [has] ascertained reasonably articulable facts giving rise to a suspicion of criminal activity, the officer may then further detain and implement a more in-depth investigation of the individual.” State v. Robinette, 80 Ohio St.3d 234, 241, (1997). Any delay in completing the stop after the arrival of Officer Wilson was the result of Mr. Zaller’s own conduct.

Thank you Harry!

We further note that nothing more was needed for Officer Fowler to order Mr. Zaller to exit the vehicle. There is no question about Officer Fowler’s authority to do so. “Under Pennsylvania v. Mimms, 434 U.S. 106, 111, (1977), fn. 6, ‘once a motor vehicle has been lawfully detained for a traffic violation, the police officers may order the driver to get out of the vehicle without violating the Fourth Amendment’s proscription of unreasonable searches and seizures.’” State v. Jackson, 2022-Ohio-4365. “An officer needs no justification beyond that necessary for the initial stop to order a driver from the car.” Id.; Robinette at 239 (“the officers’ subjective motivation for continuing the detention is irrelevant”).

How Mr. Zaller Created Additional Reasonable Suspicion

When asked to step out of the vehicle, Mr. Zaller refused. The officers opened both doors of the vehicle and Officer Fowler placed a hand on Mr. Zaller’s forearm. Mr. Zaller raised his hands (so that Officer Fowler released his forearm) but did not exit the vehicle. At this point, Officer Fowler realized that what he thought was a gun magazine was in fact a lighter for propane torches. Officer Fowler explained to Mr. Zaller that this was why he ordered him to step out. Mr. Zaller continued to argue. Officer Wilson explained to Mr. Zaller that Officer Fowler had the right to order him out of the vehicle and, if he continued to refuse, he could be arrested for failing to comply. Mr. Zaller then exited the vehicle. Officer Fowler asked if he had any knives on him or anything like that. Mr. Zaller replied, “no,” and asserted that he was not going to be searched. As he said this, he took a couple of steps toward the front of his vehicle and turned around. He then walked toward the back of his vehicle. Officer Wilson took his arm, told him to calm down, and advised him that Officer Fowler could pat him down for weapons “[be]cause the way you’re acting right now.” Mr. Zaller became compliant and advised the officers that there was a gun in his jacket pocket.

Conclusion and Holding

We find that the officers were justified in subjecting Mr. Zaller to a protective search for weapons based on his agitated and erratic behavior. Mr. Zaller repeatedly refused to comply with the officers’ demands, was argumentative, and was evasive in his conduct. Circumstances such as these have been found sufficient to justify a protective search.

Criminal Activity Did Not Evaporate

The sole assignment of error is without merit.

Information for this article was obtained from State v. Zaller, 2024 – Ohio – 2323.

State v. Zaller, 2024 – Ohio – 2323 was issued by the Eleventh District Appellate Court and is binding in the following Ohio Counties: Ashtabula, Geauga, Lake, Portage and Trumbull.

Lessons Learned:

  1. Traffic Stop to Reasonable Suspicion to Probable Cause – Mr.Zaller’s legal argument that once Officer Fowler observed the metallic object was a propane lighter rather than a firearm magazine, the criminal inquiry beyond the improper turn should have ended. If Mr. Zaller had remained calm, not undertaken an obstinate attitude to exit the Cobalt and then walked away from the officers, his argument would have much more merit.  However, Mr. Zaller’s own behaviors taken in a totality of the circumstances established additional Reasonable Suspicion that criminal activity was afoot.  Both Officer Fowler and Officer Wilson evaluated these behaviors and moved in for a pat down.  Once Mr. Zaller admitted to carrying a concealed firearm the officers lawfully arrested him.
  2. Did Mr. Zaller’s Criminal Activity Evaporate? The case on point to determine how to analyze if Reasonable Suspicion was established is U.S. v. Sharpe, 470 U.S. 675 (1985). In that case the U.S. Supreme Court held “[The U.S. Supreme Court] imposes no rigid time limit limitation on Terry Stops; 1) [W]hether the officer’s action was justified at its inception and whether it was reasonably related in scope to the circumstances which justified the interference in the first place, 2) [C]ourts must also consider the purposes to be served by the stop as well as the time reasonably needed to effectuate those purposes 3) [W]hether the police diligently pursed a means of investigation that was likely to confirm or dispel their suspicions quickly, during which time it was necessary to detain the defendant”.  U.S. v. Sharpe, 470 U.S. 675, 685 (1985).  In this case Mr. Zaller transformed himself from a suspect into a defendant by refusing to get out of his Cobalt and walking away from the officers. These behaviors are the opposite of evaporating criminal activity.
  3. Thank you Harry! When a car is lawfully stopped, law enforcement can order the driver out of the car based on Pennsylvania v. Mimms, 434 U.S. 106 (1977). On Monday September 7, 1970, Labor Day, Philadelphia Police Officers John Kurtz and Lester Milby observed Mr. Harry Mimms driving west on Baltimore Avenue in an automobile with expired tags.  Upon stopping Mr. Mimms, Officer Kurtz ordered Mr. Mimms to step out of the car and he observed a large bulge on his hip under his jacket, patted him down and retrieved a .38 caliber handgun.  Officer Milby then frisked the passenger, Mr. Clayton Morrison and retrieved a .32 caliber revolver.  Seven years later on Monday December 5, 1977, the U.S. Supreme Court held “[O]nce a motor vehicle has been lawfully detained for a traffic violation, the police officers may order the driver to get out of the vehicle without violating the Fourth Amendment’s proscription of unreasonable searches and seizures.”.
  4. Pre-Sent Arms! Warren Police Officer Fowler and Officer Wilson should both be highly commended for their investigation and arrest of Mr. Zaller.  Well done officers!

Does your agency train on Traffic Stops?

Don’t fail your training.

Don’t let your training fail you!

Be safe, smart and objectively reasonable!

Robert H. Meader Esq.